Quoted: I'm really struggling. Do I get an XD 9 or XD 40? - and no I won't by both. I've already narrowed my choice down the Sprinfield XD line - so I'm not open to "get this other..." This will be my first handgun and I'd like something I can perfect my shooting skills with, while at the same time using as my CCW gun. Ammo costs are somewhat a concern here. I do have some experience with my father-in-law's 9mm. I am open to suggestion on the 5", 4" and subcompact lines. I need to be swayed one way or another as I'd like to make a purchase in the next few days
|
I have both 9mm and .40 pistols, so here is my list of pros and cons, you decide which is important to you:
9mm PROS-Ammo is less expensive ($10 walmart 100 round pack of winchester FMJ practice ammo) - personal defense JHP about the same cost
-If the SHTF 9mm ammo is standard used by the military, larger stockpiles
-Better penetration with +P if that is desired
-
significantly more rounds in Hi-cap mags that should be available when AW ban expires -24 days-Less recoil makes for less effort when practicing accuracy
9mm CONS-higher penetration - perhaps bad if used for home defense or personal defense - overpenetration can cause collateral damage.
-Less knockdown impact than .40 in +P
.40 S&W PROS-Better knock down impact when used for home/personal defense in +P loads
-Lesser penetration compared to 9mm - less chance of overpenetration in walls or perpetrators
-Ranger Talon LE ammo available to civilians with overruns - have never seen Ranger Talon in 9mm
.40 S&W CONS-More expensive ammo for practice ($16.95 walmart 100 round packs winchester FMJ) - personal defense JHP about the same cost
-More recoil means less comfort for extended practice sessions.
-Perhaps less available if the SHTF
-Lesser penetration if this is desirable for heavy clothing on perpetrators.
-Significantly smaller magazine capacity if ban expires and Hi-cap mags available again.
NOTE: if this is for CCW, go with the subcompact unless you routinely wear bulky clothing or jackets- trying to conceal a full size is more of a challenge in the hot summer days! XML tac light can be used with both with the XD series.
My choice for CCW would be the XD9 subcompact. Second choice would be the XD40 subcompact. third choice, XD9 full size. Fourth choice, XD40 full size.
Having said that I carry a P239 compact in .40 on hot days and a P220 fullsize in .45 on cold days. I will probably buy an XD9 subcompact for CCW as well at some point.