User Panel
Quoted:
I think a non-P90 PCC would be a blast. How difficult is it to reload, or does anyone even make dies for it? View Quote |
|
https://www.ar15.com/forums/handguns/-22-TCM9R-and-TCM-glock-Lots-of-great-info-added-/13-184906/&page=10#i2208107 A shortened .22 TCM running 35 grainers, fitting in standard 9x19mm length mags... Amusing to realize we're back in 6.5 vs 6.8 all over again... @garred8787 |
|
Quoted:
I must be out of touch. I thought the AP wasn't for sale to civilians. I guess my info is out of date. View Quote Solution, but one of the copper solids I've been testing for quite some time. They are copper and not defined on a federal level as AP. (AP definition is by construction not what it can or can't penetrate). Since they are pointy, small, and fast, they will poke everything just as well as SS190, except when you get into thicker UHMWPE or steel IIIA (which is pretty rare) |
|
Quoted:
https://i.imgur.com/XQfvUzOl.jpg https://www.ar15.com/forums/handguns/-22-TCM9R-and-TCM-glock-Lots-of-great-info-added-/13-184906/&page=10#i2208107 A shortened .22 TCM running 35 grainers, fitting in standard 9x19mm length mags... Amusing to realize we're back in 6.5 vs 6.8 all over again... @garred8787 View Quote |
|
Quoted: Post the video links then. Here's the issue I have w/ the 40 grn from the 5.7x28mm & .22 TCM - you're not cracking the 2100 fps threshold from a pistol. So you have a really good hollowpoint that say expands all the way to .355" from .22", and penetrates 18" or beyond. That's .380 FMJ performance out of a full size handgun. We've got to get over 2100 fps - by going to 35 grn or below - to get rifle like wounding from a pistol. 5.7x28mm already does that, and there's now at least 5 magazines, 3 of em for pistols, that will run the cartridge. Get a .22 TCM variant, which is starting w/ a larger case capacity, and then we have nearly 120 years worth of magazines to feed from. View Quote MK2 Shot 1Weight: 33.8gr length: .300" Min: .280" Max: .381" Avg: .330" MK2 Shot 2 Weight: 36.2gr length: .272" Min: .307" Max: .404" Avg: .355" |
|
|
@10mm_
Have you done or can you do a ballistic gel test between the R&R 37 gr expanding and 37 gr fragmenting? |
|
|
Quoted:
The 5.7 was ok in the p90 , but in the pistol it looses too much velocity to be considered very a effective round IMHO. Sure it is low recoil and accurate, but if its so damn good why hasn't it been adopted by the military and law enforcement? And even in a P90 it is no better than the 5.56x45 in an M4. Just because Ruger makes a budget priced gun for it doesn't make it a good choice . In the end the 9mm and the 45acp will be what most of the military , public and LEO will be buying and using . The 9mm and 45acp have stood the test of time continue to dominate the 5.7 will end up being a flash in the pan and never sell in any meaningful volume. Wait a couple of years and when sales tank and buy the Ruger pistol and 5.7 ammo at a big discount when CDNN blows it out . View Quote |
|
I have said it before.
