User Panel
Man does not know the pain of lead. Man knows the pain of steel. The bayonet is a weapon of fear, and fear is a powerful ally.
|
|
Bayonets were rendered obsolete the day repeating rifles were invented.
|
|
|
View Quote Holy shit dude, I need to up my bayo game. |
|
|
Most fights with bladed weapons are quick and violent, to hesitate is to die, a wise man taught me once
|
|
|
|
|
What was the unit in OIF1 or 2 ... they rolled with fixed bayonets all the time?
|
|
How many bayonet fighters are they?
Two, the quick and the dead. |
|
|
|
I didn't think bayonets would ever be useful again. But with large crowds of protesters I could easily see the usefulness of one.
|
|
A question for current military, do they still teach bayonet training?
|
|
Quoted: When was the last effective bayonet charge? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I may have read a post more ignorant in my life, but it's not coming to me. That's like saying nukes are obsolete because they haven't been used in 75 years. Like the bayonet, the nuke is a weapon of fear, used to compel action or inaction on the part of others. |
|
|
Quoted: When was the last effective bayonet charge? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I may have read a post more ignorant in my life, but it's not coming to me. If we're not talking about smaller scale bayonet assaults (as recently as the GWOT and related campaigns), or ones that ended up not needing the bayonets to be used (I can think of one instance in Vietnam where that happened), then for American forces it would probably be Colonel (then-Captain) Millet's uphill bayonet charge utilizing a full company during the Korean War. IIRC, they were pretty much out of rifle ammo and still had some hand grenades (which they also used). They captured a hill from the enemy and routed them largely at bayonet-point. The artwork I've seen portraying it tends to show them using unmodified M1905 bayonets, which on a Garand definitely gives some reach. If we're talking about foreign militaries, then there have been later actions involving large-scale use of the bayonet (Dien Bien Phu saw that happen on a number of occasions; some positions were defended or taken pretty much with only bayonets or weapons used as clubs, or whatever else could be found to use as melee weapons; that battle was downright brutal). There have been smaller-scale charges with foreign forces in Iraq, at least. |
|
|
So if I wanted to put a bayonet lug on an AR I would need to do what exactly? Swap the gas block with an FSB that has one, or is it integral with the barrel? Never really looked into it.
ETA: Fuck it, duck tape it is. |
|
Quoted: So if I wanted to put a bayonet lug on an AR I would need to do what exactly? Swap the gas block with an FSB that has one, or is it integral with the barrel? Never really looked into it. View Quote What does your rifle look like now? It might be very easy to swap, or far easier to start over with a new upper receiver. You need one of the following: 20" barrel with rifle gas 16" with midlength gas 14.5" with carbine gas |
|
I know one thing, the bayonet course at Ft Leonard Wood was a bitch.
|
|
Quoted: So if I wanted to put a bayonet lug on an AR I would need to do what exactly? Swap the gas block with an FSB that has one, or is it integral with the barrel? Never really looked into it. View Quote Yes However, you need the right barrel length and gas system combo. They will mount properly on 20” with rifle gas, 16” with mid-length gas, and 14.5” with carbine gas. Any other combo and the bayonet ring will not sit where it’s supposed to. |
|
Quoted: A question for current military, do they still teach bayonet training? View Quote Marines do and Army does not, AFAIK, with respect to individual tactics. Not sure it is taught at all in any other service (probably not anymore). All of the services used to teach it, and more extensively than the Marines do today (Navy and probably also Coast Guard also used to teach the use of the cutlass until shortly after WWII, using single sticks; last use of a cutlass in combat by the U.S. was during the Inchon Landings during the Korean War). I'm not sure even the Marines still teach group tactics with the bayonet, which is where it really shines. I've seen videos of group tactics for riot/crowd control from the 1960s, I think, which shows how it could still be a very effective tool for that sort of situation if units are trained to utilize it in concert. But even absent that, it would seem to be a good deterrent against rioters. |
|
|
Quoted: Quoted: That's like saying nukes are obsolete because they haven't been used in 75 years. Like the bayonet, the nuke is a weapon of fear, used to compel action or inaction on the part of others. No, it isn't. It's history. |
|
Quoted: 14.5 in midlength barrel w/pinned & welded dynacomp, low pro gas block under ff rail. A Spike's Crusader full rifle upper. So just like this: http://www.recoilweb.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Spikes-Tactical-Crusader-Rifle-1-675x450.jpg View Quote It won’t work because your bayo lug will be too far forward on the barrel |
|
Quoted: 14.5 in midlength barrel w/pinned & welded dynacomp, low pro gas block under ff rail. A Spike's Crusader full rifle upper. So just like this: http://www.recoilweb.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Spikes-Tactical-Crusader-Rifle-1-675x450.jpg View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: So if I wanted to put a bayonet lug on an AR I would need to do what exactly? Swap the gas block with an FSB that has one, or is it integral with the barrel? Never really looked into it. What does your rifle look like now? It might be very easy to swap, or far easier to start over with a new upper receiver. 14.5 in midlength barrel w/pinned & welded dynacomp, low pro gas block under ff rail. A Spike's Crusader full rifle upper. So just like this: http://www.recoilweb.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/05/Spikes-Tactical-Crusader-Rifle-1-675x450.jpg Likely not possible to modify that setup for a bayonet. You'd need a different barrel, gas block, and handguard. |
|
Bayonets are far more frightening than deadly. Sure, a bayonet to the gut will kill you, but for the most part one side or the other runs away before things get actually stabby.
