Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
5/13/2010 9:00:57 AM EDT
click me

Soldiers
reunite to give Houston war hero final salute








By SHAMINDER DULAI


HOUSTON CHRONICLE




May 12, 2010,  9:59PM










David H. McNerney's Vietnam War bravery is the subject of the
documentary Honor in the Valley of Tears.




   






From
the outside, 1st Sgt. David H. McNerney seems like any other aging
warrior; his wars have become echoes, and he'd rather take his dog for a
ride in his pickup than revisit them.






Only
his soldiers are able to coax memories out of him, and through their
eyes the story of the Crosby man's valor has become the subject of a
documentary premiering today in Washington, D.C., at the GI Film
Festival.






The
78-year-old, who defied death decades ago while saving lives on a
Vietnam battlefield, will be there for the festivities and to say a
final goodbye to the soldiers he still refers to as his “boys.”






Lung
cancer, McNerney's doctors have told him, will soon claim his life.






“Everybody
has to pass,” said McNerney, who has no children of his own. “It's my
turn.”






For 50
men, it will be a time to say “thank you” and to honor a man they have
come to revere.






“If it wasn't for
him there'd be a whole lot more of us still over there,” said retired
Sgt. Leonard W. McElroy, from his home in Bonner Springs, Kan.






McElroy remembers
the intense fighting during a grueling March 1967 ambush by a North
Vietnamese battalion near Polei Doc, in which McNerney took command of
the unit after his superiors were killed, saving the unit against
incredible odds and earning him the military's highest honor.






Their damaged radios
cut the unit off from aid and they were surrounded by combatants,
bullets and grenades. But McNerney was calm, perhaps trying to set the
example for his younger troops as he soldiered through the chaos, his
troops recall.






“He was invincible.
He just said, ‘I'm going over to the front,' and he walked over,”
McElroy said. “I asked him later if he was afraid, and he said, ‘No, I
didn't think anything was going to happen to me.'”






But something did
happen when a grenade exploded near him and knocked him off his feet,
breaking a couple of his ribs. McNerney refused to be evacuated,
according to his Medal of Honor citation, and he continued guiding his
boys.






The documentary, Honor in the Valley of Tears, recalls
the event and the lives of the men affected.






“They have such a
profound respect and love for him,” said New York City filmmaker John
Ponsoll, whose father served under McNerney. “My dad lights up like a
Christmas tree when he gets to talk of one of his war buddies.”






Band
of brothers




Wanting to learn
more about his father's time in Vietnam, Ponsoll and filmmaker Eric Dow
crisscrossed the country interviewing veterans. The two quickly dis
covered not many enjoyed discussing their own experiences, instead
always circling back to McNerney, who was their trainer at Fort Lewis,
Wash., and then signed on to lead them in the field.






“I kind of felt they
needed all the help they could get, and they were my boys,” McNerney
said.






Now men with
families of their own, many still look to McNerney, about 15 years their
senior, as a father figure.






“My dad died before I
went into the Army. He was the closest thing I had, and I'm going to
miss him,” McElroy said. “Our group has a bond you can't believe. We're
as close as a family of brothers.”






The soldiers
describe McNerney as a stern, serious and frightful man with piercing
blue eyes that could quiet a room with a squint and rarely smiled and
never cracked a joke. Most avoided eye contact at all costs.






“In the beginning
you'd think that everyone hated him,” McElroy said. “But by the end we
all loved him.”






It is a common
sentiment among the men of A-Company 1/8. “I was scared to death of him.
He was mean and lean,” said Dave Lockwood, who was drafted as a
rifleman and became a team leader. “He was a hell of a man. … It was his
way of making men out of a bunch of boys.”






From
a military family




Years of service had
honed McNerney's skills. With his father serving in WWI and a brother
and sister in WWII, the military was in his blood. He enlisted upon
graduating from Houston's St. Thomas High School in 1949.






After two tours with
the Navy in Korea, McNerney tried civilian life with a short stint
studying at the University of Houston, but it proved disagreeable.






“I didn't like
school much,” said McNerney, who signed up with the Army when he spotted
a recruitment poster on campus. “That's what I was, a soldier.”






He retired from the
Army in 1969 and worked for the U.S. Customs Office at the Port of
Houston until retirement in 1995. His wife died in 2003.






Since then, he's
been keeping busy with his stamp collection and invited appearances at
President Barack Obama's inauguration, local JROTC troop functions,
Veterans Affairs events and the Crosby branch of the American Legion,
which has had talks about naming the branch in his honor.






Content
about the future




Lockwood isn't sure
how he'll say goodbye before he heads back home to Florence, Ore. He
said McNerney “was one of them guys that you thought would live
forever.”






Doctors offered
McNerney chemotherapy radiation as the sole option to likely keep him
alive beyond September, but he refused.






“They said I could
extend my life by a few months, but that's not much,” McNerney said.
“We'll see what happens. Maybe it won't grow as fast as doctors think.”






He is content with
dying on his terms but wonders how it will affect his boys.






“The strange thing
is that he's clearly the kind of guy that's immortal,” James Allen
recalled from his home in Aurora, Colo. “We could call him anytime and
always thought that he'd be there forever, but it doesn't work like
that.”






Allen was a medic
attached to McNerney's unit and hadn't planned on attending the reunion
until he heard of the cancer. “When I heard that, it was a no-brainer,”
Allen said.






On Friday, the men
will fulfill the only request McNerney made when asked what he'd like to
do during his last reunion: They will visit the Vietnam Veterans
Memorial Wall and lay a wreath at panel 16-E, where the majority of the
33 soldiers lost from his unit have their names engraved.






The veterans will be
honoring the memory of their fallen brothers, but it won't be lost on
anyone that they're about to lose their leader.






“They all know why
we're going,” McElroy said. “It's a tribute to him.”








edited to fix formatting at top...