Quote History Quoted:
You don’t want to direct mount he RMR on the M17/M18/X5/X-Carry/X-Compact that is cut for the DPP/R1P as the DPP/R1P is a longer optic than the Trijicon RMR meaning that you don’t have anything dampening the recoil being applied to screws. Eventually the screws will shear off and your optic will go flying. You need recoil bosses or an adapter plate that locks into the optic cut for the DPP/R1P so the screws holding the RMR are not taking 100% of the force applied by the recoil. Bobro or CHPWS are the best option to mount and RMR to the P320 with the rear sight plate as the Bobro has an integrated rear sight in the plate and CHPWS has provisions for a rear sight on the adapter plate.
View Quote
That.
My new XSeries slide came drilled for an RMR, but with the R1P/DPP cut of course, so a direct RMR mount was not advisable for the reasons you stated and also because the underside of the optic would not have been properly sealed. Even if there is no side overlap, there are two unfilled R1P/DPP holes.
The advantage of a Sig slide being pre-drilled for an RMR, however, is that you can use a thinner
filler plate, instead of an adapter plate. That allowed me to co-witness with the Sig Xray3 suppressor-height sights that came on the slide. I could not co-witness with them (at least not well) using a CHPWS
adapter plate.
CHPWS filler plate:
But without a rear sight dovetail, OP needs an adapter plate with integrated rear sight...and then likely a swap on the front sight.