|
|
Quoted: When was the last effective bayonet charge? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: I may have read a post more ignorant in my life, but it's not coming to me. I would think they would be awfully useful in close combat. I recall they were used a lot in Korea, when your 8-shot Garand ran out and you were being overrun by human waves. I recall they were also used in 2004 in Iraq, by the Brits... https://www.wearethemighty.com/articles/these-british-troops-launched-a-proper-angry-bayonet-charge-during-the-iraq-war I would think a line of millitary troops with fixed bayonets would be something that most modern day thugs/protestors would be a tad afraid of, personally. |
|
Quoted: Marines do and Army does not, AFAIK, with respect to individual tactics. Not sure it is taught at all in any other service (probably not anymore). All of the services used to teach it, and more extensively than the Marines do today (Navy and probably also Coast Guard also used to teach the use of the cutlass until shortly after WWII, using single sticks; last use of a cutlass in combat by the U.S. was during the Inchon Landings during the Korean War). I'm not sure even the Marines still teach group tactics with the bayonet, which is where it really shines. I've seen videos of group tactics for riot/crowd control from the 1960s, I think, which shows how it could still be a very effective tool for that sort of situation if units are trained to utilize it in concert. But even absent that, it would seem to be a good deterrent against rioters. View Quote The shield is a particular favorite of mine and IMO the police do not use it very well, not to put them down but they look very awkward sometimes |
|
|
Quoted: Yes However, you need the right barrel length and gas system combo. They will mount properly on 20” with rifle gas, 16” with mid-length gas, and 14.5” with carbine gas. Any other combo and the bayonet ring will not sit where it’s supposed to. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: So if I wanted to put a bayonet lug on an AR I would need to do what exactly? Swap the gas block with an FSB that has one, or is it integral with the barrel? Never really looked into it. Yes However, you need the right barrel length and gas system combo. They will mount properly on 20” with rifle gas, 16” with mid-length gas, and 14.5” with carbine gas. Any other combo and the bayonet ring will not sit where it’s supposed to. You also need a 1.9" gas block journal, and not the 1" used on some barrels where only a low-pro gas block is meant to be used. I had the ring and lug removed from a FSB and installed on the forward end of the journal separate from the low-pro gas block on my 16" mid-length barrel. The 10.5" handguard gave sufficient clearance for it. Geissele made a one-off rail-mounted device which had both the lug and a piece to support the muzzle ring (like the nosecap to a SMLE) that could attach to the bottom of the front end of a rail. IMBEL does something similar (but integral with a Picatinny rail that is mounted through holes to the bottom of the handguard) on the shorter variants of the 5.56mm and 7.62mm IA2 rifles. |
|
Quoted: The shield is a particular favorite of mine and IMO the police do not use it very well, not to put them down but they look very awkward sometimes View Quote The protestors and cops fighting each other in Ukraine were using them much more effectively. Sometimes it almost looked like they were using Roman tactics. |
|
Won’t fit under my suppressor. On the other hand, as another member here once suggested, if you shoot it fast enough it becomes a “thermal bayonet”.
|
|
I muzzle thumped some insurgents with my SAW. Wish it had a bayonet
|
|
|
|
|
Quoted: It won’t work because your bayo lug will be too far forward on the barrel View Quote Quoted: Likely not possible to modify that setup for a bayonet. You'd need a different barrel, gas block, and handguard. View Quote So constructing a new upper that will accept a bayonet I would need a gas block or FSB with a lug on it, a hand guard that wont get in the way of said block, and what else? Any special muzzle device? |
|
|
Quoted: No, it isn't. It's history. View Quote |
|
I'm about to embark on a narco AK build. The plan is to build up an 80% receiver and then titanium nitride it. Should I also titanium nitride a bayonet?
|
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.