Not too long ago I purchased a CMMG/DPMS Pre-ban M4A3 upper. This upper has a 16", 4150, 1/7 barrel with a 5.56 chamber, fully chrome lined chamber/bore and M4 feed ramps.
See the project details here ->
www.ar15.com/forums/topic.html?b=3&f=12&t=162739I just finished doing a reliability test on this upper using 5 types of ammo. I fired 200 rounds each of the following ammo.
1.Federal XM193
2.Hot Shot SS109
3.Winchester Q3131a
4.South African M1A3
5.Wolf 55 gr
I let the barrel cool off in between ammo changes also there was no cleaning during the test. I also fired Wolf last to see how it performs when it was already dirty.
Results - 1000 rounds fired with
NO malfunctions and that nasty Wolf ammo just flew right through!
The chamber seems truly 5.56 and mil-spec! The only thing different I have is the Wolff extra power extractor spring which I also run in my other carbine upper.
Afterwards without cleaning it, and using sand bags I shot 50 rounds of Black Hills remanufactured 77 gr. I was pleseantly surprised that shooting 1 MOA 5 shot groups was not difficult and if I did my part I was even able to get several 3/4 MOA groups. I have no doubt that this barrel can outshoot me and with someone more capable it could probably shoot sub-MOA all day long.
I'm very happy with this upper and barrel and would not hesitate to buy another one!
That being said I've also noticed a couple of posts about unreliable DPMS uppers and barrels and I was not too impressed with th answers given by the DPMS support people. DPMS mentioned having tighter chambers yet still being 5.56 and a special list of ammo that will work reliably, etc, etc...
I don't know why the barrels made for CMMG seem so much better but IMHO the only DPMS barrels I would ever buy would be the ones specially made for CMMG.
Please note I have no business affiliation with CMMG, I'm just a happy and very satisfied customer!