I used both, but I can't recommend one or the other. I have three Ping putters, and I love them all, but I am currently using a $3 Goodwill special. I found this old brass blade putter a couple years ago at the thrift shop and bought it to use in a spare set of clubs I have to lend out. I started messing around with it and I was rolling putts more true than I ever had before. I've used it ever since. Since you've narrowed it down to two, pick the one that you feel most confident with while standing over the putt. For me the putter is the MOST important club in the bag and cost shouldn't be a factor, a ten dollar putter that you feel comfortable with will outperform a Scotty Cameron that just doesn't "feel" right. Sorry if I wasn't much help, but I don't think you can go wrong with either one.