User Panel
Posted: 10/22/2002 8:38:35 AM EDT
Seems to me that the people on this board have a lot of knowledge about how bullets act when they hit something in theory, but in real life it's a lot easier to see. Just because you read that a .223 remington, or the mostly equivelent military version, put a hole in a dead monkey at 250 meters doesn't mean anything.
I have shot a lot of animals, never a human, but I think that the best way to see the effects of a bullet is to shoot something and try to kill it. For instance, someone gave a report about how the .223 caliber bullet caused devistating wounds on one of the snipers victoms. I have shot hundreds of coyotes, prarie dogs, etc. and even some big game with .223 caliber guns. The first thing noticed is that speed is absolutly everything. If you load a .223 remington and a .22-250 remington with the same bullet and spit one out at about 500 feet per second faster, you would not even begin to believe the difference in devistation. Also if you find a good hollowpoint and load it as hot a you can get it. When you shoot even somthing as small as a coyote the bullet usually will not even come out the other side due to it fragmenting and mushrooming out so badly. The type of bullet used makes a huge difference in what happens. As for larger game, bear, deer, elk, it has been my experience that to kill something you have to shoot it in the right place. I have friends that use .300 ultra mags and .338 weatherbys for all big game hunts. I use a .270. Killed all my animals with no more than two shots with it. All would have died with one shot, but as I am not going to let something that appears it could run and suffer do so. The second shots have all been insurance shots. The point is, yeah a bigger gun will help kill a bigger animal because it has to get through tougher bone and hide do tear the insides, but it doesn't take a bigger gun to kill a bigger animal. You have to place your shot. The bigger gun only gives you a little more leniency as to where you can put the bullet to still have an effective kill. This sniper has made very good shots so far. With those shot placements it could be arguable that a .22 mag would to the same job, obviously there would be less damage due to the speed difference, but it would have probably worked. And yes, I have shot thousands of animals with a .22 lr/mag, so I feel I can have an opinion about this. I realize that shooting gelatin and dead monkeys gives a good approximation about what would happen when a person is shot, probably the monkey more so, unless you clothed the gelatin. Anyways, I do realize that there are people on this board who have killed things and expieremented with different techniques, but shooting a wet phone book doesn't do it for me. And for those who have defended me and my family by having to take human life, you know more than me and god bless you, this is just my opinion on the matter. |
|
I have killed game animals with several different projectiles from different caliber firearms and bow and arrow. I have killed deer with .22 long rifle solids and stingers out of my Colts Woodsman and Stevens bolt action and Glenfield bolt action. I killed a deer with a head shot from a 9mm Llama. Haven't killed anything with my AR yet but hope to hunt coyote with it this winter. .30-06 is my weapon of choice for deer even if it is big enough for moose.
|
|
I have killed many types of game and nongame animals. There is satisfaction in a well placed shot, even more when a shot is difficult.
I like bustin' coyotes best. The get that OH SH!T look when they realize they are about to get rolled across the pasture. Lebrew |
|
I've kill a large variety of insects and spiders. I've run over my share of squirl, cat and bird with my car. Never actually killed anything with a gun. At least not to my knowledge.
USPC40 [img]www.ar15.com/members/albums/USPC40/line.gif[/img] [url=www.nra.org][b][red]NRA[/red][/url] [url=www.nra.org][blue]Life Member[/blue][/url] [url=www.gunowners.org][b][red]GOA[/red] [/url] [url=www.gunowners.org][blue]Life Member[/blue][/url] [url=www.saf.org][red]SAF[/red][/url] [url=www.saf.org][blue]Supporter[/blue][/url] [url=sas-aim.org][red]SAS[/red][/url] [url=sas-aim.org][blue]Supporter[/blue][/b][/url] [img]www.ar15.com/members/albums/USPC40/alabamaflag.gif[/img] |
|
I killed two flies yesterday with a newspaper but missed another one. Poor shot placement on my part.
|
|
killed a fair number of deersize animals. as well as a crapload of ducks doves squirrels rabbits etc... shotgun mostly for the latter group.
.243 only for the deersize animals, and them 100 gr Noslers are one kick ass bullet-drops em right in their tracks. |
|
Every animal in texas I ve killed. Whather it flies, slides or walks. I was a big JOY HUNTER before.
GG |
|
Quoted: I stepped on an ant, once. Does that count? View Quote How fast was your shoe moving? What size was your shoe? Were you wearing a shoe? If not, what size was your foot? You have to look at the details. |
|
jackrabbit on the run, incredibly lucky shot....and a lizard or two.
|
|
why clothe the gelatin and not the monkey? too sentimental?
|
|
Quoted: I killed two flies yesterday with a newspaper but missed another one. Poor shot placement on my part. View Quote Yup, ya gotta hit 'em in the eye. Hunting and controlling varmints/pests for almost forty years, shot a few, what's the question? |
|
I hurt someones feelings once.
