AR Sponsor
Posted: 11/11/2015 12:18:51 AM EDT
|
I just realized something. The only reason I use Q-tips to clean my AR-15 is because the Marine Corps told me to. Is there a more efficient way to do this? P.S. Happy birthday to all the fellow Marines out there. Semper Fidelis. |
|
Quoted:
I just realized something. The only reason I use Q-tips to clean my AR-15 is because the Marine Corps told me to. Is there a more efficient way to do this? P.S. Happy birthday to all the fellow Marines out there. Semper Fidelis. These are great. Cotton Q-tips of every size on long bamboo handles. I use them for all things AR cleaning. 325 for about 8 bucks. http://www.ebay.com/itm/Innovative-Products-Of-America-9010-325-Piece-Swab-eez-Industrial-Strength-Swabs-/391314357607?hash=item5b1c273d67:g:BKYAAOxy3zNSocw5 |
|
Why?
And, the Marien Corps never told you to. Idiots in the Marine Corps told you to. I challenge you to find one official Marien Corps publication that says you need to clean a rifle with cotton swabs. Learn where the carbon builds up, remove it. Identify mud and outside nastiness, clean it. Lube it. One of the bigger challenges in making weapons military proof is making them durable enough to handle military "maintenance." One of the endless challenges of those in the weapons fielding and sustainment biz is fighting the persistent cultural derp that comes up with things like cleaning weapons with cotton swabs - because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage. |
|
^ I use these and regular cotton swabs all the time on my firearms. |
|
This for the chamber |
|
Johnson & Johnson swabs are way better than Q-tip.
J&J has much firmer cotton, and the stem is PLASTIC, whereas Q-tip is paper. You can bend the J&J plastic stem to a 90-degree angle to get into the barrel extension, where all the crud likes to hide. Try bending a Q-tip like that, and the stem will snap. I get the J&J's at CVS. |
|
Quoted: Johnson & Johnson swabs are way better than Q-tip. J&J has much firmer cotton, and the stem is PLASTIC, whereas Q-tip is paper. You can bend the J&J plastic stem to a 90-degree angle to get into the barrel extension, where all the crud likes to hide. Try bending a Q-tip like that, and the stem will snap. I get the J&J's at CVS. Now THAT is what I'm looking for!
|
|
Quoted:
I just realized something. The only reason I use Q-tips to clean my AR-15 is because the Marine Corps told me to. Is there a more efficient way to do this? P.S. Happy birthday to all the fellow Marines out there. Semper Fidelis. I do the same thing and never served, it just makes good sense. |
|
Hmmm, all I ever see at the local stores are Q-Tips. No CVS closeby. I do bend my q-tips without issues. 90 degrees and a little bit beyond.
Searching RiteAid's site, I see they have some plastic version. Since it's the store brand, not sure how good quality the cotton is..... 
|
|
Quoted:
I just realized something. The only reason I use Q-tips to clean my AR-15 is because the Marine Corps told me to. Is there a more efficient way to do this? P.S. Happy birthday to all the fellow Marines out there. Semper Fidelis. yes. Spray it out with non chlorinated brake cleaner every few hundred, thousands rounds or so. Relube. Punch barrel when accuracy drops off. Happy birthday to you as well, Marine. |
|
IMO, Q-tips (regardless of brand) are outdated and a waste. While fairly cheap, and they do work, I prefer Swab-Its. Just like a q-tip, but instead of cotton it is a semi-firm foam head that you can wash and reuse. I got a pack at Midway USA that had a couple different sizes, and they make the same thing for the bore too if you're interested. I haven't noticed any degradation from using CLP (I use the break-free stuff from Safariland). I've only had them for about a year, so take it for what you want.
