User Panel
His mom thought it was a problem........she said "he has been very depressed lately" I agree that bipolar people aren't going to kill everyone they see, but let's add up this stuff. 1. coke 2. gun in the house without parents permission. 3. a depressed bipolar 17 year old. |
|
|
|
|
|
Let's call a truce on the bi-polar thing. Lots of people, like myself, don't have a great knowledge of mental illness. I think we can all agree that someone who has a serious mental disorder such that they have a proclivity to violence shouldn't have firearms, and that bi-polar disorder MAY be an indication of this, but is not necessarily so, and that the article is vague on what kind of problems the kid had.
|
|
Bipolar + Cocaine + loaded AK-47 =====DO NOT GO TOGETHER !!!
Anyone who thinks she did something wrong is seriously Fu--ed |
|
|
||||
|
+1. |
||
|
Think you can control a teenage drug dealer with an AK47? She's probably a single mother who has control problems with her son. |
|
|
I don't think what she did was wrong as a Canadian citizen necessarily. It's not how I would have handled it, but she has the right to raise her kid the way she see's best. It's illegal in Canada for her son to have that weapon. It's not a good idea for a drug user with psych issues to have a weapon like that, particularly if it's against the law anyway.
She chose to let the state intervene because she couldn't handle the situation. She still has to live with her decision, and that won't be easy. That kid should not have an illegal weapon in his parents house period. Should it be illegal in a perfect world? No, but that's the law of the land. She would be aiding and abbeting to do otherwise. Her son fell off the train a long way back. Sounds like she prevented it from getting worse. |
|
YOU might not, but to deny it happens is to have some SERIOUS blinders on. |
|||
|
1 msdemeanor count of cocaine posession 1 felony count of gun posession 11 misdemeanor counts of ammo posession by a prohibited person (probably 10 round mag and 1 in the chamber) |
|||
|
Whats the point of making something up? You think officers don't have enough work already, without making stuff up? Has it EVER happened? Yes. It gets caught in the long run, and no ones career is worth trying to nail some loser on a trumped up charge. |
|
|
Bipolar does not mean mentally unstable or violent, most bipolar people lead completely normal lives and you would never know they even have the disorder. |
|||||
|
Wow, that's a great idea. Let's wreck the military. Hello! Public schools can't hack it by themselves, and the military is going to do better? A draft won't solve the problem, it'll only defer it for 2 years. If we are going to do anything we should make parents, educators, and students accountable at an early age when things can still change. No more slipping through the cracks. |
|
|
Yes, she should promote drug use, mental instability, and illegally owned firearms. Any parent who turns a blind eye to that stuff should not be a parent IMO. I don't see how people can defend the kids choices under any circumstances. |
|
|
Besides even being a psychiatrist doesn't make you special. A few years back 2 pharmacists when to prison for prescribing drugs. 4 years of college and then 4 years of pharmacology and it was lost on them that a DR has to prescribe something, their job is to know the interactions with other drugs and to fill bottles. TRUE BPD is a very dangerous disorder than can rarely, if ever, be controlled. |
||||||
|
|
||
|
You obviously didn't read what I said. Has it happened? Yes. Is it the norm, or even common, or even accepted? No. Once again, as I said, its not worth a career to make up stuff in an attempt to arrest or convict someone. |
|||
|
|
||||
|
BPD is just the new term for manic depressive characterized by basically by huge mood swings from very happy to very depressed, not all are violent, most can be treated with proper medication and some learn to deal without meds. being BP does not mean you are violent , some are yes, but not all. |
|||||||
|
|
|
|
She could have thrown the gun and drugs in a river, then preceeded to act like a parent. I really believe mental disorder 95% of the time are nurture not nature in orgin thus likely somewhat her fault. |
|
|
|
||
|
There are at least 3 different variations of BPD, and they are NOT I repeat NOT always dangerous. There's Bipolar I, Bipolar II, and another whose name escapes me at the moment. Again, my sister does in fact have BPD (in fact she was one of the people who were used in the tests and statistics for the book "The Bipolar Child"). She is NOT a dangerous person. Just because you are bipolar does not mean that you have no regard for right or wrong, or that you are going to run right out and kill someone. BPD is more properly calle Manic Depression, meaning that sufferers of BPD experience roller coaster like emotions going from highs to lows. Some cases of this are more extreme than others, but the disorder in and of itself does not mean that you are truly "f'ed up". Speaking from personal experience, TRUE BPD CAN be controlled through either medication or will-power. A majority of those with BPD show no outward signs of the disorder, and could not be picked out by anyone. Again, my sister, my grandfather, possibly my mother, and possibly myself have/had BPD. Yet, strangely enough, no one in my family has turned out to be an axe murderer or lunatic. This notion that BPD is something that totally "f's someone up" is misguided at best. ETA: I do acknowledge that BPD+ Drugs can at times be dangerous. It has been found that most of the time that people with BPD are on illegal drugs is because they are attempting to self-medicate. |
|
|
No, not for "a lot". You are taking the actions of a select few and painting with a broad brush. |
|
|
|
|
|
He was not supposed to have a firearm
He already f!@#ed his future by gettin ginto drugs. The mother of the story had to do what a law-abiding citizen had to do. |
|
Do tell. Is being bipolar somehow such an evil thing that one should not own weapons? Educate us. |
|
|
True, but as usual on Arfcom, people are talking out of their asses about something they know NOTHING about. The usual subject that draws out ignorance is ADD, but I suppose Bipolar disorder will do. |
|
|
Are you kidding? Mother finds out her kid is a potential gun-toting gang banger and you are upset with turning the kid in?