Dscott beat me to it.......anyone guess the movie? |
|
Quoted: Quoted: I stepped on an ant, once. Does that count? View Quote How fast was your shoe moving? What size was your shoe? Were you wearing a shoe? If not, what size was your foot? You have to look at the details. View Quote The BC of your average shoe is so low I don't think it could penetrate an ant's exoskeleton or its vital organs. However if you were wearing highheels with a ballistic tip then the ant would be dispatched humanly. Therefore you couldn't have killed the ant unless you were wearing highheels. Confess! :) Shok |
|
Quoted: I hurt someones feelings once. Dscott beat me to it.......anyone guess the movie? View Quote Ronin |
|
Qshok, I think my size thirteens under my pushing 3 c-notes of weight will take care of anything's "exoskeleton".
But, on the "have you really shot anything" note? Yep, lotsa deer, squirrels, armadillos, birds, rabbits, ducks, geese, snakes, fish (yes fish), coyotes, wild boars, javelina, lizards etc..... I'd guess wild boar would do as a sub for a human sized target. Don't think I'd trust a .223 on one. Nope. I want something that promotes massive bleeding and destruction quickly. Shot a Russian boar with a .44 magnum pistol. Two shots out of 8 1/2 inch Ruger Blackhawk before the sumbitch stopped. First shot just missed the shoulder joint but took most arteries and portions of both lungs out the exit wound and a portion of the heart.....second shot in the nose cause he was coming to see what shot him the first time. Don't think he would have made it to me, but, those tusks looked nasty. 22-250 on coyotes at 200 + yards was plenty to drop them. .243 was big enough for most Texas Whitetail deer if you can shoot. I think a head shot with a .22 in the eye or something would drop a man, but if you want to really kill why bother with a smaller caliber when there are so many .308's around? IMHO |
|
Killed a six-pack last night! I have killed 2 animals with a .223. In both cases I was using Remington 55gr PSP factory ammo. The first was a squirrel. The second was a deer (head shot). I don't hunt with a .223 anymore, now I use a .308. Older and wiser......
|
|
I have taken a few whitetails with my 243, using 85g Sierra HP BT, (loaded up pretty hot)
Woodchucks, I have taken with my 243, 223(Rem700), 6mm, 222, even got one with my 445 supermag[:O] Since we can't use a semi or a fmj in PA for hunting, I havent shot any woodchucks with my AR15, XM193, or 69g SMKs. But my 243 w/ 58g VMAX make the biggest holes in woodchucks. I did recently got a 40XB in a 220 swift, I havent worked up any loads for it yet, but I cant wait to take that out for woodchucks. The person who I bought it from had some 55g spitzers and some 55g Nosler BT loaded up for it, the noslers w/4064 shot a few nice one hole groups. I am pretty confident that that load in this rifle will play a good role in reducing the woodchuck population on the farm[;)] |
|
I have dispatched my share of critters and I believe that larger animals are best hunted with larger bullets. I have shot them with the smaller stuff and while I may get some pretty good wounds, they just are not as quick and humane as the larger bullets. I am glad that someone is having good luck with Nosler 100 gr. .243s. I once shot a 100 lb. deer at point blank range with one. It went through the heart, but the deer ran several hundred yards with no sign of any problem before stopping at the end of a pasture.
I usually hunt anything as large as deer with a 30.06 or maybe a .308. The reason is that a deer is four legged and the bullet may have to travel a good ways through the animal. I shot one head on just under the throat once with a 30.06 and the bullet went the full length of the animal. A small bullet will not do that. |
|
Seems that the tiny .223 is doing a pretty good job from the "beltway sniper's" rifle even if his shot placement isn't very good - what 9 out of 12 one shot kills ...
You'd have to kill lots of somethings to actually zero out randomness and other variables. People aren't like most animals when it comes to being shot - the human mind gives in much too easy after being shot. |
|
I've killed time!..........As a matter of fact. I'm killing it right now! [;D]
|
|
I have killed a caribou, five deer, hundred of birds and thousands of insects. You guys oughtta see what a .243 does to a deer at close range. Its effective, but it wastes meat.
|
|
I've killed everything from birds to bugs to fish to cats to 1 POS pitbull that chewed up my wife to deer to turkeys to fish to rodents of every description.
The most satisfying shot was that goddamn dog. |
|
Me, why I never have killed anything. That deer camp I own in southeast Ohio is just a place to go and camp during deer season. All the guns are for shooting cans.........
