User Panel
Posted: 10/30/2020 11:45:09 PM EDT
Well?
Watching a movie about Russian tankers in Afghanistan... British accent. Nazis in ww2... British accent. Imperial storm troopers... British accent. British soldiers in the Patriot... you guessed it, British accent. Why though? |
|
Because Mel Gibson REALLY Hates the British.
He Hates them even more than he hates the Jews. |
|
It makes them sound all menacing and also super stupid and kind of cuntish.
|
|
The British produce a huge stable of professional actors for the entertainment industry. The really good ones surprise you because you learn of them first in American productions when they're acting with perfect American accents and you are gobsmacked to learn they're limeys.
|
|
Never understood this.
Stuff written in the 18th century, sure. Now? Probably our best allies. French accent for bad guys would be fun but how “bad” could they be? Unless they were reinforcements I guess. |
|
To be fair you Yanks don’t want to hear an American accent as the bad guy.
|
|
Quoted: The British produce a huge stable of professional actors for the entertainment industry. The really good ones surprise you because you learn of them first in American productions when they're acting with perfect American accents and you are gobsmacked to learn they're limeys. View Quote This is true. Good observation. Sometimes Australian. |
|
The accent gives credibility. Better villains, better infomercial salesmen, better debaters, whatever.
|
|
Why do ancient Romans always have english accents? Why don't they sound like they're from Jersey?
|
|
At one time, there were British colonies all over the world and I'm sure that some of them picked up the accent.
|
|
Have you never seen this commercial?
British Villains - 2015 One Show Automobile Advertising of the Year Finalist |
|
|
|
|
Quoted: Why though? View Quote Fake accents, unless perfectly mastered, kill a good film. |
|
Quoted: Never understood this. Stuff written in the 18th century, sure. Now? Probably our best allies. French accent for bad guys would be fun but how “bad” could they be? Unless they were reinforcements I guess. View Quote Attached File |
|
|
|
Quoted: Why do ancient Romans always have english accents? Why don't they sound like they're from Jersey? View Quote It’s Written! That’s Why! Life of Brian - Stoning (HD) Complete scene |
|
Quoted: The British produce a huge stable of professional actors for the entertainment industry. The really good ones surprise you because you learn of them first in American productions when they're acting with perfect American accents and you are gobsmacked to learn they're limeys. View Quote Yep. Classic British theater training produces amazing actors. The "villain" aspect comes from two directions. Said theater training helps for well punctuated over the the top moments (Like a lot of Christopher Lees career) it also created a still deadpan villain that is not a flat performance. Like Peter Cushing as Grand Moff Tarkin. Watch the way Patrick Stewart delivers many of his lines. It is a rather smooth but deadpan delivery. Rather stiff even. Yet he commands the screen. The tension in his face, neck and body, his gaze, the intention he delivers with. It is masterful. It is confident. It becomes arrogant if it were a villain. Which, if you are looking for that, there it is. American training, which is evolved from the Russian Moscow Theater (Stanislavski) around a century ago, produces a different style of acting. Think about how James Dean or Al Pachino act (Stanislavski style trained actors) compared to Alec Guinness or Patrick Stewart. The British classical theater training has mostly resisted Stanislavski influences. |
|
NPR loves to use British accents to dump their beliefs on American listeners, they think it just reeks of sophistication or something.
|
|
How about that?!
The Englishman just showed up in the last Mummy movie, with Brendan Fraser and Jet Li, and l see this thread. |
|
Quoted: Because there's a (metric) fuck ton of British actors, and it's better to hear their accent than a brit doing a fake russian/italian/german accent. Fake accents, unless perfectly mastered, kill a good film. View Quote Just look at that God-aweful southern accent Nic Cage tried in Con-Air. Decent enough movie but l can never watch it again because of that horrible southern accent. |
|
View Quote You know the story behind that shot? |
|
Quoted: Why do ancient Romans always have english accents? Why don't they sound like they're from Jersey? View Quote |
|
Because a bad guy with a French accent could never be taken seriously.
|
|
Because the Cold War is over and making the Russians the bad guys is an overplayed trope.
