Posted: 10/4/2009 10:12:02 AM EDT
|
if i do sell my 1911s i am going to buy 1 gun, mags, ammo , holsters and light.
which of these .45s would you suggest for someone with small hands as their only handgun for hd/sd/range/classes/matches/shtf? must be reliable . i can only have 10 rd mags unless prebans are around. M&P45 HK45 SIGP220 G21SF (is this too fat for small hands?) state why you choose the pistol you choose. all pistols are equally grabbing my attention and all seem extremely reliable. the M&P might be winning alittle since its made in the USA and is inexpensive with interchangeable backstraps but all contenders are very tempting. |
|
I guess I'd go with an H&K USP. Accuracy, reliability, and capacity. Of course there's the fucking light rail which is not standard.
On second thought, if the G21SF fits your hands, I'd go with that for all of the above reasons, plus it has a normal light rail. I have medium-sized hands and the regular G21 fits them just fine; I reckon the SF would be perfect for your girly paws. 
|
|
Quoted:
I guess I'd go with an H&K USP. Accuracy, reliability, and capacity. Of course there's the fucking light rail which is not standard. On second thought, if the G21SF fits your hands, I'd go with that for all of the above reasons, plus it has a normal light rail. I have medium-sized hands and the regular G21 fits them just fine; I reckon the SF would be perfect for your girly paws. They are girly. hate that. i was looking at the hk45 not usp 45. usp 45 is definitely too big as is the regular g21 |
| Personally, I'd skip the 220. I had one and recently sold it. Why? It was a fantastic weapon. I loved it. But it was just too big for my hands. I could shoot it well, but in order to get good direct trigger pull, I had to grip the gun in a slightly twisted grip. Just my .02. I'd look into the 21SF. It's on my list as well. |
|
Quoted:
the M&P might be winning alittle since its made in the USA The HK45 and HK45c are now being built in the USA at the new plant in Newington NH. Out of the guns you have listed I would take the HK45. The gun is dead reliable and feels great in the hand. I also find it to be just as accurate as most semi-custom 1911's that I have shot including a few Nighthawks. The only major issue with the HK45 IMO is that magazines are around $50 a piece. |
|
Quoted:
I'd take the M&P45 out of the group, but you won't go wrong with any. is the M&P45 not as good as the HK45, G21SF or P220? ive never shot either gun and wont get the chance to. Long island doesnt have a gun shop with this option. 
what if i introduced the G19 as another possibility? id only get one if i could find preban mags. |
|
Quoted: Quoted: I guess I'd go with an H&K USP. Accuracy, reliability, and capacity. Of course there's the fucking light rail which is not standard. On second thought, if the G21SF fits your hands, I'd go with that for all of the above reasons, plus it has a normal light rail. I have medium-sized hands and the regular G21 fits them just fine; I reckon the SF would be perfect for your girly paws. They are girly. hate that. i was looking at the hk45 not usp 45. usp 45 is definitely too big as is the regular g21 Out of what you listed, the HK45. I dumped my USP 45 due to the grips alone. The HK45 is just a fantastic gun, really a great shooter and as for the rail? It holds my X300 just as it should. I don't need it to do anything else.  |