The 5.7x28 and 22tcm for me are ideal for what I want. A fast flat trajectory round with minimal recoil this I can shoot out to 100 yards. It would be the ideal truck gun that could be used from coyotes to personnel protection. My ideal pistol would be a maxim 9 integrally suppressed pistol with a rmr on it. Keep thinking maybe a 22tcmR barrel could be made for maxim 9 |
|
Quoted:
What's the longest bullet he'll be able to run without sacrificing case capacity/velocity? View Quote With the .860" case I can run bullets that have a ~.300 nose length (from the start of the ogive) and bullets up to about .600" seem to not impact velocity too bad according to QL. Weight obviously does play a role on velocity. A 40gr FBHP estimates 2100 ft/sec, the 34gr pictured estimates 2300, 30's 2450, and a long 25gr (.600" reeds custom ammo) 2550. These are all calculated off 55k psi from a 5.2" barrel. Dropping to 9mm +p+ pressures drops about 100 ft/sec across the board. I'm going to load up some more ammo this evening to work the load up to at least the 9mm +p+ threshold and hope to shoot them tomorrow. |
|
Quoted:
This place conducted quite a bit of testing on the 5.7 loads using 10% calibrated organic gel 2017 Joint Testing This was their follow up testing with the use of body armor: 2019 Armor and More testing View Quote |
|
Quoted: Not sure why I didn't get the mention notification on this thread. With the .860" case I can run bullets that have a ~.300 nose length (from the start of the ogive) and bullets up to about .600" seem to not impact velocity too bad according to QL. Weight obviously does play a role on velocity. A 40gr FBHP estimates 2100 ft/sec, the 34gr pictured estimates 2300, 30's 2450, and a long 25gr (.600" reeds custom ammo) 2550. These are all calculated off 55k psi from a 5.2" barrel. Dropping to 9mm +p+ pressures drops about 100 ft/sec across the board. I'm going to load up some more ammo this evening to work the load up to at least the 9mm +p+ threshold and hope to shoot them tomorrow. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
This place conducted quite a bit of testing on the 5.7 loads using 10% calibrated organic gel 2017 Joint Testing This was their follow up testing with the use of body armor: 2019 Armor and More testing View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Anyone have the fbi protocol test results? 2017 Joint Testing This was their follow up testing with the use of body armor: 2019 Armor and More testing Whish all these youtube videos used organic gel. Clear gel is a bane on all of us. |
|
My observation with 5.7 rounds has been sometimes it penetrated and in some cases most times it penetrates. When it does not penetrate it seems as it does not transfer much energy. This could be quality of test material.
The marketing issue for the 5.7 might be that there are other lightweight projectile loads in .355 to .451 caliber that utilize hyper per caliber velocities that provide similar or in some cases improved penetration VS the 5.7. |
|
|
Quoted:
Kind of strange that the Better Business Bureau has had ZERO COMPLAINTS lodged against Elite! Maybe it’s because they INVESTIGATE every complaint? View Quote Or maybe because they throw lawyers at every complaint, including people who posted things about them on ARFCOM. What's your angle? |
|
Quoted: Or maybe because they throw lawyers at every complaint, including people who posted things about them on ARFCOM. What's your angle? View Quote Its rather strange that there aren’t complaints posted over on fnforum.net or fivesevenforum.com on Elite Ammunition or Jay Wolf considering that that’s where people are going to “hang out” that purchase his products. There was an infamous blowup at Elite Ammunition quite a few years ago that Jay had to deal with involving a partner. I don’t know the details as I wasn’t an owner of anything 5.7x28 at the time. As to my angle? B44T SHITS in every thread related to 5.7x28 and touts how great the obscure .22TCM is. In addition he lists disinformation....Black Fang is discontinued, Elite has sold their brass manufacturing machinery, etc. |
|
Quoted:
Is there a place that can provide ready to use organic gel? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: Not too shabby Whish all these youtube videos used organic gel. Clear gel is a bane on all of us. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. |
|
Quoted: Unfortunately no. It's a pain in the butt to use but actually gives usable data. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. View Quote I seem to recall the organic stuff being very temperature sensitive and has to be calibrated with a bb at a certain speed and shot in a very narrow window of time from that calibration to be valid data. |
|