I want more black representation in movie bad guys |
|
|
Because no one would be afraid of a villain with a trailer park accent (Deliverance might be the exception).
|
|
Quoted: The British produce a huge stable of professional actors for the entertainment industry. The really good ones surprise you because you learn of them first in American productions when they're acting with perfect American accents and you are gobsmacked to learn they're limeys. View Quote It was explained to me once that the British studios also select their movie actors primarily for their proven acting ability after they've gotten experience in plays, whereas the American studios select movie actors primarily based on how photogenic they are. Americans don't give a shit if the good guy is played by a great actor, but they really eat it up if the bad guy is played by a great actor. |
|
|
Quoted: Because no one would be afraid of a villain with a trailer park accent (Deliverance might be the exception). View Quote This. Americans now associate RP accent with snooty social class. Revolutionary War? Left wing writers? Who knows. But Spartacus used UK actors for Romans, Brooklyn guys for slaves. |
|
It’s quite simple
Can’t have black bad guys Can’t have muslim bad guys Can’t have Mexican bad guys White males are the bad guys now, but you don’t want American bad guys so guess what |
|
|
Quoted: It was explained to me once that the British studios also select their movie actors primarily for their proven acting ability after they've gotten experience in plays, whereas the American studios select movie actors primarily based on how photogenic they are. Americans don't give a shit if the good guy is played by a great actor, but they really eat it up if the bad guy is played by a great actor. View Quote Again, in general, British and American actors are also trained differently. |
|
You do realize that British produced TV shows and Movies often use actors with an American accent for the bad guys.
Amazing how that works. |
|
Quoted: Why do ancient Romans always have english accents? Why don't they sound like they're from Jersey? View Quote I don't think that most people would like the way that the Roman's actually sounded. They pronounced Vs like Ws so vene, vidi, vici is spoken in Latin as When-eh, Wee dee, Wee Kee. What Latin Sounded Like - and how we know Princess Bride Wedding |
|
|
Quoted: after what we did for them in WWII?? @Agent_Funky explain yourself!!! View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: You do realize that British produced TV shows and Movies often use actors with an American accent for the bad guys. Amazing how that works. after what we did for them in WWII?? @Agent_Funky explain yourself!!! I'm not sure I agree with what KA3B says. Most of our "baddies" are either cockney wide boys, or are continental European or some other form of Johnny Foreigner. Can't think of many instances where Americans are portrayed as the bad guys. |
|
Quoted: I'm not sure I agree with what KA3B says. Most of our "baddies" are either cockney wide boys, or are continental European or some other form of Johnny Foreigner. Can't think of many instances where Americans are portrayed as the bad guys. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: You do realize that British produced TV shows and Movies often use actors with an American accent for the bad guys. Amazing how that works. after what we did for them in WWII?? @Agent_Funky explain yourself!!! I'm not sure I agree with what KA3B says. Most of our "baddies" are either cockney wide boys, or are continental European or some other form of Johnny Foreigner. Can't think of many instances where Americans are portrayed as the bad guys. well, I can think of one. something about overpaid, oversexed, and over here... |
|
Quoted: well, I can think of one. something about overpaid, oversexed, and over here... View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: You do realize that British produced TV shows and Movies often use actors with an American accent for the bad guys. Amazing how that works. after what we did for them in WWII?? @Agent_Funky explain yourself!!! I'm not sure I agree with what KA3B says. Most of our "baddies" are either cockney wide boys, or are continental European or some other form of Johnny Foreigner. Can't think of many instances where Americans are portrayed as the bad guys. well, I can think of one. something about overpaid, oversexed, and over here... That's just banter. We will always mercilessly take the piss out of our American cousins. It's part of our "special relationship" Can't honestly think of a UK TV show where the villain is American, though. |
|
It is more of a transatlantic dialect rather than standard British
I would disagree with the idea that British actors are trained differently. That was the case with the RSC crew (Stewart, Holm, Dench...) because they were classically trained from early on. More modern British actors have a much stronger Stanislavsky based (Meisner or Strasberg) training. However, there is still an emphasis on language and speech which is why so many British and Australian actors are more flexible with their ability to play various nationalities. American trained actors have less time and experience with dialect work due to fewer classical theatre training. That's my perspective, based on my classical training here in the US and England (RSC). |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.