Posted: 2/4/2006 6:56:04 PM EDT
|
well i have both, my series 80 came with a plug and i just put in a frame saver 1 piece. please weigh the pros and cons. |
|
Usually I would just say that have not shown to increase reliability, the only benefit normally being the extra weight out front helps tame recoil. They do complicate assembly. They may also ping the back of your suppressor if you are using one (depends on setup). However I use one in a particular slide upper I have in .45 because it allows me to pop out the slide catch and remove the entire slide assembly complete, then I swap it with my .22lr conversion kit, slide catch lever pin back in and away I go. It's a unique situation otherwise there is generally no use for it except weight. It's also harder to cycle one handed in certain tactical situations. |
That may be it. But, you now have the opportunity to find out.  And yes, I do know it for a fact, but you probably knew that.
|
The real question is, do you want the pain it adds to disassembly to lengthen the life of a very inexpensive part? I will bring my commander to the next shoot and let you disassemble it. |
|
I thought the GI plug was going to be a ton easier to take down than the Kimber full length I have now. Yeah, the springs are cheap, I'll probably just keep a few of those around. But this full length guide rod has got to go. It's kind of a pain. But still bring your Commander, just because its cool. |
I forgot about your new baby! 
|
From actual use?  Nevermind, I have no clue about such things. 
|
............ prove me wrong and I'll thank you for it, don't just run away.
|
If you have personal experience please explain it. I am relatively new to 1911 and prefer the GI guide rod because it is easy for me to dissemble with no tools. If you explain your reasoning why you like FL I might change my mind. But now you just sound like another want to be know it all going right to degrading others. |
|
I don’t know much about these 1911 thingys but I can tell you for sure a full length guide rod will never double the recoil spring life or prevent a quality and properly functioning recoil spring from binding or kinking. What they will do is stick out of the end of the gun when it’s locked out of battery and make the gun weigh slightly more and possibly improve the “feel” of some guns. |
|
First, a recoil spring won't "bind" in a GI setup (by the time it gets close to complete compression, it's almost totaly encased within the plug with the guide rod up thru the center.....no place for the spring to go, other than where it's supposed to! ). I've run both FLGR and GI setups. A FLGR SLIGHTLY complicates disassembly. On the other hand it does absolutely NOTHING to improve lock-up "tightness", spring life, remove crab grass, replace balding hair or improve your sex life (unless both you and your significant other absolutely love a dead-sexy FLGR  ). It's said that a FLGR improves feeding and extraction......it feeds the dealer who's selling it to you and exatracts $$$ from your wallet!  On the other hand, a GI plug assembly allows you to do two things that you can't do with a FLGR setup. By pressing the lower edge of the slide (directly on the plug) against a hard object, like a table edge for instance, you can cycle the pistol one handed. Also, my preferred way of doing a "press-check" is to hook the thumb of my non-shooting hand in the trigger guard, reach forward with the index finger of the same hand, place my fingertip on the plug and gently squeeze. No danger of sticking a finger or two in front of the "loud end" of the barrel, that way. YYMV, though........ LOL |
That's what I was wanting to know. Makes sense. |