Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
AR Sponsor
2/11/2010 6:28:58 AM EDT
My first AR will be a 16-inch middy. I'm trying to decide between two (three, really) options:

1) Go cheaper, meaning a DSA 16-inch middy upper for $300 and fit it with a BCM BCG and charging handle and maybe a Troy TRX rail, for a total of under $700. Disadvantages: 1:9 twist and probably little resale value while these uppers are at these proces. Any others I am not considering?

2) Go "gooder," meaning a BCM middy upper (basic $425/hammered $525) with a BCM BCG and rail , for total upper cost of $800/$900. Advantages: 1:7 twist and good resale value. Any others I am not considering?

I shoot mostly flintlocks, so it will not see thousands of rounds. This'll go on a Mega lower I already have built. What I really want is a good, reliable shooter. I'll build a boutique AR later.
2/11/2010 7:05:37 AM EDT
[#1]
What I really want is a good, reliable shooter.


I think the extra money for the BCM is worth it.  I'm not a fan of the other dsa's.  Ran into enough issues with their 308's to turn me off to the entire brand.  
BCM is more consistent, in my opinion, than a lot of other manufacturers.  Could be wrong, but that's my opinion.
2/11/2010 7:21:25 AM EDT
[#2]
Unless you are punching out past 300 years, the 1:7 won't make any difference to you.  And that is only if you use heavy bullets.  So go #1, if you are looking for <300 yards.  

Don't worry about resale, you won't sell it later anyway.  Go cheap, buy ammo, have fun - to 300 yards.

I shoot 68 and 69gr in a 1:9 to 600 yards and they work pretty well, though I would use my 1:7 in competition.
2/11/2010 8:40:53 AM EDT
[#3]
BCM standard (not BFH) middy upper is the way to go.  If you want to save money and get the DSA then get the 1:7 Chrome Lined M4 for $325.
AR Sponsor