I'm all for RKBA but not little turd gang bangers carrying AK's. Good grief people. |
|
Here's something most people don't understand.....You don't just decide to "kick" a cocaine habit. If the little shit was into coke and other stuff along with carrying AK's then prison is the best place for him. What next.....are you willing to sweep a little "homicide" under the table because its your kid? RKBA does not have anything to do with gun-toting, gang banging drug-dealing/using turds. don't confuse the two. |
||
|
don't confuse the two |
|
|
|
|
|
Are you kidding? Mr. Florida aren't you in LE? Have you ever seen a family ripped apart from Coke/Crack? Give me a break...... Coke using thugs get what they deserve. Right now I have a good friend whose family is getting ripped apart by their crack using brother. I can't believe you are advocating covering this up. |
|||
|
A good ass-kicking solves a shoplifting problem or a cigarette problem or a staying out too late or vandalizing mailboxes problem......it does not solve a cocaine addiction..... Trust me, I've kicked alot of crack head's asses.......they seem to keep using crack and breaking into houses/cars/etc. |
|
|
Illegal weapon...hmmm...too bad they don't have the 2A up there, since we have shall not be infringed down here, wait, nevermind... |
|
|
Family imho should always come before the law...handle the situation in house... |
||||
|
I think it's more likely he left the AK in plain sight because he's a dumbass, same reason he had the drugs.
Now, who wants to bet that it's a WASR-10 that got stolen? |
|
You know I was going to put a disclaimer in my post that I realize this was Canada but I figured people would realize I was just making a point and not .........Oh forget it. Yeah, "toronto teen" gave it away in the first sentence. |
||
|
Homocide?....Child molestation?......what else should we cover up for our "fam"? That's a pretty broad and ignorant statement |
||
|
Bi Polar....wow. a good thing they caught it before it was too late. Now he will get the help he needs, like a steady flow of legal drugs pumped into his system. These drugs are safe and good, as opposed to illegal drugs that i am sure had nothing to do with his depression in the first place. Everyone knows that coming down of coke does not cause depression or make you feel like shit in general.
|
|
ETA: The kids I knew that started smoking crack were a different story FWIW |
||
|
|
|||
|
|
|||
|
the fuck business is it of yours who I decide to hang out with? I guess that totally invalidates everything I say right? |
|
|
Ever see weekend at Bernie's? Hiding a dead body can be a fun experience... |
|||
|
I have an opinion on this situation. But it doesn't matter and it would be wholly inconsequential to everyone concerned. However, this thing speaks about 2 issues. The disintegration of the responsibilities and duties of the modern Western unit as family and the role of the burgeoning socialist Nanny State as parent.
Can you imagine if she would have called in the Mounties regarding this situation 100 years ago? You know, back when the family structure was strong and State power over individual families was weak? They would have laughed at her and told her to take the cocaine away from him and back to the local pharmacy where he got it, and to remove the gun and him from the house if she found her son and the inanimate objects a peril to her and her family. There's nothing new under the sun. Imagining the social conditions of the time, this incident probably would not even have ocurred considering she would have had to rely on her own individual duty and wits and not on some unthinkable, non-existent state bureaucracy. With this as a foundation for society, there would never have been any family problem to begin with. My point is this. As the family grows weaker, the responsibilty to the State grows stronger. As the state grows stronger, the family and it's obligations then gets weakened. There's a vicious circle until there is no incentive left for individual family responsibility in any matters that might befall them. When we rely on abstract government for being the parent of our kids we then forsake even the slightest duty to take responsibility for our own kind. Even when there is a slightest hint of an onset of personal or family troubles. I cannot account for everything that this family went through. It's none of my nor anyone else's business, including the State's. But my guess would be that in the absence of draconian gun/drug laws, with all the government "responsibilities" that this brings, coupled with the novel categorizations of mental illness, this family would have been better off taking care of their own so-called problem themselves. My God, what would she had done without modern government as a recourse and fallback? Probably the right thing in the first place! Well, shucks........ perhaps I did have an opinion on this thing to begin with. |
|
He was her minor. Her kid. Now who does he have to turn to? Nobody. If he was lost before he's lost in a room full of vipers now. Thanks Mom.
When I think of this bitch all I can see is Cindy Sheehan. |
|
|
||
|
So you think that the 2nd Amendment should protect 17 year old coke addicts back here in the good ole' USA? That it applies to everyone, including criminals, in absolute terms? Let me guess, "..shall not be infringed." |
||
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.