Quote History Quoted: I'm still learning, so bear with me please. If a close range optic is all I want, would there be any benefit to going with the Hogster-R 35 over the 25 or stimulus?
View Quote
I realize price is important because if a person has a 3K budget, it doesn't pay to look at a 10K Trijicon. However, the biggest things are FOV and magnification. If you are looking for a close range optic, you want a wider FOV and less magnification.
Hogster 25: 384x288, 17 µm, 1.4x native mag, FOV 14.9°, and can shoot comfortably to 150 yards. $2,355
Hogster 35: 384x288, 17 µm, 2x native mag, FOV 10.7°, and can shoot comfortably to 200-225 yards. $2,675
Hogster Stimulus: 256x192, 12 µm, 2.3x native mag, FOV 9.2° . $1,495
Super Hogster: 384x288, 12 µm, 2.9x native mag, FOV 7.5°, and can shoot comfortably to 300+. $3,195
12 µm 640 resolution thermals are awesome. 12 µm 320 resolution thermals are just OK. The 12 µm 320 sensors seem to make objects look very blotchy and the image isn't very crisp. The Super Hogster is different. It doesn't suffer from this nearly as much as other 12 µm 320 thermals because of the way they get to 384 12 µm by using a segment of a 640 sensor. However, my concern is what will a 256x192 look like if the 320 12 µm usually look blotchy. I won't know until I can test it.
So your question was would there be any benefit of going with the R35 over the 25 or stimulus? The only positive of the stimulus is the price. According to other early reviews, you loose a lot of image quality in comparison to the 25 or 35. The Stimulus is more a competitor to the ATN LT market. The 25 and 35 will have a better image and the 30hz response rate has been reported as showing some lag on the stimulus. I test almost all prototypes but didn't test the Stimulus yet. If you have the extra money, I would get 25 or 35 all day long. The more a person hunts real tight cover and shoots at mostly short ranges, the 25 is a great fit. For the person who wants to shoot both close and medium range, the 35 is the better choice. For the person who shoots a lot of different ranges including long range, the Super Hogster is the best choice. For the person who has a tighter budget, Bering made one option. It isn't nearly as good as any of the other options, but it is an option. I will know a lot more when I test it but others are confirming it is decent for what it is, but do yourself a favor and don't buy something just because it is cheap vs buying something that is a proven performer.