Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
3/5/2011 10:09:37 AM EDT
I want a service grade Garand. It will be my first; never shot one. Is there any difference between the HRA and Springfield Armory manufacturers? I know SA was the govt arsenal and HRA a private contractor. Any ideas?
3/5/2011 10:16:02 AM EDT
[#1]
I have one of each.  HRA's are more rare, as many many fewer of them were made vis-a-vis Springers of which a ton were made.

There shouldn't be any differences other than rarity since they were all made to the same spec.
3/5/2011 10:16:49 AM EDT
[#2]
Get both.

If I could only get one I would probably get the H&R just because they are more scarce.
3/5/2011 10:16:52 AM EDT
[#3]



Quoted:


I want a service grade Garand. It will be my first; never shot one. Is there any difference between the HRA and Springfield Armory manufacturers? I know SA was the govt arsenal and HRA a private contractor. Any ideas?


Lots of minor differences but nothing that really matters.  The late springfields and HRA's are probably the nicest finished rifles(before put in the hands of soldiers)



 
3/5/2011 12:55:39 PM EDT
[#4]
Ah, the key here is "late SA".  Either would be nice.  

I have a 5.97m SA that I think is the best finished Garand I own.  The parts function smooth as glass.  I have older SAs that are not nearly as nicely finished.  Just my opinion...but I think the last of the SAs were made with all the changes built in by those with the most experience putting them together without the rush involved in war time production.

My main shooter Garand is an H&R, with a 6-54 barrel.  It is very nice.  I saw a photo once of the inside of the H&R plant during war production and it had a sign that said something like "Build it like your loved one is going to use it."  My H&Rs are built like that.
3/5/2011 12:58:57 PM EDT
[#5]
I have two late (after Korea) Springfields, and an H&R that I built into a .308 Garand (out of an H&R reciever from CMP.


Either would be nice, you will love the Garand, but remember! It takes three to use the stacking swivels? I'm just saying...

 
3/5/2011 12:59:16 PM EDT
[#6]
I'll tell you this since I just learned it today and you may be interested.  

The Glock Sport Shooters Foundation (GSSF) is now a CMP-affiliated organization.   This means that your $35 GSSF annual membership qualifies you to purchase from the CMP, but it also allows you to buy a glock at LEO/MIL pricing.  Better deal than the Garand Collectors Association, although I did enjoy their periodical.
3/5/2011 1:03:01 PM EDT
[#7]
Mine is a SA WWII era and I put the correct sight knobs back on. I personally would rebuild and shoot a WWII gun before getting a nicer condition later model. For me it's the era over condition. Mine is just into the 2 mil ser number, oct 44.