Thanks for the responses. I wasn't aware that it was every really clarified whether the 26" minimum applied to every SBR or just those owned by reenactors. I can't find the actual law language right now but I remember that the wording of it could pretty easily be interpreted as meaning that the 26" minimum only applied to reenactors and not C&R holders. I also understand that the ATF was originally approving Form 1s for C&R-possessed SBRs with an OAL of less than 26" but then changed their minds and stopped. I guess it's all in how the law language is interpreted by the ATF or others that have a say in the matter.
I was just asking in case there had been any changes to this interpretation, either official or perhaps just C&R holders getting approval for shorter OALs.
The reason that I'm asking about all of this is that I'd like to Form 1 my Glock 17 and use it with a CAA Micro Roni carbine chassis. I know that some consider these to be goofy but I like the idea and I just think they're neat. Plus, I have an opportunity to pick a used one up for a song. I know that they offer a pistol version with a brace instead of a stock but there are some other changes to it and it doesn't appeal to me. Since I already have the Glock and I can get the Roni used for really cheap, I could have a swell little SBR for not much more than the price of a stamp. Problem is, the Micro Roni has an OAL of bit less than 23". I'm considering adding a permanently installed extension to the Roni barrel shroud to bring the OAL up to 26" but I'd really rather not. Looks like I probably will if I want to get it approved, though.