[ARCHIVED THREAD] - The Expanse (Page 3 of 5)
|
Quoted: Good series. I just binge watched it about two weeks ago and am watching it a second time. For anyone about to start the series, I highly recommend watching this video below. It gives a clear understanding of the different factions and timeline without any spoilers.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNjrI0YvZYAThanks for this. |
|
Quoted: I think I'm the only one who liked season 4   I thought it did a pretty good job of visualizing the book. I hope the show keeps going past season 5, some of these later books will make for awesome seasons if they keep on staying pretty true. Anyone heard if book 9 is still dropping this year? |
|
Quoted: I tried to watch the first season, but it took forever for the story to unfold and there was nothing to keep my attention in the meantime. Solid skip for me. I felt exactly the same way. I was about to skip season 2. But, I was extremely curious to find out exactly what was going on. I highly recommend that you watch season 2 as it's outstanding and explains everything. I'm glad I didn't let that crap 1st season keep me from watching season 2. You will thank me if you watch season 2 and forget season 1. |
|
Quoted: Season 1 does rather toss you in at the deep end. However, if you stick with it, a lot gets explained or just becomes clearer as it progresses. Subsequent series lean on what you learned in season 1. By that time, I had read the first book or two and now had a LOT of the holes filled in. They could have covered it in S1, but only if they were willing to do a 20 part S1, which US companies just won't even think of these days. Usually, I either read the book or watch the film/series because one or the other will diverge and totally ruin the other. In this case, the divergence is minimal, and understandable trying to cram everything into a 10 part series. Neither ruins the other, they are complimentary. Don't be afraid of reading the books, or of watching the series if you started with the books. That is probably the first time I have EVER felt comfortable saying that. I am just a bit worried about what will be the outcome of the sexual harassment accusations... Quoted: Quoted: OK, season 1 sucked royally. No explanation as to what is going on and a lot of huge plot holes. Season 2 and 3 are great! Everything is explained and things are cleaned up in season 3. I'm about to start watching season 4 on Amazon. Season 1 does rather toss you in at the deep end. However, if you stick with it, a lot gets explained or just becomes clearer as it progresses. Subsequent series lean on what you learned in season 1. By that time, I had read the first book or two and now had a LOT of the holes filled in. They could have covered it in S1, but only if they were willing to do a 20 part S1, which US companies just won't even think of these days. Usually, I either read the book or watch the film/series because one or the other will diverge and totally ruin the other. In this case, the divergence is minimal, and understandable trying to cram everything into a 10 part series. Neither ruins the other, they are complimentary. Don't be afraid of reading the books, or of watching the series if you started with the books. That is probably the first time I have EVER felt comfortable saying that. I am just a bit worried about what will be the outcome of the sexual harassment accusations... I doubt it. Plot holes that I thought were awful were mainly these two. 1st Why is that evil Chinese Corporate trillionaire$ guy Mao so cruel that he even has no problem with his daughter being killed by the alien crystals as long as he gets the crystal's secret to make money off of? And # 2, why would the Belter Police force give badges and guns to the same evil gang that murdered one of it's police detectives??????  I wasn't buying that at all.   As I already said, season 1 sucked royally. Season 2 and Season 3 are outstanding. I especially liked the scene where this icehole character was killed in season 3.   |
|
Quoted: I watched the first season, never could get into it. Oh well. First season is just there to tell the back story to the Canterbury, and paint the picture of political distrust and tensions between everyone. Everything picks up and seems much more focused season 2 and on. Even my wife who isnt into SciFi got hooked. |
|
Season 4 is a transitional season. In both that they were trying to shoehorn in different parts from different novels in order to make one season that was coherent, and that it gave Amazon a chance to take a dry run in a season where nothing much happened in the way of big space battles and plot developments. I expect season 5 to be much more intense. |
|
Quoted: Amos is the most badass character in the series but he has no character arc. He's been the same guy throughout. Not true. It's subtle and slow, but you see him trying to work out how to be normal, or at least understand normal. I love his character. When the rubber meets the road and it's gotta get done, he stops thinking and gets to doing. |
|
Quoted: Firefly was actually interesting and entertaining. I couldn't even make it through the first episode of the expanse as it bored me to tears. |
|
Quoted: Not true. It's subtle and slow, but you see him trying to work out how to be normal, or at least understand normal. I love his character. When the rubber meets the road and it's gotta get done, he stops thinking and gets to doing. |
|
Quoted: Yep, I get that, it started slow but it gets better and is a great series. Maybe a little more on the drama side than Firefly but very good. Quoted: Quoted: Firefly was actually interesting and entertaining. I couldn't even make it through the first episode of the expanse as it bored me to tears. |
|
Quoted: as long as they're not minors, what makes them inappropriate? Quoted: Quoted: I just scrolled through the aggregated list of accusations on reddit. There are quite a few people coming forward; some apparently have screenshots of inappropriate conversations. as long as they're not minors, what makes them inappropriate? Some were allegedly minors. |
