Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
Armory Sponsor
12/23/2012 8:14:42 AM EDT
I shot this yesterday and could tell it had high pressure when I went to open the bolt. I brought it to work to show a guy what to look for and the primer fell out, that's what I don't understand. The primer wasn't cratered just flatten, is this common for the primer just to fall out ?

12/23/2012 9:13:38 AM EDT
[#1]

Was the primer pocket a " loose fit " when you seated the primer?

Also... You aren't enlarging the flash holes are you ?
12/23/2012 9:15:42 AM EDT
[#2]
If the web area expands from 1 over load or many maximum loads, primers fall out.  Brass that is loaded many times like 38 spec. light target loads, just wear out.   photos
12/23/2012 9:23:19 AM EDT
[#3]
I didn't notice any diference while seating any primers during that reloading session.  And no I don't enlarge the flasholes.
12/23/2012 9:36:00 AM EDT
[#4]
Details of the load and firearm, please.

That is way over pressure.

12/23/2012 9:49:17 AM EDT
[#5]
Savage Model 10 24" barrel
bullets 165 grain Hornady SST
CCI primers
Mixed headstamp brass
WC 846 surplus powder
OAL 2.800" (if memory serves me correct, it's the standard length that Lyman and Lee maunals recommend)

I was working on some load develpment for my gun and had charges ranging from 41.0 - 45.5 to find the the correct load for this rifle. That load in the picture was from the 45.5 grain. (And the only 45.5 grain I shot, I'm going to pull several of the different wieght charges and stay on the lower side.
12/23/2012 10:15:05 AM EDT
[#6]
 Dear Reloaders,

Here is my experience with 846 powder.
I started out with once fired 308 brass, LC05 military.
Trimmed to length, full length resized.
Primer = CCI #34 military primer.
Bullet= MBM80 150gr FMJBT bullet w/c.
Firearm= Springfield M1A standard model bought about 1987.
(It has been shot a lot over the years)

I started out with 40.5 grains which was a bit mild, but it did function the
rifle with no FTF, FTE, etc.

I worked up to 43 grains of 846 with the resulting chronograph reading with that load as follows:
43.0 GRAINS, 150gr FMJBT bullet.
1.  2725
2.  2698
3.  2708
4.  2749
5.  2718.
I tested the chrono with known factory military ammo and the readings were all around 2750 for this chrono indicating that
I was getting good data.

There were no signs of excess pressure with 43 grains. The primers were flattened some, but not beyond a normal expected amount.
I also went up to 45 grains with some signs of pressure as the primers were beginning to flatten more than with 43.0 grains. No blown primers with
any loads. I think I will stay at 43 grains for my loads, or maybe 42.5. I shoot at about 100 meters and the slightly reduced loads are fun to shoot and
they are all I need for the 100 meter range.

A military listing shows 45 grains of 846 for 147gr M80 bullet. Remember that this is also the load that functions an M60 so approach that load with caution.

You must understand that this is surplus powder and not canister powder. Canister powder is consistent from lot to lot as tested by
the manufacturer so that loading data will remain constant. So, this means that this powder may vary some from keg to keg as can ALL surplus powder from any dealer
and you should be aware of this. ALWAYS START with a reduced amount of powder and work up your loads to the level you want. Check for pressure, velocity, case
damage, primer flattening, etc. This powder will probably not vary much, but your results may be very different from mine. That is the nature of
surplus powder. You save quite a bit, but you must always approach it with care. You should approach ALL powder with care, even first rate canister powder
from the major manufacturers.

Some people say that blc(2) or H335 is equal but remember these are ONLY guidelines! Work up your own load with this powder that is best for your
rifle, your shooting range, your bullet and your special circumstances. You can’t get exact loading data so do your own.

