Here's my repeated answer to this repeated question. It's updated every once in a while but is current as of today. I've got guns from almost all of the suppliers and can't think of one that I haven't fired except for some of the wierd very early ones.
The top two are close:
Colt. Whatever you like or dislike about this company, it's still got the pony on the side and is the only company that can sell rifles that have parts based on the government prints. It's headed by a retired Marine Lieutenant General who's shaking things up there. Their weak point is military business that weakens their focus on private buyers but hell, this is war.
ArmaLite. OK, ArmaLite is only headed by a retired Army Lieutenant Colonel, but he was an ordnance officer so that counts for something. He was a cop too. Their strong point is lifetime warranty, great engineering, and a string of new products. They've got 5 rifles (10, 15, 180, and the very neat bolt action AR-30 and AR-50). Quality is very high. Their weak point is supply. It's hard to find an ArmaLite. Word is that export military sales are cutting into supplies but hell, this is war.
Buishmaster. Their advantage is good supply of good guns. Not great guns. Their weak poiint is occasional oopses like purple rifles.
Olympic. OK guns. Average quality.
DPMS. Good guys. Their specialty is decent guns at low price.
All the others. Surplus guy, hobbyists, ex-emplolyees of other companies, and parts manufactures who learned that it only takes a little more effort to get a license, make a couple changes to brag about big "improvements" and "imagination" and then sell guns. Watch for two things; massive copying and very uneaven quality. The general problem at this end of the market is that they buy parts from a pool of suppliers and build good guns one week and lousy ones the next.
I rate ArmaLite as my favorite but support the old saying "Stick with ABC: ArmaLite, Bushmaster, and colt."