Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
3/28/2008 5:48:37 PM EDT
Anyone have any experience with these?

Kitchenaid grain mill attachment



I have zero experience with mills, but I want to get into wheat storage. Thinking about picking one up (sold on Amazon for $109). The FAQ says it grinds to about corn meal consistency, not super powdery like store flour. Is that good enough?


GRAIN MILL ATTACHMENT (GMA) QUESTIONS

What is the grain mill used for?
The grain mill attachment is used to grind low-moisture grains and nuts into flour. Fresh flour produces excellent bread.
> Return to top

How fine will the flour I grind be?
The consistency of the flour is as fine as cornmeal at best. The flour will not look like the typical flour available at a grocery store.
> Return to top

This attachment looks so heavy, what is it made of?
The grain mill attachment is made of cast aluminum; the shaft is chrome-plated steel.
> Return to top

What is the best way to keep the grain mill attachment clean? Can I wash it?
Wiping or brushing off the attachment thoroughly is usually sufficient, as the grain mill attachment does not need to be cleaned after every use. It should be hand washed and immediately dried only when necessary. None of these parts are dishwasher safe. Do not store the grain mill attachment assembled. If this attachment is to be stored for a long time, the burrs should be lightly coated with mineral oil. Hand wash the parts before use to remove the mineral oil.
> Return to top

What speed should I run the mill at?
Run the grain mill attachment at speed 10 while milling. Do not run the grain mill attachment with the burrs rubbing together, as damage may result and no replacement burrs are available.
> Return to top

Can I grind seeds, such as sesame or poppy, in the grain mill attachment?
Due to the high oil content of sesame, sunflower, soy or poppy seeds, we do not recommend grinding them in the grain mill attachment.
> Return to top
3/28/2008 5:59:49 PM EDT
[#1]
you'll burn up your kitchenaid, and the design of the attachment is pretty bad.

Best to buy a dedicated mill; cheaper and lasts longer.
3/29/2008 3:49:08 AM EDT
[#2]

Quoted:
The FAQ says it grinds to about corn meal consistency, not super powdery like store flour. Is that good enough?

> Return to top


No  You will run into trouble trying to bake anything if corn meal is as fine as it will mill.

Spend a little more and get a good mill.  We use a Wondermill.
3/29/2008 4:08:58 AM EDT
[#3]
thanks for the info.. I have a K.A.Pro.  the only extra attachement I have is the icecream maker

I'll avoid this attachment, thanks to you guys.  so far none of the other attachments apeal to me.
3/29/2008 4:52:40 AM EDT
[#4]

Quoted:
thanks for the info.. I have a K.A.Pro.  the only extra attachement I have is the icecream maker

I'll avoid this attachment, thanks to you guys.  so far none of the other attachments apeal to me.


the whole attachment thing seems misguided. None of them are really better than a dedicated machine, and the kitchen aid mixer isn't really better because of the attachments. I've seen heartache and pain from ill-functioning attachments; why risk burning up your mixer?
3/29/2008 6:05:15 PM EDT
[#5]
Thanks for the input! Sounds like you saved me from making a $110 mistake.
3/29/2008 7:38:08 PM EDT
[#6]
I've got one my parents bought in the '80's.  Used it for the first time last week.  It made really good wheat flour.  Looked the same as the commercial wheat flour I buy from the store.  It was slow though.  Took about 20 minutes to grind 5 cups of hard white wheat.  It seems to be hard on the mixer though.  I've never had my mixer that hot.

I bought a Nutrimill today and am looking forward to using it.
3/29/2008 8:23:46 PM EDT
[#7]

Quoted:
I've got one my parents bought in the '80's.  Used it for the first time last week.  It made really good wheat flour.  Looked the same as the commercial wheat flour I buy from the store.  It was slow though.  Took about 20 minutes to grind 5 cups of hard white wheat.  It seems to be hard on the mixer though.  I've never had my mixer that hot.

I bought a Nutrimill today and am looking forward to using it.


That's the thing. Even though it's geared way down (slow), the mixer still runs hotter than heck. The mixer we burned up was older (a year or two old), but we were taking it easy with the milling. We were afraid the damn thing would burst into flames.
3/30/2008 3:41:16 AM EDT
[#8]
for 109$ ya can get a good hand mill that wont mess up your mixer.
3/30/2008 3:59:25 AM EDT
[#9]

Quoted:
for 109$ ya can get a good hand mill that wont mess up your mixer.



Link?
3/30/2008 5:19:01 AM EDT
[#10]

Quoted:

Quoted:
for 109$ ya can get a good hand mill that wont mess up your mixer.



Link?


google grain mill..

ya got the back to basics at 59-59$ and some other nicer electric ones in the 150$ if ya shop around
3/30/2008 4:14:21 PM EDT
[#11]
Hmmm....interesting.  We've got the basic KA mixer, and while it gets warm, it's never gotten hot.  Second to the slowest speed, and 2 runs through with progressively finer grinds.  Worst I've ever gotten out of ours was a drip of oil on the base.  Of course, I've just fallen off the truck yesterday, so.....  I've been doing this for several years, and the mixer still purrs right along.  Too many people want it done right now and either run it too fast or too fine for one pass.  If you're one of those people, buy a dedicated machine.

Yes, it is a compromise, but outside of a dedicated machine, everything is.  If you're not going to use it all day every day, it will work fine for several cups of hard red a few times a week.  Probably 4 years so far, and 1 drop of oil.  

Yeah, it's junk


(FWIW, it also does great with the 6 and 9 grain mixes from Honeyville Grain.  Great bread.)
3/31/2008 2:16:34 AM EDT
[#12]
i know the motor houseing gets hot on my KA,, but its also  one from the 70's ,, and only when im shoving chunks of deer and pork through it  to fast for the grinder to spit it out
ive got the pasta maker also,, but  havent got the  mill,,, only cuz i already have a hand mill( cant use the KA if power goes out )
3/31/2008 6:07:31 AM EDT
[#13]
Good timing. I have the grain mill for the KA
and used it this weekend. I milled 2 cups hard white and 3
hard red. I grind it 3 times as it is easier on the mill.
First pass is as coarse as possible which really just
cracks the berries. Second pass is in the middle of the dial
with the final grind as fine as possible. This yields about 7 cups
which produce two nice loaves. The mixer is warm to the touch at the end
but far cooler than when I milled 5 cups directly to a fine flour the
first time I used it.