User Panel
Quoted:
This is Arfcom...get both. Here's a rasp knife I am working on normalizing in my propane forge...it's been off for 10 minutes. https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/41190821/misc/dck_radiant.jpg I made it out of a broken air compressor and some plumbing fittings... https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/41190821/gunstuff/forge1.jpg That forge is mostly for blade work, and is mounted above my coal forge which I find MUCH more useful on a regular basis and use for everything except long (length, not time) soaks mostly for blade normalizing and quench heats. Here's a video covering some basics of metal working where you can see the coal forge in action. It covers the coal forge enough a clever person could make a version. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BZkoj1Wpf6Y Honestly, going straight to propane is like going straight to a scoped rifle IMO. You miss a lot of important learning. If you hate coal then use charcoal...personally I love the smell of coal going to coke. Coal is stoopid cheap to use compared to propane. View Quote Yeah, learning how to tend a coal fire is great. That is what I learned on. If you are traditional blacksmithing that is the way to go. However if you live in a neighborhood it may cause problems. Also for me to get good coal it is $1 a pound. Charcoal is much more. Propane for me is $1.19 gal. I can run all day on $15 propane compared to $50- $100 of coal. The end user needs to take a look at what they need. I also do a lot of long work. Coal can be difficult to heat a 20+ inch long piece evenly. If someone is going to make knives rather than traditional blacksmithing I would recommend propane for sure. But like I said solid fuel knowledge is a great asset. |
|
This is actually the second thread in the past few weeks requesting a blacksmith subforum. Blacksmith subforum
Maybe someday. I would not mind moderating if they needed one. |
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
I refuse to argue with your username. Coal is stoopid cheap here. And I recycle charcoal from my woodstoves/fireplaces/firepits as a supplement to green coal in the forge. I respect your ABS journeyman rating. I was ignoring all of that as I am wont to do with such things until a master near me admonished me for not marking my blades. I was dumbfounded, explaining I thought us amateurs should not aspire to such things. He was adamant that my work was 'good enough' that at some point it would confuse/confound things and that I should get a stamp and use it. So I did. http://home.windstream.net/jbperry/img_knf/dam1a.jpg Where's our forum bro? View Quote Absolutely, sign your work. Even if just starting out. I have seen that touch mark before. Nice job. |
|
Another vote for a metalworking subforum. Ive been big into bladesmithing for awhile now
|
|
View Quote That poor anvil! Are the shoulders good near the horn? |
|
Again I'd like to suggest it not be a blacksmithing forum, but a metalworking form, encourage all forms of metal working in the sub, casting, welding,machining, forging,printing, and anything else I've forgotten. if you've made it in metal, you can post it there.
|
|
Wouldn't mind seeing a metal working forum covering lathe, mill, and blacksmithing projects. As many of the folks here that are getting/using mini mills & lathes it could be beneficial for all.
|
|
Tag and support! I just caught this bug this year. I need to get my anvil on a stand and refinish the top.
|
|
|
Quoted:
+1 to sub forum Got into knife making a while back but haven't done much with it. playing around with a split cross https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/290627/IMG-20161129-195732-144028.jpg https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/290627/IMG-20161129-200255-144029.jpg View Quote Cool, I made a split cross for my mom out of a old wrought iron railroad spike, it almost looks like wood with the wrought iron grain. I need to get up to my spot and harvest more of those old spikes. |
|
Quoted:
Wouldn't mind seeing a metal working forum covering lathe, mill, and blacksmithing projects. As many of the folks here that are getting/using mini mills & lathes it could be beneficial for all. View Quote I agree, make it all metalworking. Heck, just call it crafts and let the woodworkers in also. |
|
Can anyone care to comment on what a good assortment of hammers are for this endeavor.
|
|
|
Get some ball peen hammers at HF too. They're cheap enough, and if the handle falls out of them its a perfect time to reforge them into other tools. I've used a 2lb HF engineers hammer for a long time. I'm sure my new hammer will take it's place though once I get to swinging it.
|
|
Hammers are a matter of personal choice. Any of the Hammers found Here would be great.
I use a couple Japanese style hammers I made, one about 1.75lbs the other about 3lbs. One thing I would recommend is do not go too heavy. A 2.5lb hammer should be fine for most basic forging. If you need to go heavier you should find a striker. I was forging a few years then went to a 6lb hammer. It was great. I moved tons of material. Right up until I developed tendinitis so bad I could not lift my arm or close my hand. Took 6 months of rest and rehab to get back to work. So my favorite hammer is a custom angle peen made by master knifesmith Ed Caffrey. I use it probably 75% of the time when swinging a hammer. For heavy stuff I use a 100lb mechanical hammer and a 45ton press. |
|
Quoted:
I support this I just got my Alec Steel square circle hammer this week. Haven't had a chance to use it yet https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/116423/20170208-125524-143820.JPG View Quote I'm in on the forum! Let us know how that hammer works for you. I'll probably buy one from Alec when do does another run, Love his videos. |
|
I'll be able to try it out on Sunday and I'll report back. I can tell it will be an improvement since the handle isn't round. I wish I had bought a cross pein as well, I'll probably get one in the next preorder.
