User Panel
It is my understanding that the forces under Sam Houston as well as the rest of the army were more pissed off about the Goliad Massacre than the Alamo. The reason for the continued resurgence of the story/movie/pride about the Alamo is that it makes for a better story.
The Goliad Massacre was not a tale that invoked pride and bravery, not did it have colourful characters like Davey and Bowie. If I remember my history, the cry of Remember Goliad was louder than Remember the Alamo at the battle of San Jacinto. My .02 gleaned from my foggy memory of Texas History class. |
|
No one has to call the Fatcobra names...it is self evident for all to see. Was WACO the second Alamo? They knew they were going to die if they stayed, and an overwhelming force murdered them also. What would you have done Fatcobra? Are you French...
|
|
I don't give a shit why the war was being fought, the actions of the men in the Alamo was brave. I don't think it's "Revisionist History" to think that slavery had something to do with Texas independence...that's how people thought back then, and for some time after it.
Going to school in California public schools, in a VERY liberal area, I know what "Revisionist History" is. |
|
I bet they weren't lost, but rather just a mite confused about their location for a bit. "Since you have chosen to elect a man with a timber toe to succeed me, you may all go to hell and I will go to Texas." |
||
|
While this applies to Americans at the Alamo, it does not take into account the large percentage of Mexican Texans who took part in the battle. Most of the native Mexicans in Texas at the time wanted their independance as well |
|
|
It was the galant stand at San Antonio followed by the masscre of Goliad that bought precious time for Sam Houston and spurred recruitment. Had they not happened many historians agree Texas would have remained a part of Mexico and a very good chance the Mexican War never would have happened.
Its very difficult to predict how that would alter history but one thing for sure, the illegal immigrant from Mexico sure would have a shorter walk. Tj |
|
Dude, the Alamo was a fortress. The fortress is long gone, buddy. It doesn't exist anymore. When people say they are going to see "The Alamo," they are really going to see a church that was inside the fortress. |
||
|
That's not the Alamo. It's a church. The Alamo doesn't exist anymore. |
|
|
Look at the damn date on the blog. May of last year=ancient history. We beat this horse to death almost a year ago.
|
|
<----------- Give 'em Hell Davy! |
|
|
lets not forget Alabama had a bit of involvment there as well....
William Barret Travis, commander of Texans at the Alamo Monroeville, AL |
|
Another Plus 1 |
||||
|
+1 |
|||
|
While I appreciate the close relationship between TX & TN, we here are pretty damned proud of our heros and they are without a doubt Tennesseans, not Texans (though I guess they could have some sort of dual citizenship). |
|
|
Contrary to your thinking, you don't have a damn clue what you are talking about. |
||
|
Thanks for this article, this guy has a good set of articles on AK74 build. Looks like I'm going to have some good reading. Thanks! As for the Alamo... America wouldn't be the same without the Alamo and the people who won Texas. It's just too bad that the Mexicans have taken the south back without firing a shot. |
|
Some people are so ignorant, I begin to feel embarrassed for them.
|
|
Fixed it for you. Some are dense enough to need things explained in explicit terms. |
|
|
Time to play a little Devil's Advocate.
Where/when/why did Nickelodeon say this, I got was Nickelodeon said this, nothing more, Thats a pretty weak argument if you don't provide a source. That said if they did say that, and I don't doubt they did, thats FUCKING bullshit. |
|
I would very strongly disagree with that. |
||
|
The point is that the guys on Wake Island all got killed or captured, but they were tougher than hell and brave, and were prepared to fight to the last man. That kind of determination is honorable. THAT is my point. And THAT is the point of the Alamo. |
|
|
Indeed. Like the battle at Thermopalye pass, it was a few men placing themselves in a hopeless situation and using their own lives to buy time for others who would live on to make ready and give an adequate defense. It was an honorable stand. |
|
|
Cant we all stop feeding the troll fatcobra?His mommy will put him to bed soon anyway.
|
|
Only to the ignorant, maybe?! |
||
|
Don't presume to lay your lack of understanding on the rest of the 49 states. Honor, duty in the face of overwhelming odds, fighting to the last man because it gives others a chance.... those things may be meaningless to you, but to many others they mean much. Your sentiment is your own. |
||
|
You must have mistaken the fact that Texans give a shit about the other 49 states. How many of those states had the balls to be an independant country? Why we tied ourselves down with all of that dead weight I'll never understand. American by birth, Texan by the grace of God..... |
||
|
All Tennesseans should remember the Alamo if for nothig other than David Crockett, a true Voulnteer who told congress "You can go to hell--I am going to Texas".
|
|
I will NEVER understand the arrogance of some Texans (lack of education is what it boils down to). Most have Zero clue about the rest of the country. If they knew what good REALLY was they would not be boasting about texas the way they do. Texas is not whats its cracked up to be. The VAST majority of the U.S is a much better place than texas (Education,Raising children,Quality of life, etc...) Texas falls way behind in national statistics. BTW I am a texan |
|||
|
|
||
|
Ok so there are atleast 3 of us who have a clue. You two guys are not so dumb afterall But Doublefeed has minus points for that avatar. |
|||
|
It was our Pearl Harbour |
|
|
live in Austin ? You might live in this state buddy, but buy no means are you a Texan |
|
|
Some of you are actually sitting there thinking that a story of bravery, self sacrifice, and responsibility to duty and defense of your homeland against immense odds isn't something that everyone should be proud of?
Yeah gosh, wouldn't want kids learning about any of that and maybe instilling pride or values in them, perish the thought. |
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
Its a pretty good bet I live closer to the alamo than you do. Why am I not a texan? Because I disagree with the way some texans conduct themselves? Your attitude is EXACTLY what makes texans look so bad. |
||
|
I don't care who you are, that's funny right there. |
|
|
I hate people now days, everyone has to find the bad things about people or events. If we keep destroying our heros what is there to live up to? Yes maybe they did have slaves but they fail to notice the good traits they had like standing up for your rights even if they mean certain death. If we keep from trying to do all the bad things we will fail because we will have failed to do any good.
|
|
|
||
|
Psychic hot line? |
|
|
Strange. The attitude and way in which the majority of Texans I've met conduct themselves is one of the primary reasons I'd considered moving to that wonderful land. |
|||
|
Thank you for the post....really put it all into perspective. |
|
|
Know one thing that's kinda sad?
I live here, and a lot of people around here (maybe from out of town, I don't know...) actually didn't know that we were defeated at the Alamo. And one of the jokes about San Antonio is that you know you're from here when you've never seen the Alamo in real life. |
|
They're called Tejanos not Mexican Texans. To call them Mexicans is an insult, Tejanos are some of the finest people I know. |
||
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.