Quote History Quoted:
If you don't mind sharing... what happened with the carrier weld job?
I have welded up HK rifle carriers in the past without issue but have never welded up a MP5 carrier. It seems like it should be a pretty straight forward job but what happened on yours?
I plan on doing all the work myself (barrel swap, weld/remark, paddle, etc.) but if there is something out of the norm with the SP5K carrier that makes welding it a challenge I would be interested to know what happened.
I am still on the fence whether I want to weld the carrier to just mill the pin out of the receiver and use a factory german MP5K carrier.
View Quote
Sorry I took so long in responding. I am not sure what exactly happened but the locking piece will not fit into the welded carrier I received back from the shop that did the welding/milling. I tried three different locking pieces and none of them will fit the newly welded carrier. All three are interchangeable in other carriers (one welded, one semi and one full-auto). There is nothing obviously out of spec with the problem carrier. The shop that did the welding has been responsive and I am sending it back to see if they can figure it out.
Just speculating, but one opinion I got was that the heat from welding may have distorted the carrier ever so slightly but just enough to keep the locking piece from fully seating.
I will update this thread once I hear back from the shop that did the work.
UPDATE- The shop exchanged the welded carrier they sent me with another one that fits and functions just fine. They didn't elaborate on what was wrong with the first one but were very responsive and made it right. I am not naming names because I don't want to give anybody cause to be worried about doing business with a stand-up vendor.
Still, my personal,
non-professional, opinion is that I just don't like welded carriers. I have two guns that run them but I really prefer a carrier built with a full-auto profile from the start. Preferably HK factory but as long as it is built right, it doesn't make much difference to me. Again, just my ignorant opinion
YMMV.