Quoted: A SPR or match grade AR, trying to stick to 30 or 35 pounds of torque will give you a little better accuracy. Building an SPR with of a stainless steel barrel, for instance, you should try a few barrel nuts to find which one will get you closest to 30 when tightened. Going beyond 35 pounds or so on a match grade barrel will impart forces on the bullet that would go unnoticed or be unimportant on a service grade rifle.
I'm having a hard time believing that the torque on the barrel nut has anythig to do with accuracy. I wonder if there is any hard evidence of this? I'd sure like to see it. It would seem that if this were true then there would be a difinite spec for torque - not 30 to 80 ftlbs!
Again, I'd sure like to see some documentation.
|
The USGI spec is for service rifles (30 to 80), where the accuracy gains are not significant or necessary. When tightening the barrel nut, you are applying torque 90-dregrees to the direction of bullet travel. The effects of torque are slight on the lower end, but get greater and greater with the amount of torque. After 80 pounds, you are twisting and likely damaging the upper and/or barrel extension (and barrel). It's common sense, after 80 pounds you are likely either causing damage or getting close to causing damage, adding stress to the barrel/upper interface. The more torque applied, the more stress applied. The barrel nut does not need 80 pounds of torque to secure the barrel, it might need 80 pounds to get the barrel nut notch aligned for the gas tube. Tighter is not better here. At 30-35 pounds, you have adequately secured the barrel into the upper. Anything after that is about function (gas tube alignment), not barrel retention or accuracy.
Again, the effects are slight, but cummulative. 30-35 pounds on the barrel alone might not be noticed, but add to that a few other thnigs and you can get a noticable difference. Add a good quality stainless steel barrel and you'll notice a big improvement in accuracy over a GI barrel right out of the gate (which tends to overshadow smaller potential gains elsewhere), but hit that target torque for the barrel nut and get a muzzle brake or flash hider to index properly at 5 pounds (using shims AND a crush washer, not just a crush washer) and you will have squeezed all you can out of that barrel installation.
This stuff isn't published (at least I don't think so), but it's being used out there.