|
|
Quoted:
IMO, Q-tips (regardless of brand) are outdated and a waste. While fairly cheap, and they do work, I prefer Swab-Its. Just like a q-tip, but instead of cotton it is a semi-firm foam head that you can wash and reuse. I got a pack at Midway USA that had a couple different sizes, and they make the same thing for the bore too if you're interested. I haven't noticed any degradation from using CLP (I use the break-free stuff from Safariland). I've only had them for about a year, so take it for what you want. Non chlorinated brake cleaner. |
|
Quoted:
Why? And, the Marien Corps never told you to. Idiots in the Marine Corps told you to. One of the endless challenges of those in the weapons fielding and sustainment biz is fighting the persistent cultural derp that comes up with things like cleaning weapons with cotton swabs - because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage. That's a little harsh. I've yet to see Q-tips damage a weapon. |
|
"because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage"
Not "it leads directly to flat-out damage." Reading comprehension, folks. Q-tip cleaning is related to other, more damaging "tips" that get passed on from Joe to Joe, and for which there is good reason they aren't in any manuals. Worst I've ever seen with Q-tips is getting a cotton swap stuck in the gas key - a simple fix if noticed and not left unaddressed. |
|
Quoted: That's a little harsh. I've yet to see Q-tips damage a weapon. Quoted: Quoted: Why? And, the Marien Corps never told you to. Idiots in the Marine Corps told you to. One of the endless challenges of those in the weapons fielding and sustainment biz is fighting the persistent cultural derp that comes up with things like cleaning weapons with cotton swabs - because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage. That's a little harsh. I've yet to see Q-tips damage a weapon. |
|
Quoted: IMO, Q-tips (regardless of brand) are outdated and a waste. While fairly cheap, and they do work, I prefer Swab-Its. Just like a q-tip, but instead of cotton it is a semi-firm foam head that you can wash and reuse. I got a pack at Midway USA that had a couple different sizes, and they make the same thing for the bore too if you're interested. I haven't noticed any degradation from using CLP (I use the break-free stuff from Safariland). I've only had them for about a year, so take it for what you want. I just placed an order for Bore Tips and Swab Its from Midway. I guess I'll find out if Slip 2000 Carbon Killer degrades them. |
|
Quoted:
And I'm still trying to figure out why our armory gave them to us. Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Why? And, the Marien Corps never told you to. Idiots in the Marine Corps told you to. One of the endless challenges of those in the weapons fielding and sustainment biz is fighting the persistent cultural derp that comes up with things like cleaning weapons with cotton swabs - because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage. That's a little harsh. I've yet to see Q-tips damage a weapon. Because the Armory wanted the things super duper white glove clean. I've seen armories give out much worse - I've seen all purpose cleaner used on rifles. But the "Marine Corps" only officially says to do what's in here: http://www.ar15.com/content/webPDF/TM9-1005-319-10.pdf |
|
Quoted:
Because the Armory wanted the things super duper white glove clean. I've seen armories give out much worse - I've seen all purpose cleaner used on rifles. But the "Marine Corps" only officially says to do what's in here: http://www.ar15.com/content/webPDF/TM9-1005-319-10.pdf Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Why? And, the Marien Corps never told you to. Idiots in the Marine Corps told you to. One of the endless challenges of those in the weapons fielding and sustainment biz is fighting the persistent cultural derp that comes up with things like cleaning weapons with cotton swabs - because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage. That's a little harsh. I've yet to see Q-tips damage a weapon. Because the Armory wanted the things super duper white glove clean. I've seen armories give out much worse - I've seen all purpose cleaner used on rifles. But the "Marine Corps" only officially says to do what's in here: http://www.ar15.com/content/webPDF/TM9-1005-319-10.pdf TM 9-1005-319-10, dated June 2010, Work Package (WP) 0014, "Cleaning Instructions", page 00-2: 
You do also realize that the TM 9-1005-319-10 also lists CLOTH, ABRASIVE, (50 sheets), (81348), P-C-458, NSN 5350-00-221-0872, as one of the expendable service items. And, you serious think that a cotton swab will hurt the rifle? |
|
Quoted:
TM 9-1005-319-10, dated June 2010, Work Package (WP) 0014, "Cleaning Instructions", page 00-2: http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y9/lysanderxiii/Untitled_zpssdgbdmw7.png You do also realize that the TM 9-1005-319-10 also lists CLOTH, ABRASIVE, (50 sheets), (81348), P-C-458, NSN 5350-00-221-0872, as one of the expendable service items. And, you serious think that a cotton swab will hurt the rifle? Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Why? And, the Marien Corps never told you to. Idiots in the Marine Corps told you to. One of the endless challenges of those in the weapons fielding and sustainment biz is fighting the persistent cultural derp that comes up with things like cleaning weapons with cotton swabs - because its a symptom of a larger problem that often leads to flat-out damage. That's a little harsh. I've yet to see Q-tips damage a weapon. Because the Armory wanted the things super duper white glove clean. I've seen armories give out much worse - I've seen all purpose cleaner used on rifles. But the "Marine Corps" only officially says to do what's in here: http://www.ar15.com/content/webPDF/TM9-1005-319-10.pdf TM 9-1005-319-10, dated June 2010, Work Package (WP) 0014, "Cleaning Instructions", page 00-2: http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y9/lysanderxiii/Untitled_zpssdgbdmw7.png You do also realize that the TM 9-1005-319-10 also lists CLOTH, ABRASIVE, (50 sheets), (81348), P-C-458, NSN 5350-00-221-0872, as one of the expendable service items. And, you serious think that a cotton swab will hurt the rifle? I have never once said a cotton swab will hurt a rifle. That's absurd. |
|
I got the Swab-Its in the mail. First thing I did was take the Glock 43 apart and use them to clean up all excess EWL. They're really good at getting into the hard-to-reach areas. I was able to use the pointed tip to clean inside the slide rail and then I used the second pointed tip to precisely apply EWG inside the rail. So they allow for precise cleaning and application of grease. Very happy so far, and very good advise to get them. |
AR Sponsor