Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
6/23/2004 9:46:23 PM EDT
what is the difference between these 2 hard drives.
to me the look like the same thing.so which should i go with?



129-40 rebate=89
(submitted by 6-30-04 (doubt i could get it postmark by the 30th)

Western Digital Caviar SE 200GB / 7200 / 8MB / ATA-100 EIDE Hard Drive

Western Digital—200GB—Special!
Offering capacities as large as 200 GB, the Western Digital high-performance family of EIDE Hard Drive is equipped with an 8 MB buffer—the largest buffer available today in a desktop EIDE hard drive, delivering data to users faster than any hard drive in its class.

These high-performance hard drives provide a higher percentage of cache hits and significantly faster time to data than industry-standard 2 MB versions. Within the complex operations of hard drives, the buffer is used to hold the results of recent reads from the disk, and also to "pre-fetch" information that is likely to be requested in the near future. The use of an increased buffer improves the performance by reducing the number of physical accesses to the disk and allowing data to stream from the disk uninterrupted by mechanical operations.


This drive holds:
- 85 two-hour DVD-quality movies or
- 300 hours of VHS-quality video or
- 177 days of around-the-clock MP3 audio or
- 75,000 vivid digital photos or
- 427 action-packed games!
Specifications
   Capacity (GB) Learn More    200
     Interface    Ultra ATA-100
 
   Spindle Speed (RPM) Learn More    7200
 
   Buffer Memory Learn More    8MB
 

   Average Seek (msec) Learn More    <9.5
 



129 no rebate
Seagate 200GB / 7200 / 8MB / ATA-100 EIDE Hard Drive

The World's Toughest and Quietest High-Performance Desktop Drive With Record-Setting Storage Density

Seagate's Barracuda 200GB hard disc drive (Model: 7200.7) delivers 7,200 RPM access speed and an Ultra ATA-100 interface for mainstream and high-performance desktop applications. This drive features superior performance, quiet acoustics and Seagate's comprehensive 3D Defense System, for the highest security of your data. The Seagate 200GB hard drive handles the common uses of today's PCs, such as games, photo and video editing, advanced applications, MP3's and the usual Internet downloads. And with the 8.5 ms access time, these functions will be performed swiftly and accurately!

This drive holds:
- 85 two-hour DVD-quality movies or
- 300 hours of VHS-quality video or
- 177 days of around-the-clock MP3 audio or
- 75,000 vivid digital photos or
- 427 action-packed games!


Specifications



   Capacity (GB) Learn More    200
 
    Interface    Ultra ATA-100
 
   Spindle Speed (RPM) Learn More    7200
 
    Buffer Memory Learn More    8MB
 
   Average Seek (msec) Learn More    <9.5  

   Type    OEM

6/23/2004 9:50:27 PM EDT
[#1]
I've found Western Digital's to be more reliable over time.

If you can afford it, get a motherboard and hard drive that support Serial ATA - it's much faster.
6/23/2004 9:54:36 PM EDT
[#2]
Pretty much nothing.  Like was stated above though, WD tends to be a better drive.
6/24/2004 12:45:46 AM EDT
[#3]
That's surprising. My clients have had many more Western Digital failures than Seagate failures (no drive is perfect, that's why we have backup).

Personally I would go with the Seagate.
6/24/2004 1:09:37 AM EDT
[#4]
Another vote here for the Seagate.  I've been using them exclusively for years without a single failure.  Fast and reliable drives.  They're nice and quiet too.
6/24/2004 2:28:28 AM EDT
[#5]
I prefer Western Digitals.  If you can run SATA get a pair of WD Raptors.  They absolutely scream.
6/24/2004 2:40:50 AM EDT
[#6]
thanks for everyones opion.
but what is sata?
6/24/2004 2:52:28 AM EDT
[#7]
Short for Serial Advanced Technology Attachment, a disk drive implementation that integrates the controller on the disk drive itself.
There are several versions of ATA, all developed by the Small Form Factor (SFF) Committee.

Often abbreviated SATA or S-ATA, an evolution of the Parallel ATA physical storage interface. Serial ATA is a serial link -- a single cable with a minimum of four wires creates a point-to-point connection between devices. Transfer rates for Serial ATA begin at 150MBps. One of the main design advantages of Serial ATA is that the thinner serial cables facilitate more efficient airflow inside a form factor and also allow for smaller chassis designs. In contrast, IDE cables used in parallel ATA systems are bulkier than Serial ATA cables and can only extend to 40cm long, while Serial ATA cables can extend up to one meter.
Serial ATA supports all ATA and ATAPI devices.

I run a 36 gig WD Raptor (10,000 rpms) as my system hard drive, and two 200 gig SATA hard drives for storage.

SATA's main advantage is slimmer power / data cables, higher data transfer rate and when using a SATA motherboard the ability to daisy chain multiple hard drives without the expense of SCSI drives.



Quoted:
thanks for everyones opion.
but what is sata?

6/24/2004 2:53:05 AM EDT
[#8]
Oh yea, get the Western Digital, Seagate is second. Avoid Maxtor.