I know you want to replicate the fragmentation characteristics of the claymore, but I wouldn't write off a single tube design so quickly.
Frankly, without constructing and testing it (legit tests, witness plates/targets and whatnot), we're both speculating on the effectiveness (or lack thereof) for such a design.
It may be an 80% solution (or a 20% solution).
Quantity has a quality of it's own, and I believe the simplicity, size, and weight may go a long way, depending on your use case. (This'll still be a hefty thing)
You could, for instance, place two of these together, 15-30° apart, and coverage might not be so bad. (Or maybe a two-barrel version with a frame that holds them at whatever angle makes sense)
As you mentioned, the volley gun will probably have the size of a rolling suitcase. At that size, you might legitimately want to add bicycle wheels and a handlebar and roll it around like a miniature field piece.
Also, the shot pattern of a large single barrel design can probably be tuned quite a bit with loading techniques and wad design.
A wad with overshot card will do one thing, an epoxied wafer of shot will do something else.
A giant flitecontrol wad would do yet another thing.
I'm not very familiar with black powder, but I imagine the different grades will burn differently and affect performance too.
You could also look at other techniques to shape a single barrel's shot output. Perhaps a square barrel would work? I'm not sure what sort of pressures black powder would generate in this configuration, but it might work.
Alternatively, giving the shot charge and powder charge a curve or bended shape may work, given the extreme diameter to length ratio of the barrel. Such a charge might shape the shot column into something along the lines of the claymore, wider than it is tall.
Maybe cut the barrel back on the left and right sides and could squeeze the top and bottom "flaps" in to have it act along the lines of a duckbill shotgun choke.
Lots of ways to approach it.
All that said, we know you can perfectly replicate the claymore with a volley gun, it's just going to be a tradeoff of size, weight, and complexity vs performance.
(At the extreme end, a volley gun with 700 barrels could replicate it perfectly, at a weight and complexity penalty)
I'm not sure if flechettes would work in this application.
I don't have any good cites, but my understanding has always been that flechette performance is typically underwhelming and extremely inconsistent when driven by a relatively low velocity, low pressure gun, like a shotgun.
I think the volley gun barrels would perform closer to shotgun barrels than anything else.
Something to consider, I don't know how consistent black powder ignites and burns compared with smokeless, but if the timing is not perfect or close to it, the barrels might fire slightly out of time and turn or move the gun, and throwing off the nice claymore pattern.
Ignition may need to be very controlled, or the device may need to be heavy enough that recoil doesn't move it much before all barrels fire.
All that said, I do want video of you taking a sounder of hogs with whatever you make.