I like my 8mm Mauser best of all for this topic even though I never have done that, fast trajectory almost fast about the same as a 5.56mm and the bullet slightly bigger than a 30.06. Makes one hell of a mess but you can't miss. Heavy to tote in the woods though. Use a 50 cal ball for black powder season even though I have an inline. Like what the ball does............. |
|
So umm...
Exactly what type of "job" do you need done? I have standard rates and discounts to AR15.com members. E-mail me..... Sgt(A-Team)ar15 |
|
White tails: 3 with shotgun/rifled slug, 4 with .50 cal black powder, 1 with a bow (not some fancy compound bow either - it was an old laminated recurve).
Squirrels: Many with .22 LR Doves: Many Ducks: 2 Dogs: 1 Cats: 2 Wild Boar (not feral hog): 1 with a .45 Govt model, 230gr. ball ammo. Ground Hogs: Many with .222 Magnum Rabid Raccoon: 1 with a 12ga shotgun |
|
Whoops missed the dog story.
When I was a kid and lived on the farm, a pack of dogs killed a couple of our hunting beagles while chained up. My grandfather, father, and I posted a dog kill in the county advising our neighbors to keep their pets home that weekend. We killed 38 dogs that weekend. Mainly shooting them at distance from the back porch as they crossed the bottom (all our property). I was impressed as my grandfather took out on after the other with his Remington 22 bolt action. The man could shoot and head shots each everyone. Of cource being the youngest, I got credit for all the gut shots guilty or not. |
|
Most of my clinical knowledge came from here:
[url]http://www.fen-net.de/norbert.arnoldi/army/wound.html[/url] [url]http://www.bobtuley.com/terminal.htm[/url] [url]http://www.ammo-oracle.com/[/url] Scott |
|
Quoted: I've killed time!..........As a matter of fact. I'm killing it right now! [;D] View Quote You beat me to it, I kill time here every night.[;d] |
|
Deer- 22 I think
2 w/.50cal T/C blackdiamond black powder 5 w/ .350 Remington Mag. 1 w/Whitetail hunter bow all the rest with .270 Black Bear 1 w/ .350 Remington Mag Feral Hog 2 1 with .350 Remington mag the other with Remington 870 12g w/ slug Turkey 4 3 w/ Remington 870 12g 1 w/ .223 in Remington M7 Crap load of squirrels with .22lr and asorted 12 and 20 gauges Same from Rabbits 'yotes 5 2 w/ Ruger P94 .40 S&W 1 w/ .270 2 w/ .223 crap load of groundhogs 6mm remington .270 .223 P94 .40 |
|
I just got home from groundhog hunting. Shot a very large male at 150 yards with my .17 rem using 30 grain Bergers and Varget.
Never had an exit even at close range(under 30 yards) and when I pick up the 'hogs and shake them it sounds like a bag full of water. Speed does kill but BC rules.[:)] |
|
I've shot deer with 7.62x39, not too effective. 16" barrel SKS at about 50 yards. Took the deer though. Had to use a follow up shot to finish him off. Young buck. I shot Bambi... that's what girls at my school told me. But they don't mind. Many Bambi's out there, huh?
I'm using my Bushy M4A3 this year, hope to get a bigger harvest. Little brother wants a CETME, already has a Savage .30-'06. Dad uses a .30-30. All have taken deer. I'm gonna try to use my Thompson this year too. Last year I used a 1911, Norinco, borrowed it from a friend. That wasn't too effective at 60+ yards. |
|
Quoted: I just got home from groundhog hunting. Shot a very large male at 150 yards with my .17 rem using 30 grain Bergers and Varget. Never had an exit even at close range(under 30 yards) and when I pick up the 'hogs and shake them it sounds like a bag full of water. Speed does kill but BC rules.[:)] View Quote Ah, now I know why I like you so much--you know what "BC" means, and how important it is. My kinda people! Aim small, miss small. [;)] |
|
Killed a bottle of Pepe Lopez in the desert once. Felt bad and will never do it again!
|
|
I probably should have worded my answer a little better. I know that in the hands of an experienced and self-disciplined hunter that a .243 is just fine. I hunted for years with a guide that used a 6mm Rem and he never had to shoot anything twice. The unsuspecting doe that I shot was at no more than six inches from my muzzle. I was more than unhappy watching it run several hundred yards after a heart shot. The difference is that a bigger bullet will suffice for a greater number of shots. I have seen deer quickly succumb to shots that I would not have thougth would have been fatal, but I don't reccomend any slob shots of course.
