Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
AR Sponsor
8/9/2017 11:22:08 AM EDT
I several bolt carrier groups from Brownells with bolts in 9310 steel.
One carrier group has a bolt in Carpenter 158 steel.
Is there a way to differentiate the two steels?
Thanks
8/9/2017 11:35:18 AM EDT
[#1]
Quoted:
I several bolt carrier groups from Brownells with bolts in 9310 steel.
One carrier group has a bolt in Carpenter 158 steel.
Is there a way to differentiate the two steels?
Thanks
View Quote


Not by looking at them, unless marked such.
8/9/2017 12:13:08 PM EDT
[#2]
Unfortunately, there are no markings that I can notice.
8/9/2017 2:21:00 PM EDT
[#3]
FWIW, I run both and have never had an issue in thousands of rounds.
8/9/2017 4:02:05 PM EDT
[#4]
Quoted:
I several bolt carrier groups from Brownells with bolts in 9310 steel.
One carrier group has a bolt in Carpenter 158 steel.
Is there a way to differentiate the two steels?
Thanks
View Quote

Energy dispersive spectroscopy?
8/9/2017 4:22:21 PM EDT
[#5]
If you don't have the proper stuff, you are not going to ID the metal used in the BCG,  and being honest there is really no reason to worry about it, when I buy BCG's what it is made out of is the least of my concerns, especially if you are buying from a reputable company.
8/9/2017 8:16:12 PM EDT
[#6]
Send them to a laboratory that does non-destructive testing.

OR....ask the manufacturers to provide the material certifications when they bought the material they made the bolt from.


That's it.



_
8/9/2017 8:33:09 PM EDT
[#7]
Quote History
Quoted:
Send them to a laboratory that does non-destructive testing.

OR....ask the manufacturers to provide the material certifications when they bought the material they made the bolt from.


That's it.



_
View Quote
Why?
8/9/2017 8:40:21 PM EDT
[#8]
Quote History
Quoted:


Why?
View Quote
Because.


_
8/9/2017 8:45:02 PM EDT
[#9]
Quote History
Quoted:
Because.


_
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Quote History
Quoted:
Quoted:


Why?
Because.


_
Deep.
8/9/2017 10:04:04 PM EDT
[#10]
Quote History
Quoted:


Because.


_
View Quote
Because is not a valid reason..

Now you sound like my kids when they were growing up and I asked them why they did something..

I don't know or Because!
8/10/2017 12:49:28 AM EDT
[#11]
There is one way, shoot them until the break the ones that lasted longer were 9310.
8/10/2017 12:55:29 AM EDT
[#12]
Quote History
Quoted:
There is one way, shoot them until the break the ones that lasted longer were 9310.
View Quote
Maybe.
8/10/2017 1:11:49 PM EDT
[#13]
Quote History
Quoted:
Why?
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Quote History
Quoted:
Quoted:
Send them to a laboratory that does non-destructive testing.

OR....ask the manufacturers to provide the material certifications when they bought the material they made the bolt from.


That's it.



_
Why?
Quoted:
Quoted:


Because.


_
Because is not a valid reason..

Now you sound like my kids when they were growing up and I asked them why they did something..

I don't know or Because!
It would seem that you have it backwards....

Children say "why".....adults say "because".

And regarding the answer I posted for the OP....

He asked what I considered a metallurgical question.

I gave him 2 valid ways to help him get answers  his questions. One is easy to do...one is expensive and time consuming.

But somehow, you either missed that, or don't understand it.

Don't fear or be scared of what you don't understand.







_
8/10/2017 1:25:39 PM EDT
[#14]
Quote History
Quoted:






It would seem that you have it backwards....

Children say "why".....adults say "because".

And regarding the answer I posted for the OP....

He asked what I considered a metallurgical question.

I gave him 2 valid ways to help him get answers  his questions. One is easy to do...one is expensive and time consuming.

But somehow, you either missed that, or don't understand it.

Don't fear or be scared of what you don't understand.







_
View Quote
I didn't misunderstand anything at all, I fully understood what you stated, I just didn't agree with it, and in the context of kids saying because, often times when I asked my kids why they did something the answer was "Because"

And once again, the only group of people I know that can take something so simple and make it complicated is AR owners!

8/10/2017 2:14:29 PM EDT
[#15]
Train left the tracks somewhere between "why " and "maybe".

8/10/2017 2:16:18 PM EDT
[#16]
Quote History
Quoted:
Train left the tracks somewhere between "why " and "maybe".

View Quote
Actually I think it happened at "I don't know"

Tig!

8/10/2017 3:01:16 PM EDT
[#17]
The one that does not have any molybdenum in it is Carpenter 158.
AR Sponsor