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
DO IT! We all like red hot steel here. https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/148252/redhot1--1--144380.JPG View Quote Just out of curiosity, why the mask at the forge? |
|
|
Since we don't have a forum to ask it in...
Any of you experienced guys have any input on this forge? Whitlox wood-fired forge I've got a lot more trees on my property than I have propane or coal |
|
Quoted:
Since we don't have a forum to ask it in... Any of you experienced guys have any input on this forge? Whitlox wood-fired forge I've got a lot more trees on my property than I have propane or coal View Quote Looks interesting. Wood charcoal does not get quite as hot as coal or coke. But if you have enough wood that can be a option. Just take the time to cook it down before getting started. |
|
Quoted:
DO IT! We all like red hot steel here. https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/148252/redhot1--1--144380.JPG View Quote I have a old propane tank that I want to turn into a forge. What is yours lined with? I was thinking of the blanket and fire brick Also, what is a good burner for that size? and do you need 2 burners for that size? Thanks |
|
Those that want such a forum, there is a procedure for doing this. I don't remember the exact details but when some of us wanted an airgun sub forum we contacted RAF (site staff) who gave us the procedure. This thread does show part of what was needed: sufficient interest. As I recall, a thread had to be made with the specific request in the title and original post. This thread also had to be in the main forum where it would be located.
|
|
I like this idea better than having two smoking-related subforums, which the site currently has.
My vote is a generalized metalworking/machining/black smithing subforum. |
|
I'd love a metal working forum, maybe a catch all type with jewelry, blacksmithing, wood furniture(probably fits in the diy forum also), leather work and the like.
I work in leather, kydex, dabble in stock removal knives, knife mods, and generally try to build stuff before I buy something. |
|
|
I have an interest in anything metal forming/machining related.
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
So my favorite hammer is a custom angle peen made by master knifesmith Ed Caffrey. View Quote my dad and brother are friends with him, and i finally met him about 3 years ago. the shop is amazing. dad is a knifemaker, but i've never been particularly interested in it. a half-hour in ed's forge, and suddenly i was youtubing smithing vids. |
|
|
|
As there is already a gunsmith forum in armory, I wouldn't be opposed to having it combined as a metalsmithing / metalworking forum.
And linked in general. It would get a lot more participation. |
|
So the Alec Steele hammer is awesome. It just feels right swinging it. I didn't do any steel work today, instead I tried out coin mokume gane
with some quarters. I've done a few forge welds with mild steel, but never damascus or anything like it. I had fun with it. I started out like this, didn't think It would really work so I half-assed it- Attached File Starting to expand for some reason... I lost 6 out of the 10 quarters during this fiasco Attached File I had 4 quarters left that welded completely. They made a nice bookmark/ world's tiniest holdown tool. It was originally going to be a necklace or ring for the wife, but it started coming apart on me when I bent it too sharply. This works too. Attached File Attached File I lost a second 8 quarter billet in the crack in the stump that my anvil sits on. That was enough frustration for the day, so I called it quits. Attached File |
|
Quoted:
So the Alec Steele hammer is awesome. It just feels right swinging it. I didn't do any steel work today, instead I tried out coin mokume gane with some quarters. I've done a few forge welds with mild steel, but never damascus or anything like it. I had fun with it. I started out like this, didn't think It would really work so I half-assed it-https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/116423/20170212-092528-145472.JPG Starting to expand for some reason... I lost 6 out of the 10 quarters during this fiasco https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/116423/20170212-093420-145475.JPG I had 4 quarters left that welded completely. They made a nice bookmark/ world's tiniest holdown tool. It was originally going to be a necklace or ring for the wife, but it started coming apart on me when I bent it too sharply. This works too. https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/116423/20170212-154719-145476.JPG https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/116423/20170212-155032-145477.JPG I lost a second 8 quarter billet in the crack in the stump that my anvil sits on. That was enough frustration for the day, so I called it quits. https://www.AR15.Com/media/mediaFiles/116423/20170212-171147-145486.JPG View Quote Cool mokume @Spiral_Out, this is one of those things that is very hard to learn. One of the things I've found about mokume is to always start big, expect to grind off a significant part of your edges which don't fuse well, and to silver solder the hell out of the cracks that show up later in the process. you should try flattening out a bunch of quarters into a sheet for a belt buckle, it's easier with less de-lamination issues since you don't have to hammer on the seams. this is a 260 cartridge brass and nickel silver ring I made. I've since added a silver lining to the inside to prevent your finger from turning green. Someday I'll succeed in making a silver/copper ring, my first one pooled into an alloy mix, turns out I had the kiln set about 150 degrees too hot. |
|
I'm just a tinkerer, but to have a dedicated forum here would be amazing.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.