Have fun. I really like this powder. It meters well, it is cheap, it is clean and looks brand new, there is no clumping and it gives an excellent grouping.
It looks like and meters like 748 ball powder.
I was shooting about a 3” group with iron sights at 100 meters off a sandbag.
Good for me and my old eyes and considering this is not a NM rifle. (not even NM sights)

Good shooting,
Stan Widener
 


Link
http://www.wideners.com/itemdetail.cfm?item_id=6673&dir=278|283|999
12/23/2012 11:19:47 AM EDT
[#7]
Quoted:
Savage Model 10 24" barrel
bullets 165 grain Hornady SST
CCI primers
Mixed headstamp brass
WC 846 surplus powder
OAL 2.800" (if memory serves me correct, it's the standard length that Lyman and Lee maunals recommend)

I was working on some load develpment for my gun and had charges ranging from 41.0 - 45.5 to find the the correct load for this rifle. That load in the picture was from the 45.5 grain. (And the only 45.5 grain I shot, I'm going to pull several of the different wieght charges and stay on the lower side.


I don't see evidence of high pressure in the photo -
But:
If the military load is 45 grains for a 147 gr. bullet, then your 45.5 load is on the high side - using a 165 grainer ( mag primers too? )
Remember the military load was designed for a shorter barrel " gas gun ".  The 24" Savage closed breech bolt gun doesn't dump pressure.

You need a chronograph ...
12/23/2012 11:43:42 AM EDT
[#8]
I don't see evidence of high pressure in the photo
 Its there, shows an ejector mark. Factory ammo will show this sometimes. How much it is raised will tell you if over pressure. If it catches on a finger nail, your too hot.  Photo starting on right, light load. Moving to hottest on the left.   Far left, primer pocket expanded, primer fell out.
12/23/2012 12:25:15 PM EDT
[#9]
Quoted:
Quoted:
Savage Model 10 24" barrel
bullets 165 grain Hornady SST
CCI primers
Mixed headstamp brass
WC 846 surplus powder
OAL 2.800" (if memory serves me correct, it's the standard length that Lyman and Lee maunals recommend)

I was working on some load develpment for my gun and had charges ranging from 41.0 - 45.5 to find the the correct load for this rifle. That load in the picture was from the 45.5 grain. (And the only 45.5 grain I shot, I'm going to pull several of the different wieght charges and stay on the lower side.


I don't see evidence of high pressure in the photo -
But:
If the military load is 45 grains for a 147 gr. bullet, then your 45.5 load is on the high side - using a 165 grainer ( mag primers too? )
Remember the military load was designed for a shorter barrel " gas gun ".  The 24" Savage closed breech bolt gun doesn't dump pressure.

You need a chronograph ...


Please please do not talk about what a "military load" was or is.  The Army ammunition data sheets information on weight of powders is useless.  Lake City and all the other folks that load for the military use non-cannister grade powders by the rail car.  Each lot of powder is test fired in test barrels for velocity and pressure acceptance.  Each lot of ammo is loaded based on this initial data and then each lot of ammo is accepted based on test firing those lots.  Take 852 powder for example, it was used to load 30 cal ball M2 (30-06 M2 152 gr ball) for M1s and Browning MGs and BARs.  Some lots were relatively fast and used about 52 grains.  Some lots were slow and used over 57 grains.  

When shooting pulldown military surplus powder, you need a safe start load for that specific lot of powder.  IMO if the supplier cannot supply that then you should walk away.

Using Army ammunition data sheets to determine start loads or safe loads is a dangerous practice.  

12/23/2012 2:22:01 PM EDT
[#10]
Quoted:
I shot this yesterday and could tell it had high pressure when I went to open the bolt. I brought it to work to show a guy what to look for and the primer fell out, that's what I don't understand. The primer wasn't cratered just flatten, is this common for the primer just to fall out ?

http://i1082.photobucket.com/albums/j379/brow_tines/8255E842-978C-4C14-BD5C-DE41736B4476-1453-00000502B9DEAEFA.jpg


Looks a little warm.  The ejector smashed the headstamp.

You found out where dragons be with that rifle and gunpowder.  The bad news is that when you get the next lot of W846 you should back down from the load you use with this one due to the variation in burn speed from lot to lot with these gunpowders.

If you fired only the one round,  I say mark it down to really good experience that can only be gained this way, then press on with a good load and pass your experience on to someone else later.

Armory Sponsor