I’ve heard some speculation here that CMT makes uppers for Colt. I had a chance to study some CMT and Colt uppers to see if they appeared to be the same.
They are all recent production. 1 CMT flattop, no M4 cuts. 1 CMT flattop w/M4 cuts and 1 Colt A3, no M4 cuts.
They all work flawlessly and have the same color finish. The machining on the CMT is marginally better as to tool marks in the Charging Handle cut, but this is pretty picky. The Colt had a few small scratches/dings through the anodizing. Looks like rough handling prior to packaging.
I have concluded that they are not made by the same CNC program. I guess CMT could be making them for Colt, but they are not using the same tool paths and geometry that is used on the CMT receivers. This is not to say that CMT never made them for Colt, just that these appear different.
I didn’t take any measurements, just observed the way some complex areas were machined. The area on the right side between the ejection port and barrel threads was a good place to see subtle differences. While they are very similar in many respects, it is clear that the tool paths are not the same.
Besides the fundamental differences in the machining, there were a few things noticeable on these particular parts.
The charging handle (Colt) snapped closed with a lot more positive feel than the 2 CMT’s. Not a biggie. They all work just fine.
Barrel alignment: I have installed the same Colt 16” Lightweight barrel on all 3 receivers. The first was the CMT W/O the feed ramps. The rear sight was about pegged to the right to get on target.
I removed about .008 from the slot and it centered up fine. Same story when I installed the barrel on the CMT with the M4 cuts. At this point, I was convinced that Colt messed up the front sight installation.
Funny thing happened when I put the barrel on the Colt upper. Near perfect alignment (4 clicks on an ARMS 40). Now I’m thinking the CMT’s are a little off. Far too small a sample to draw any conclusions and an easy fix in an case.
I like all of them and they all work good. I’m certainly not starting a which one is best thread. Just wanted to pass on some observations. BTY, the CMT’s were less than $100 delivered and the Colt was about $140 (stripped) from Brownell’s.
Edit: I forgot to mention that the "T" markings on the CMT seem to be a little bigger than the Colt. Part of that may just be because the paint is applied outside of the lines on the CMT's.