If you're interested in FUN I'd recommend the .44 Mag.
If you're interested in real fun, I'd recommend the Ruger Super Red Hawk and a 7.5" barrel.
Magnum revolvers in general and Magnum revolvers with short barrels in particular are not really very much fun to shoot (unless you're one of those guys who is very recoil insensitive). A good friend of mine just bought a collector's grade S&W Model 29 with a 4" barrel. He's been shooting .44 Specials through it occassionally. He has put TWO (2) rounds of .44 Mag through it. That was enough. OTOH, I can shoot a full box of 50 hot rounds through my Super Red Hawk revolver and actually have fun doing it. What is the big difference? Two things; 1) The Super Red Hawk has a specially designed grip which does away with the steel back strap that recoils back into the web of you hand. 2) The Super Red Hawk with a 7.5" barrel and a 4x Leupold scope weighs probably a good 50% more than my friend's Smith; better grip + more weight = more fun.
You could buy the .454 Casull. Keep in mind that this gun generates 50% more power than the .44 Mag. What do you think it will be like to shoot that? Fun? Maybe. And how often? Do you really want to plunk down several hundred dollars on a gun that will be fun to shoot once or twice? It's your money.