I’ve used the hill people gear runner kit bag for backpacking carry over the past 5+ years. It’s more slim than the heavy, enough room for a g19x, map, phone, extra mag, fire starter, wallet, burts bees, compass, and a small benchmade. Pretty much everything you would want to grab quick without taking the pack off. Maybe if you wanted binos too the heavy would be better for the extra pocket or recon for PALS attachment of a bino case