|
Quoted: Amos is the most badass character in the series but he has no character arc. He's been the same guy throughout. I think Miller has had the best character arc, going from loser detective to savior of the universe. Amos is absolutely in the midst of a character arc. It's very subtle, but I feel it's going to become a big deal in the upcoming seasons. Quoted: Firefly was actually interesting and entertaining. I couldn't even make it through the first episode of the expanse as it bored me to tears. Firefly is amateur writing compared to this show. I enjoy it too, but The Expanse is so much more mature in different ways than Firefly. |
|
Had never heard of it, and started watching it on a whim one night, then binge watched all four season in a few weeks. It's Sci-Fi for people who love Sci-Fi. Absolutely fantastic. Didn't even know it was a book series until this thread though. That's interesting. |
|
Quoted: Amos is the most badass character in the series but he has no character arc. He's been the same guy throughout. I think Miller has had the best character arc, going from loser detective to savior of the universe. I've never understood the insistence that all characters in any form of media must have an "arc". Why can't they just.... exist? |
|
Quoted: I've got nothing more to add other than two of my favorite moments in all of TV. Not necessarily my "favorite" moments, but definitely top ten: https://image.ibb.co/de6Oad/tumblr_p8uubfukba1r30atgo3_540.gif https://66.media.tumblr.com/66c92b7837835cd6f6c4bb4b0e8c6bbe/9f3314341c3b1bc1-78/s500x750/a9db5e2bf41a5dd54c7146440874c83d3e8b2e9b.gifv I want a "I am that guy" PVC patch so bad |
|
Quoted: Watching Amos come to terms with his psychopathy and then watching him try to be normal is great, the speed that he can change from one guy to the other shows just how thin the "normal guy" layer is. Quoted: Quoted: Not true. It's subtle and slow, but you see him trying to work out how to be normal, or at least understand normal. I love his character. When the rubber meets the road and it's gotta get done, he stops thinking and gets to doing. It’s a disguise he wears so others feel comfortable around him. |
|
Quoted: Amos is the most badass character in the series but he has no character arc. He's been the same guy throughout. I think Miller has had the best character arc, going from loser detective to savior of the universe. Oh, Timmy’s got a character arc. Pretty big one. |
|
Quoted: I think Miller has had the best character arc, going from loser detective to savior of the universe. I think my biggest complaint about the first couple seasons of The Expanse was that they downplayed what a burnout Miller was. It kind of lessened his final sacrifice in my eyes. But Jane still did a great job in the role. |
|
Quoted: I've never understood the insistence that all characters in any form of media must have an "arc". Why can't they just.... exist? You can but then they'll but then you'll have an essentially flat character and no story. Cue Neo typing away at his desk in some non-descript office building and then Trinity shows up. Character -> Obstacle -> Goal (Higher Self). |
|
Quoted: 1st Why is that evil Chinese Corporate trillionaire$ guy Mao so cruel that he even has no problem with his daughter being killed by the alien crystals as long as he gets the crystal's secret to make money off of? Quoted: 1st Why is that evil Chinese Corporate trillionaire$ guy Mao so cruel that he even has no problem with his daughter being killed by the alien crystals as long as he gets the crystal's secret to make money off of? She was already dead. What would have been gained by scrapping everything at that point? And # 2, why would the Belter Police force give badges and guns to the same evil gang that murdered one of it's police detectives?????? There is no "Belter Police Force," the stations in the belt are owned by Corps based in Earth or Mars, the "police" are all contracted security guards (Detective Miller was an employee of the StarHelix security corporation and the Chinese Corporate trillionaire$ guy Mao was a major stockholder). And the gangsters were not given badges and guns by the local police agency, they were PMCs hired by an Earth corp. I'm not saying there are not any plot holes in the series, but something isn't a plot hole just because you weren't paying attention. |
|
If the series was to continue I’d love to see them use the thirty years between Babylon’s Ashes and Persepolis Rising to improvise new content. As for Cas Anvar, I sure hope he weathers this situation, I like his character. If he goes down, they have to re-cast, because his character is too important. I hate re-casts but what choice would they have? Things aren’t looking too good for him right now. |
|
Quoted: I hate re-casts but what choice would they have? Things aren’t looking too good for him right now. If they recast, I sure hope they do better than they did with Arjun Avasarala. Nothing against the actor they got, but he was such a huge change from the previous actor and he didn't have the same chemistry with Chrisjen's actress. |
|
Quoted: If they recast, I sure hope they do better than they did with Arjun Avasarala. Nothing against the actor they got, but he was such a huge change from the previous actor and he didn't have the same chemistry with Chrisjen's actress. Yeah, the "very bad man" guy was better. |
|
Quoted: If they recast, I sure hope they do better than they did with Arjun Avasarala. Nothing against the actor they got, but he was such a huge change from the previous actor and he didn't have the same chemistry with Chrisjen's actress. Admittedly new Arjun seems too young for Chrissy, but frankly Arjun isn’t really a major character in the books. |
[ARCHIVED THREAD] - The Expanse (Page 3 of 5)
Join the Community
Your next conversation starts here.
Create your free account to join discussions, share your experience, save topics, and connect with the AR15.COM community.
- Join discussions
- Follow topics and replies
- Connect with fellow enthusiasts
Already a member? Sign in
Stay informed by subscribing to our Newsletter