Quoted:
HI guys,
Now I'm new to the AR scene here, and I've been reading up on some laws regarding AR pistols, rifle, SBR conversions. Yet I still have a few questions that I couldn't find answers for. I know this has been talked about endlessly.
But from my understanding:
-pistols can be converted to rifles or SBR (with paperwork) and back to pistols again
-ARs registered as rifles cannot be converted to pistols
-ARs built as rifles first cannot be converted to pistols
I'm planning on just getting a stripped lower, but I'm not sure how they are registered. Are they registered as pistols, pistols, or other, etc.?
From what I gathered it seems the dealer would have designate it as "other", but then how would anyone know if it would be built as a rifle first or a pistol first?
What is stopping someone from getting a stripped lower, building a rifle out of it first and decides to convert it to a pistol later? Unless I misunderstood something...
View Quote
The law, as it is written. Specifically, the definitions of 'rifle', 'pistol', 'short-barreled rifle' and 'any other weapon' - plus some ATF rulings, et-al.
If you assemble an AR15 lower into a rifle, it is 'a rifle forever'. Attachment of a short-barrel upper would require an NFA stamp. Period. Even if you take the stock off, the ATF still considers it a rifle & you can be prosecuted for an unregistered NFA item if you don't put it on paper/get your stamp.
If you assemble it into a pistol first, then you can make it into a rifle configuration (and take it back to pistol) legally - you just can't put your short 'pistol' upper on it while it has a stock.
Nothing else matters. Having 'pistol' stamped into the side, or similar markings from the manufacturer/FFL/etc, is completely worthless under the law. What matters is the config of the first build.
It doesn't have to make sense. It's just how the law is written. Same thing with machine-gun receivers in semi-auto config (once a machine gun? Always a machine gun. Even if cut to pieces & re-welded up to fire semi-only).
As for 'but how will they catch me?', that doesn't matter!
The RIGHT question to ask is, 'IS it worth the risk of no-guns-for-life due to a felony conviction'? And the answer is NO!