Quoted: You don’t stay in business as long as Elite Ammunition has been around screwing customers. All of my dealings have been fine. B44T listed a thread that’s OVER ten years old and a single Yelp complaint. Its rather strange that there aren’t complaints posted over on fnforum.net or fivesevenforum.com on Elite Ammunition or Jay Wolf considering that that’s where people are going to “hang out” that purchase his products. There was an infamous blowup at Elite Ammunition quite a few years ago that Jay had to deal with involving a partner. I don’t know the details as I wasn’t an owner of anything 5.7x28 at the time. As to my angle? B44T SHITS in every thread related to 5.7x28 and touts how great the obscure .22TCM is. In addition he lists disinformation....Black Fang is discontinued, Elite has sold their brass manufacturing machinery, etc. View Quote Nobody is disparaging their product, just the douchebagery between the husband and wife. Yeah when you threaten to sue everyone that criticizes you, then people tend to bite their lip. |
|
Quoted: Please tell me more about how businesses operate Nobody is disparaging their product, just the douchebagery between the husband and wife. Yeah when you threaten to sue everyone that criticizes you, then people tend to bite their lip. View Quote I will continue to use their products. |
|
|
Quoted:
The only person bitching about people exercising their right to buy elsewhere is you buddy View Quote This is a TECH FORUM. This is getting way off topic and being I believe Jay Wolf is a member and it could be considered a personal attack, reported in the Moderators Forum! |
|
Quoted:
Wonder what that brassfetcher guy charges. I seem to recall the organic stuff being very temperature sensitive and has to be calibrated with a bb at a certain speed and shot in a very narrow window of time from that calibration to be valid data. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: Unfortunately no. It's a pain in the butt to use but actually gives usable data. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. I seem to recall the organic stuff being very temperature sensitive and has to be calibrated with a bb at a certain speed and shot in a very narrow window of time from that calibration to be valid data. Although its not "calibrated" its "validated". Clear gel could have a bb go exactly as far as you need a bb to go in organic gel but it doesn't mean the results would even be close. |
|
|
Quoted:
You don’t stay in business as long as Elite Ammunition has been around screwing customers. All of my dealings have been fine. B44T listed a thread that’s OVER ten years old and a single Yelp complaint. Its rather strange that there aren’t complaints posted over on fnforum.net or fivesevenforum.com on Elite Ammunition or Jay Wolf considering that that’s where people are going to “hang out” that purchase his products. There was an infamous blowup at Elite Ammunition quite a few years ago that Jay had to deal with involving a partner. I don’t know the details as I wasn’t an owner of anything 5.7x28 at the time. As to my angle? B44T SHITS in every thread related to 5.7x28 and touts how great the obscure .22TCM is. In addition he lists disinformation....Black Fang is discontinued, Elite has sold their brass manufacturing machinery, etc. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: Or maybe because they throw lawyers at every complaint, including people who posted things about them on ARFCOM. What's your angle? Its rather strange that there aren’t complaints posted over on fnforum.net or fivesevenforum.com on Elite Ammunition or Jay Wolf considering that that’s where people are going to “hang out” that purchase his products. There was an infamous blowup at Elite Ammunition quite a few years ago that Jay had to deal with involving a partner. I don’t know the details as I wasn’t an owner of anything 5.7x28 at the time. As to my angle? B44T SHITS in every thread related to 5.7x28 and touts how great the obscure .22TCM is. In addition he lists disinformation....Black Fang is discontinued, Elite has sold their brass manufacturing machinery, etc. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Gentleman, I apologize for his trolling behavior and his following me here. |
|
Quoted:
Wonder what that brassfetcher guy charges. I seem to recall the organic stuff being very temperature sensitive and has to be calibrated with a bb at a certain speed and shot in a very narrow window of time from that calibration to be valid data. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: Unfortunately no. It's a pain in the butt to use but actually gives usable data. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. I seem to recall the organic stuff being very temperature sensitive and has to be calibrated with a bb at a certain speed and shot in a very narrow window of time from that calibration to be valid data. |
|
I hope for a 5.7 craze. I'm hoping some solid, scientific gel tests will occur and convince me that 5.7 really is the best thing ever.
|
|
Quoted: Wrong again 3 X , as usual. Please return to GD. This is a technical forum. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Gentleman, I apologize for his trolling behavior and his following me here. View Quote You need a 24 hr “time out”. |
|
ok i'm so upset with myself!!!! just powered up the chrono and went to log my data and I pressed the wrong button and deleted everything.
