Posted: 8/11/2005 7:31:36 PM EDT
| Is the compensated version of the G19 that much different than the non-compensated version? |
My thoughts exactly.
|
I have shot most all of the "C" models. While it certainly does make a difference in the 9mm, the greater benefit of the "C" models is in the .40 and .357 sig. So, to answer the question, in my opinion, a slight diffrence in the 9mm. |
|
"Recoil" is very subjective. What I think is light may feel heavy to you, or vice versa. I have fired only one C model, but it happens it was a G19C. Shooting it "side by side' with my standard G19 and the same ammo, I honestly could not tell any appreciable difference. The guy who owns it, however, swears he can...go figure. I seem to recall someone here saying once that they took some grief from the owners of an indoor range because they did not allow comped pistols there? Since I have no indoor range available, I would not know if that is a standard thing for such places or not...if you plan to shoot on one maybe you should check. |
Yep, sounds like utter bullshit to me, Aim4MyHead. No personal experience whatsoever, and totally disrespectful. 
|
|
I've never owned a G19c but i have put several rounds through them. I guess it all depends on what sort of application the pistol is needed for. I had the oppurtunity to speak with a member of the Israeli special forces a few months back. We spoke about a lot things . One thing he did mention is how they use Glock G19c. I asked why the C and he said for double taps. 9mm isn't a round that produces any sort of recoil that would require compensating to control but, if you wanted to make sure your 2nd shot is VERY close to your first i can see why one might want to compensate it. Of course how you stand while shooting plays a big role in how much recovery time you have in between each shot. J |
|
I am not convinced that the compensator cuts will have a significant negative effect on velocity. I have seen some chronograph results that show an increase in certain pistols! That said, I wouldn't bother with the C version of the G19 unless you have one offered to you at a smoking good deal. If that is the case then go for it. The G19 is a great 9mm, comped or not. I have a "regular" version that I frequently carry and I think the G19 and the G20 are Glock's best products. |
|
With the "C" models you can easily swap to a stock barrel for competitions or carry if you need/want to, but you can’t swap the other way. Bullet weight is one of the biggest influences with the “C” barrels. With lighter bullets generally the comp works better because they are loaded with faster powders. You loose about 50' per inch in velocity of barrel length so with the "C" it would be about 60’-70’ per sec loss. The "C" models do nothing for recoil, when you pull the trigger the recoil is still there. What you do loose is muzzle rise thus recovery is faster for follow up shots. I have several "C" models and even though they are louder they are still fun to shoot. I have shot in complete darkness and muzzle "flash" is a non issue until about the 6-7th rd and at that point I did see spots but could still find my night sights. If you ever get a chance to shoot a G18 verses a G18C you will really notice the difference. JM $0.02 worth 
|
|
Go with the NON-compensated pistol if you intend to use it for personal defense...the ported pistol, when used for defense, has way too many drawbacks which really can't be reasoned away. For gaming and general goofing-off go ported...pistols for serious use should have only ONE hole at the end of the barrel... |
|
lightfighter.net/groupee/forums/a/tpc/f/1931084651/m/7391074351 I personally dont care for the "C" models, IMO. -Justin |
|
I HAVE a Glock 19C and shoot it a lot. It shoots great and I always use earplugs anyways so noise isn't much of a big deal to me. However, I have tried some "point" style shooting where the gun was slightly lower that my line of sight, and the blast was VERY noticable! It hits you in the face and without eye protection it would seem kinda hazardous. I would not consider the 19C to be a good gun for carry/home defense, so I am currently looking for a regular (maybe even a slightly used) G19 barrel to "drop in" as a replacement for that reason. Just my $0.02 Tex78 |