I can speak with some authority on this subject. I am a former Sumter Police Officer and the accusation of under reporting is absolute bullshit. My shift alone when I left was writing an average of 30-ish reports per night, and that number does not include traffic collisions or citations issued. That number is for a 9 Officer shift that is 12 hours in length.
I’ll be absolutely transparent here. If an officer can get out of a call without writing a report, he / she will. Nobody wants to write another report for a stolen bottle of hand soap that happened three days ago (I wish I could make that up).
No, I’m not going to write a report about kids shooting off fireworks on July 3 because your cat can’t sleep.
No, I’m not writing a report because the city waste department picked up your “herby curby” (that was a new expression to me) without asking you. That’s not stealing.
No, I’m not writing a report because the ghosts in your house are stopping you from getting out of your bed. I can’t arrest the ghosts.
Someone vandalized your house? Yes, I’ll write a report, take photos and dust for prints. Someone broke into your car? Yes, I’ll write a report, take photos and dust for prints. Someone did a drive by on your house? Hell yea I’m coming and my boys are coming too. That’s the shit we love. We’re all coming. And yea, we’ll write a report, take pictures and then go look for a subject.
I left the department last year. I don’t have a negative word about to say about the department, but policing just wasn’t for me.
PS- every situation I mentioned above actually happened to me.