I do remember some of the velocities. 5.2gr were in the mid 2000's, 5.4gr was upper 2200's with one that read 2400 on the nose then things nose bombed. Here's a quick measurement rundown. Fresh resized brass measures .373", 4.5gr measured .3745, 5gr measured .3745-.375, 5.2gr .3755, 5.4gr .3755 now all of these plunk in and out of the barrel without issue. Now is where things changed 5.6gr had erratic velocities from 1700-2100 cases took effort to remove from the chamber and will not drop back into the barrel. case expansion was .377" and weirdly 2/3's of the body of the case has this measurement but the web is still .3755". I shot 1 5.8gr which was 2108 ft/sec and it got stuck in the barrel. I didn't want to damage the extractor so I waited till I got home and used a vice grip to get it out. body diameter was .3775" and web .376" now an intersting thing about this case is it had a deeper firing pin indent and it looked as it walked to the edge of the primer as if it maybe was trying to tilt the barrel down during the hit? The primers on all but the 1 mentioned looked the same and they have less primer flow than factory 9mm ammo, likely due to the rifle primer thickness? All of the loads were starting to cycle the slide with the factory spring. Looks like I need to go a touch slower on the powder or concentrate on the 5.2-5.4gr load. |
|
Quoted:
Sounds good. Going to have to lighten the springs? View Quote It was advised to me by a fellow on Glock Talk who plays with these bottleneck cartridges to work up with the stiffer spring to prevent a timing issue that could turn bad (ie. gun try's to unlock with too much pressure in the case still) I may try AA#9 or maybe load some at 5.3gr and 5.4gr and test them again and see if i'm happy there. I mean 2200 is still no slouch with 34gr bullet from a handgun. I'm awaiting his response and guidance before I pursue further. I may be @ the 55k threshold early because i'm running rifle primers in such a tiny case. |
|
Quoted: Unfortunately no. It's a pain in the butt to use but actually gives usable data. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. View Quote How about ballistic soap. Is there any validity to the data collected from it? |
|
Quoted: As usual, you can’t get a grasp of reality. If you could simply READ you’d realize that I posted BEFORE you did. You need a 24 hr “time out”. View Quote OP, I think it's just taken some time for people to warm up to something as radical as the 5.7. Hopefully we will get a lot more offerings from here. Don't care for HP ammo though, unless it is able to penetrate 12" |
|
Quoted: Never seen an adult want so badly to be hall monitor OP, I think it's just taken some time for people to warm up to something as radical as the 5.7. Hopefully we will get a lot more offerings from here. Don't care for HP ammo though, unless it is able to penetrate 12" View Quote AND, one of the videos I linked to shows Buffman testing R&R Weaponry’s R37.X hollow point going PAST 12”. |
|
Quoted:
Speer has recently come out with a 5.7x28 hollow point self-defense round. I'm not sure if it's on the shelves but expected price is going to be just under $1.00/rnd. Definitely NOT for plinking, that's what American Eagle is for. https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Speer-Gold-Dot-5.7x28mm-660x290.png I can't find any info on energy levels, so I'm going with the same as SS197 https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2020/01/01/speer-gold-dot-5-7x28mm-ammunition/ View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Speer has recently come out with a 5.7x28 hollow point self-defense round. I'm not sure if it's on the shelves but expected price is going to be just under $1.00/rnd. Definitely NOT for plinking, that's what American Eagle is for. https://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Speer-Gold-Dot-5.7x28mm-660x290.png I can't find any info on energy levels, so I'm going with the same as SS197 The bullet weight of Speer Gold Dot 5.7x28mm ammunition is 40 grains. It will be sold in 50-round boxes with an MSRP of $51.95 – that’s a little over a dollar per round MSRP. That may sound quite expensive compared to the 5.7 ammunition offerings from other large manufacturers currently available on the market, however, bear in mind, that with the Speer Gold Dot we are talking about defensive high-end ammunition and considering the company’s ability to design outstanding self-defense ammo, their new 5.7x28mm cartridges may become the ultimate defensive round for those of you who trust their lives to the guns chambered in this caliber. |
|
How about a couple of you guys just agreeing to ignore each other?
