AR Sponsor
Posted: 2/16/2004 8:43:38 AM EDT
| Since this seems to be rehashed again and again, I thought I would go with a poll just to see what everyone's favorite 9mm mag block is. I am limiting this to the four in production that seem to be in common use. Any comments on why you like it are welcome! |
|
Quoted: I voted VM Hytech, but I don't know what it's worth. It's the only one I have used. I voted ASA, but just like Offspring said, it's the only one I have used. Although it doesn't have the last round hold open feature, I really am happy with the fit and function of this block even though I did have to sand down the top of the ejector slightly because it was binding my bolt. |
|
I voted VM Hytech because the work good. But I Ain`t real happy with there service. I called them 2 weeks ago about there replacement mag release the were going to GIVE everybody that bought there first gen mag blocks. First call they said they would ship one out the next day.I waited a week & called back. They said they had sent them out.That was a week ago & I Ain`t got nothin yet. Not very good service. |
|
I would have voted for the Hahn block but you didn't have it listed. I've used the Colt/RRA block. The Tacblock (crossfire clone) I think throwing the VM Hytech in that list is not fair as its like comparing apples to oranges. The VM Hytech is the only one that uses unmodified UZI mags. I think that is great!!!....but I already have 7 factory Colt mags. The Hahn block is very well constructed and I like that the mag well is flared. It is the ONLY block that I've seen like that. It makes for smoother mag insertions that are helpful for competitions. It has a wide roller that is adjusted when the block is in the receiver so it won't fall out. I like that better than the pins that are projected out on the Colt/RRA block. It also comes in the toploading variant like the ASA block if you don't care about the bolt hold open feature. I would take the Colt/RRA as my 2nd choice after the Hahn. |
|
The poll is kinda goofy, you have 3 blocks that serve the same basic function (ASA, Garrison, Rock River), they're all "Colt" pattern blocks, that allow Colt mags, or Uzi mags with an extra slot cut in hopefully the right place..... The Hy-Tech serves the same basic function as the "Colt", but allows use of in-expensive plain old everyday Uzi mags..... although you will need to clean up the opening in the block to accept the flat rear IMI mags, the block was cut to accept the military seam back mags. |
| I didnt vote at all...Im running a RRA block,...My RRA block will fit all types of mags freely(well except for the odd overspec SA mag),..But im not 100% happy with the retainer style,.Couldnt get mine to stay put without pinning,...If I could get RRA's fit with ASA's top drop in feature Thats what Id run....But the RRA is the only one I used so what do I know?[:)].............UDOG |
|
I think throwing the VM Hytech in that list is not fair as its like comparing apples to oranges. ...but it serves the same function. To reliably feed 9mm ammo to the Colt style system. I think it is fair to add it to the poll. I looked at all of the above named blocks when I decided on the VM Hytech. What sold me was the plug and play operation without the hassle of modifying magazines. I can see why someone would choose the traditional Colt or ASA type blocks in order to preserve the "look". It was a tough decision, but the Hytech was just too user friendly for me to pass up. |
|
Quoted: The poll is kinda goofy, you have 3 blocks that serve the same basic function (ASA, Garrison, Rock River), they're all "Colt" pattern blocks, that allow Colt mags, or Uzi mags with an extra slot cut in hopefully the right place..... The Hy-Tech serves the same basic function as the "Colt", but allows use of in-expensive plain old everyday Uzi mags..... although you will need to clean up the opening in the block to accept the flat rear IMI mags, the block was cut to accept the military seam back mags. In defense of my poll, there really are three different types of mag blocks as I see it- 1. top loader using original mag release, 2. bottom loader with set screw using orignal mag release 3. Top loader with uzi style mag release Meaning that by rights the ASA and Garrison should be lumped together. But as I am not getting paid to do a scientific poll and I am using this for my own "market research" to get opinions on all of them lumped together, I broke out the four I am interested in. So yes, the poll is goofy. You may also scold me for not putting a cover sheet on my TPS report if you like! [;)] (edited) To be honest, I am wrestling with two issues: 1. To have bolt hold-open or not to have bolt hold-open (i.e. go with Garrison) 2. To need to notch mags or not need to notch mags (i.e. VM Hytech) I have 10 uzi mags already, so really it comes down to do I want to pay $80 to have the conversion done so that I can use the standard mag hold-open button or suck it up and go with the VM Hytech which would save me $80 but probably end up on the floor once in a while when I hit the standard mag release. My purpose is to have an indoor pistol range capable AR15 with some decent recoil and mag capacity. I think I am willing to sacrifice bolt hold-open (at least until I can afford to have Joe Black convert a few uzi mags or the price on Colt mags comes down) but the mag button is a tough call. |
| I have an A.S.A. and is very happy with it. Have experience with the RRA and didn't like the set screw. Almost bought the pinned setup but didn't want to drill holes in the lower. The biggest advantage with the Colt system is the mag button placement, to use the other systems would take away that plus. I think it all boils down to how much money you can spend and how much work you can do yourself to reach the final goal. My $0.02 |
| I am going to build up a 9mm. All RRA stuff, kind of partial to RRA. The only thing I am not using is the mag block. I am going w. the Garrison block. Buddy of mine has one and loves it. I really don't care about the bolt hold open. As long as I can use the stock mag relese. Can train w/ the 5.56 or 9mm with out learning a new reload operation, except that I will have to cycle the bolt. Good thing anyway, just treat it as a misfire. |
|
I can honestly say I have tried them all. The one I shoot the most? THe original COlt set screw type. THe reason, I use the original COlt mags and like the mag hold open. Makes for faster change when doing comp shoots. My second favorite, and the one I suggest to first timers, the ASA drop in. The two piece types are cool, if you don't mind pinning and want a gun that is dedicated or you are using a conversion such as 45 or 10mm. and need the extra wide space allowd by using the two piece as opposed to the one piece types. The main thing is to get somnething to work and go SHOOT! [beer] |
AR Sponsor