HD and SHTF are 2 entirely different categories. I don't live in Windsor Palace, trying to look down the hallway of my house through a magnified optic is no joy. That being said, I'm also not using a rifle for home defense because my kid's bedrooms are on the other side of the house and in the direction I would likely have to be shooting in the case of a home defense situation, over penetration is a consideration I have to take into account.
Quoted:
I put an Ultimak on mine with a mini RD. It works, and I'm sure entirely sufficient. That said I would 1000x take a decent AR first.
Honestly I wonder if the AK people have actually drilled with both. It was pretty obvious to me which one was superior in about 100 rounds. But opinions differ so use what you like I guess.
View Quote
You shoot and train with the AR more than the AK? If so, that's why you are better with an AR. An AR does have better ergonomics, but it's not some huge unspannable divide, it's just a matter of training a different manual of arms.
I got into AKs before I got into ARs and shoot AKs a good bit more, so I am faster on the clock with an AK than with an AR. It all just comes down to training and practicing.