OK guys, thanks for the replies. I accepted the deal. Here are the details:
I'm 2-2, he's 1-3 with Vick (who is now injured) as his QB. I saw this and figured Eli Manning would be the conduit to facilitate a trade with him.
My roster was this:
P. Manning
E. Manning
J. Delhomme
A. Green
J. Jones
R. Brown (rookie RB with Miami)
M. Moore
TJ Houshmanzadeh
B. Stokley
P. Burress
C. Chambers
A. Toomer
M. Pollard (TE)
J. Elam
Dallas D
Cincy D
We can only play one QB per week. Since I already had Peyton (and a decent b/u in Delhomme), when Eli got hot, his trade value skyrocketed. A. Green got hurt (his production sucked anyway), I had no #1 WR, and my bench QB (Eli) was scoring points in bundles. This guy I traded with got a few offers from me, which he made counter-offers until we wound up with this particular trade offer by him.
I sent him Eli, TJ, and Moore. The WR is a solid #2...but he's hurt right now. The RB is a part-timer, and the QB (Eli) is a stud who's points mean nothing because he's on the bench. For those three guys, I get in return: McAllister who's the man in N.O. and a proven performer, and Holt, an elite WR on a pass-happy offense.
The deal was approved by the league GMs and is now official!
Thanks again for the advice.