Tower Cigars for AF Hemingways. Best I have found. They are also great for Padron Anniversario's, when they have them. Ask for Mark. The price he will quote you is often better than the web site. This assumes of course, that you are not in CA.
Famous Smoke is good for a lot of sticks and they have fast shipping.
If you use CheaperCigars.com, make sure you call. I am still stuck in the middle of a four-week delay because their web site is not updated on a regular basis. They have been terrible about returning emails. You will need to call them if you want to make sure your smoke is in stock or if you need to check on an order.
J.R. and Holt's are always excellent, but their prices are not always the best. J.R. does not carry Padron.
For Padron's, Tower or
2 Smoke are almost always the best I have found.
I have also had good luck with
Phoenix.