|
|
Quoted:
ok i'm so upset with myself!!!! just powered up the chrono and went to log my data and I pressed the wrong button and deleted everything. I do remember some of the velocities. 5.2gr were in the mid 2000's, 5.4gr was upper 2200's with one that read 2400 on the nose then things nose bombed. Here's a quick measurement rundown. Fresh resized brass measures .373", 4.5gr measured .3745, 5gr measured .3745-.375, 5.2gr .3755, 5.4gr .3755 now all of these plunk in and out of the barrel without issue. Now is where things changed 5.6gr had erratic velocities from 1700-2100 cases took effort to remove from the chamber and will not drop back into the barrel. case expansion was .377" and weirdly 2/3's of the body of the case has this measurement but the web is still .3755". I shot 1 5.8gr which was 2108 ft/sec and it got stuck in the barrel. I didn't want to damage the extractor so I waited till I got home and used a vice grip to get it out. body diameter was .3775" and web .376" now an intersting thing about this case is it had a deeper firing pin indent and it looked as it walked to the edge of the primer as if it maybe was trying to tilt the barrel down during the hit? The primers on all but the 1 mentioned looked the same and they have less primer flow than factory 9mm ammo, likely due to the rifle primer thickness? All of the loads were starting to cycle the slide with the factory spring. Looks like I need to go a touch slower on the powder or concentrate on the 5.2-5.4gr load. View Quote |
|
Quoted: I'd like to suggest looking for a milder primer. View Quote Currently running a cci 400. Whats another primer that can handle 55k psi but maybe not as hot? ETA: Nevermind found it. so it sounds like Rem 6 1/2 is the one to try.....and I think I remember that now that I think of it. seem's someone told me it was designed for small cartridges like the 22 Hornet...Dir!! This getting old stuff sucks |
|
Quoted: I used to have a primer cup thickness and brisance(sp?) chart but I can't seem to find it. Currently running a cci 400. Whats another primer that can handle 55k psi but maybe not as hot? ETA: Nevermind found it. so it sounds like Rem 6 1/2 is the one to try.....and I think I remember that now that I think of it. seem's someone told me it was designed for small cartridges like the 22 Hornet...Dir!! This getting old stuff sucks View Quote ETA: It would be worth asking around to see what primers gives the most consistent start pressures and muzzle velocities in the .221 Fireball and .22 Remington Jet |
|
Quoted: Remington 6 1/2 are just right for the case capacity of the .22 Hornet. I believe the primers cups may be a little softer than regular small rifle primers. FWIW the .22 Hornet is a low pressure round by today's standards. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Yeah that temperature window that is has to maintain would basically mean early spring, late fall, and winter shooting only for gel testing. How about ballistic soap. Is there any validity to the data collected from it? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: Unfortunately no. It's a pain in the butt to use but actually gives usable data. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. How about ballistic soap. Is there any validity to the data collected from it? They have an entire laboratory dedicated JUST to making gel blocks (organic). Climate controlled and everything. If they don't shoot the ammo through organic gel they use....water. I'm not privilege to the details of course, but just plain ole water is used for ballistics testing to supplement real organic gel in a production setting. |
|
Quoted:
My buddy recently got a job at one of the major ammo manufacturers that produces ammo for both civilian and military. They have an entire laboratory dedicated JUST to making gel blocks (organic). Climate controlled and everything. If they don't shoot the ammo through organic gel they use....water. I'm not privilege to the details of course, but just plain ole water is used for ballistics testing to supplement real organic gel in a production setting. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted: Unfortunately no. It's a pain in the butt to use but actually gives usable data. Clear gel just makes pretty pictures and gives people a false sense of reality. How about ballistic soap. Is there any validity to the data collected from it? They have an entire laboratory dedicated JUST to making gel blocks (organic). Climate controlled and everything. If they don't shoot the ammo through organic gel they use....water. I'm not privilege to the details of course, but just plain ole water is used for ballistics testing to supplement real organic gel in a production setting. |
|
|
Quoted: If you were paying attention, you would have realized that I am a “Hall Monitor” when I stated this thread was being reported in the Moderators Forum. AND, one of the videos I linked to shows Buffman testing R&R Weaponry’s R37.X hollow point going PAST 12”. View Quote Nobody is arguing that, non sequitur. It was a general statement as some 5.7 HPs and even FMJ fail to regularly penetrate 12" Thanks for proving my point on trying to squash any criticism of Elite BTW |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.