Quote History Quoted:
@TOOL1075 is likely the best equipped dude to answer this question.
Note, it might help to list your priorities. Seems like:
1. Least [back pressure]
2. Weight? (Ti and K vs normal lines from OSS deduction)
3. ???
If you don’t mind a reasonable amount of length, a reasonable weight, indestructibility, and other neat [stuff], the CGS Helios QD can do some impressive math/science too.
3rd hand, anecdotal report tells me OSS Ti did fine with decent firing schedules and some F/A strings at a LEO demo. That buddy ordered himself a Ti version that same day.
View Quote
I am happy to jump in.
@AKDoc - I also shoot a transferable auto lower, suppressed.
You have a few choices:
1. You can ignore suppressor-tuning from the unsuppressed state and just go with a low backpressure silencer (OSS HX-QD series, CGS Helios DT, Dead Air Sandman-K) - this will mitigate "blow back"
2. You can tune/modify your gun to function with silencers that exhibit moderate flow restriction (back pressure) - this will also mitigate "blow back"
Many people do (1) because they are unable or unwilling to do (2), and that is totally fine. In my testing, the silencers listed above (and others) are able to keep flow velocity high while still suppressing sound. Some do it better than others. The Sandman-K has extremely low flow restriction but is very loud. The OSS silencers are quieter and still very low flow restriction. The CGS Helios DT is identical to a Hyperion K, but threaded 1/2-28tpi and extremely efficient at balancing flow restriction and suppression.
I personally do (2). I use a CGS Helios QD (an R&D sample of the Ti version) on my M16. My upper of choice right now is 11.5" midlength gas with adjustable gas block and Surefire OBC (their BCG that has many real enhancements; I consider it one of the best improvements to the Stoner system in the past decade or more). I can run this system suppressed/unsuppressed on the same gas setting, even with moderate back pressure silencers, due to its low gas sensitivity. I can do mag dumps all day with very minimal "blowback" through the ejection port, with brass ejection at 4:00 or whatever I want.
Blowback on autoloading hosts is a function of the host's
sensitivity to back pressure. This is what a lot of people miss. You don't necessarily need a low flow restriction (low back pressure) silencer to mitigate "blow back" (Option 1). You can make the gun work for you (Option 2).
I have quantified the flow restriction of many .30 silencers on my website with the PEW Science Omega Metric. It is an objective quantity that lets you know how restrictive a silencer is to energy efflux / mass flow rate. You can use this information to determine whether or not a silencer might be appropriate for your host weapon. Whether or not you need a low Omega silencer for your host is a function of your host's
back pressure sensitivity.Here is a link to my data:
PEW Science Public Research Supplement 6.40: The Omega Back Pressure MetricI hope you and others find this useful!
*Note - 5.56 bore silencers usually have higher flow restriction (back pressure) than .30 bore silencers. This is simply due to smaller orifice size, which decreases energy efflux and mass flow rate. I am excited to test the 5.56 bore OSS silencers and compare them to other dedicated 5.56 bore silencers!
Jay
PEW Science