I would not try it myself for a new Hummer and a date with Pam Anderson but I saw a home movie of some Rhodesian soldiers on elephant culling duty. They casually walked into a herd of elephants and began shooting them in the head with their .308s. You would have thougth that they were using RPGs. I could not believe their total confidence in their weapons when they were only yards at most from the very upset elephants. |
|
I probably should have worded my answer a little better. I know that in the hands of an experienced and self-disciplined hunter that a .243 is just fine. I hunted for years with a guide that used a 6mm Rem and he never had to shoot anything twice. The unsuspecting doe that I shot was at no more than six inches from my muzzle. I was more than unhappy watching it run several hundred yards after a heart shot. The difference is that a bigger bullet will suffice for a greater number of shots. I have seen deer quickly succumb to shots that I would not have thougth would have been fatal, but I don't reccomend any slob shots of course.
I would not try it myself for a new Hummer and a date with Pam Anderson but I saw a home movie of some Rhodesian soldiers on elephant culling duty. They casually walked into a herd of elephants and began shooting them in the head with their .308s. You would have thougth that they were using RPGs. I could not believe their total confidence in their weapons when they were only yards at most from the very upset elephants. |
|
My fiancee has 'killed something' in the back of our truck right now. Looks like it might once have been a raccoon that tangled with a few million grains travelling at 60MPH.
[BD] |
|
Hmm - why do you want to know?
I don't keep track of bags anymore, but I have got deer, elk, boar, groundhog, ground squirrel, rabbit, woodchuck, badger, horse (euthanasia,) cow, sheep (slaughter,) and human to my credit. Human kills were either self-defence or "under orders," and have been taken by firearm, blade, and H2H. What do you want to know? FFZ |
|
Originally Posted By Gun Guru: Every animal in texas I ve killed. Whather it flies, slides or walks. I was a big JOY HUNTER before. GG View Quote So that's why I didn't see anything when I was there last week! I've killed 2 and 4 legged stuff, .22lr, .32 flint, .75 roundball,.44 perc., 12Ga., .45, 5.56, and 7.62. |
|
I went on a magpie killing spree last year. Their screeching call really gets on my nerves, especially in the morning.
I found out they're really fricking smart. Dont want to bore you with details, but I was amazed at their intelligence. I got 4 of them before one who got away warned all the other magpies to avoid my place. |
|
If someone says a .243 wont kill a deer, don't believe them. Itll kill em just fine. The problem is the bullets dont hold together as weel as other calibers, and you end up with lead in your meat.
|
|
Quoted: If someone says a .243 wont kill a deer, don't believe them. Itll kill em just fine. The problem is the bullets dont hold together as weel as other calibers, and you end up with lead in your meat. View Quote Partitions, my friend. Partitions. |
|
Quoted: Quoted: I just got home from groundhog hunting. Shot a very large male at 150 yards with my .17 rem using 30 grain Bergers and Varget. Never had an exit even at close range(under 30 yards) and when I pick up the 'hogs and shake them it sounds like a bag full of water. Speed does kill but BC rules.[:)] View Quote Ah, now I know why I like you so much--you know what "BC" means, and how important it is. My kinda people! Aim small, miss small. [;)] View Quote Ballistic Coefficient? What do I win? |
|
I've killed a lot of somethings. They ALL tasted real yummy.
AB |
|
My latest kill was a moth crawling across my 100yd target. One shot one kill :)
And the best part was I even had witnesses! |
|
Quoted: Quoted: I just got home from groundhog hunting. Shot a very large male at 150 yards with my .17 rem using 30 grain Bergers and Varget. Never had an exit even at close range(under 30 yards) and when I pick up the 'hogs and shake them it sounds like a bag full of water. Speed does kill but BC rules.[:)] View Quote Ah, now I know why I like you so much--you know what "BC" means, and how important it is. My kinda people! Aim small, miss small. [;)] View Quote I'm feeling kinda blue that winter is almost here and there won't be many more 'hogs out to accept my offerings of high speed lead. I wish I could take credit for the "BC rules" quip but I have to give the credit due to Fred Moreo of SharpShooter Supply. We were talking varmint splatter rifles and he steered me towards my fast twist(8) .22BR. I wanted a hyperspeed .22 and was thinking a 22-250 AI but was swayed by the Lapua brass and his resounding endorsement of the .22BR with a faster than normal twist. To say I am pleased with the results would be an understatement. Fav. load is VV 540 and Hornady 75 gr Amaxs @ 3250 MV. Very flat shooter out to 300 yards so far and with the Amax's BC of .440 I haven't even started to stretch it's legs. |
|
Winchester 105 grain balistic silvertip, in the box that says thin skinned game. Its overrated. Between the two of us, my brother and I have shot six deer with 7x57. All under fifty yards, all fist sized exit wholes. He has had sucess with the 7.62x39 with federal ammo, but the mini thirty is a POS, and it jammed on him twice. Lucky I was there with MY ruger (Mark 2). [:)]
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.