User Panel
To me, not having a manual tranny is an absolute deal buster. |
||
|
I've always been a stick man. Having said that, AUTOMATICS are getting so good these days that I'm ready to give up sticks. These new auto-stick style transmissions are a blast when driving in the mountains. They give up nothing. Many are 5, 6 or 7 speeds too.
If you have lots of congested stop and crawl traffic, pass on the stick. If you're buying a sports car for sunday drives, get a stick. Nowdays, autos are very responsive to the kickdown and most shift at the horsepower peaks. With enough power, auto's do just as well at drag racing too. Take a test drive in an automatic version of what you want and see if it responds the way you want. M4-AK |
|
Manual transmissions, in general, are more fun to drive(if you don't live in a large metropolitan city). Automatics are nearly as efficient as manual transmissions.
That said, be aware that some brands have automatic transmissions that are high maintenance. Chrysler has had more than a few problems with their minivan and Durango slushboxes. GM autos fail when pulling loads if a transmission cooler isn't added. As for me, if the vehicle is a fun car (Miata, Civic SI, 'Vette, GTO or Mustang, I'd go manual. If it's a "grocery getter", then I'd get an automatic but it wouldn't be one with a bad rep! |
|
A slight twist. I've never owned a manual, and I just realized that I wouln't be able to shift while getting serviced. I guess automatic wins by default.
Oh yeah, the car is one of those economy coupes. |
|
More power to ya. I was really disappointed in the selection. My whole life I dreamed about having a new/newer car. Now There's only a handful I want. There is not one car/truck made by Ford, GM, or Chrysler that I like available with a manual transmission. I just think that's sad. |
|||
|
1. Name some cars that have 6 or 7 speed "auto sticks". 2. No clutch still means it's an auto 3. Still gonna break like an auto 4. The way autos kickdown is nowhere near like a manual where you bring up the revs before dropping the clutch so there is no lurch. 5. I will tell it where to shift, period. 6. That auto stick is going to overhead while you are "having fun in the mountains". 7. Tried 'em, no thanks. |
|
|
Yeah? Try for BMW's and some Lexus and I believe Acura is putting them into cars/suv's as well. Weird. |
||||
|
Never had a problem with that with a manual. Be sure you are in 1st, 3rd, or 5th. |
|
|
Actually, you can get the Dakota V8 with a manual and the Ranger V6 with a manual, unless they stopped that since the 2004 models. |
||||
|
The other consideration is if you are ever in a driving shootout...you better have the automatic otherwise you won't be able to get any shots off.
|
|
Fixed it. |
|
|
That is silly in this day and age. Autos are stronger on single axle trucks requiring gentle shifts to prevent damage to the drive train components (especially U joints). Autos are great while off roading while crawling over very uneven terrain without stalling the engine of the vehicle. Last but not least, a three or four speed automatic hotrod will clean the clock of a comparatively built rig with a manual in a drag race. I love a manual on curves and on the open road. Everything else is the realm of the automatic. |
|
|
My 1993 Volkswagen Eurovan is just shy of 200,000 miles on the original auto tranny. This argument is so 1975. |
||
|
BMW of North America says no such thing as an 8 speed. They do put a 7 speed in the M5. I will check on Acura and Lexus tommorrow. Really, it doesn't matter. Automatics are WIMPomatics no matter how many gears they have. |
|||||
|
*yawn* www.aiada.org/article.asp?id=46770 |
||||||
|
Any manual can be shifted when the load is removed. You can spin up the intermediate shaft by double clutching for smoother downshifts as well. If you hold a little pressure on the syncros when you upshift you will always catch the next gear. That is just driving a stick. If done properly it is actually easier on the car. Its not rocket science. If you are good, you can drive with the clutch linkage broken from work back to dry dock without using the clutch at all. That WILL be a little hard on the car, however. |
||
|
Many intermediate size work trucks have manuals to save the jarring of shifting with a large load. |
|||
|
6 OR 7 SPEED AUTOSTICKS? Doesn't the new Corvette auto use a 6 speed paddle wheel shifter (06) and the new Mercedes transmission is a 7, don't know about autostick in that. What about the SRT8 Charger it's an autostick but I don't know off hand how many gears. Besides with the auto, your torque converter acts like 2 more gears. At (stall) take off, it's another gear, and at lock up, a change of ratio due to no slippage. What about the new Caddilac STS V isn't it a paddle wheel 6? These are all new transmissions, so I'm not sure about the auto stick features, but I think the sporting models have them. I don't think an auto is a substitute on the road race track, but more most spirited driving maneuvers of a non "sports" car, I think auto's don't loose too much of the fun factor anymore. M4-AK |
||
|
You know you can down shift an auto right? |
||
|
Yeah, and you get a lurch, unlike a manual. All the argument aside, automatics are WIMPomatics. |
|||
|
My BMW is a 5-speed auto, my Maserati is a 6-speed manual w/paddle shifters and an automatic clutch. It also has an auto shifting mode.
BMW makes a very good automatic, and it shifts just fine. They are nothing like the crap automatics that domestic cars have had in the past. In the near future I see me getting the M6 when it comes out and i'm sure I will enjoy its 7-speed. |
|
If you buying a pick-up. Try and get the allison automatic. I have put over 250,000 miles on two of them with out any problems. Lot's of abuse and heavy towing, with chipped up engines. A friend of mine has over 10 newer Ford power stroke/automatics in his business and has had lots of problems. He's switching back to the GM /Allison comboon his next purchase cycle. Stay away from manual's unless your buying a porsche, c6 vette or "M" series BMW..........
|
|
wtf? i drive a stick and a manual and it seems to me that most ppl defend manuals because its "oh so cool". ive had the same dependability with my auto as ive had with my manual and theyve both done well |
||
|
Modern auto transmissions are computer controlled to match your driving. They are not your father's auto transmission. Fuel mileage is not a concern with either one. Your driving style is king of gas mileage. An auto transmission will tow about double that of a manual transmission, because of the way the gearing is engineered. I don't know the particulars, not an engineer, just check the manufacturers tow figures. Resale is higher for an automatic. Manual trannys usually are a deduction in the NADA books to the tune of $600-800.
|
|
Horseshit. |
|
|
No, I think he meant any kind of load. |
||
|
He is talking about 2x torque reduction... |
||
|
Driving a sporty car with an automatic is tacky and a dumb idea in general.
Kind of like running a race in army boots. On the other hand, nothing is to be gained by getting a big car or truck with a manual transmission. In short, get an automatic unless there is a very good reason to get a manual, such as the car is a high horsepower sports car. (not some focking ford focus gt) |
|
I've never owned an auto in 20 years of driving, probably never will
Get whatever you're more comfortable with. |
|
i prefer manual. If you dont worry about saving money, get the Automatic.
|
|
What I've found, at least in the truck arena, is that manuals have less towing capacity. I think it's because the auto makers tend to marry the manual transmission with smaller engines for economy. I'm sure that's different if you're talking about a performance car. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.