Moose, I like both the rifle length and the mid-length systems. The rifle length offers a longer sight radius. For shooters with older eyes this system is a plus. Replacing full length hand guards is less costly. The mid-length still gives you a little better sight radius then the carbine length and you save a few oz. in weight. The mid-length may be the best of both worlds. I am looking at CMMG's 18" mid-length with the 1/8 twist. Good luck and let us know how your new upper shoots.
MHL555