I'd say he's just about laid it out for ya. Think about your terrain (I live in very brushy steep wet country in the Pacific NW). Will a lot of junk hung on the outside just get snagged? Does everything want to be inside, and the pack somewhat "streamlined?"
If you want versatility on a modest budget, an external frame like the Camp Trails Freighter lets you pull the bag off, and lash just about anything against that folding shelf.
Personal preference counts, along with intended use. My sister spends more time in the hills than I do, and she likes internal -- also better for ski touring because weight is closer. But she travels light.
My daughter used the same internal frame "convertible" by Eagle Creek in Search And Rescue, that she did going to China a few years earlier. I lean toward internal frame or small external (like ALICE) for a bugout bag. How will you carry your BOB, and does appearance matter? (Some folks don't want a military-looking pack visible in their vehicles.)
I have always favored external frame for any significant weight and for the ventilation. I do NOT like anything hung onto the outside, so I go for a big bag on that frame. But as I get older, I'm working at avoiding that "significant weight," if at all possible.
It may be that you are talking about two different packs for two different missions. As with personal arms, it's nice if you can try out several before laying down your hard-earned long green.
Caveat emptor