Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
AR Sponsor
7/27/2008 1:04:23 PM EDT
I'm at about 3000 rounds in my rifle. The bolt fragged itself today mid-magazine.  It basically cracked in half in the middle of the cam pin hole.  The crack is in the vertical axis of the hole.  Is this a common stress point, or should I be looking for problems elsewhere?

I was shooting my reloads.  However, they were all well below the advertised maximum charge amount.  I was using 22gr of H335 with a 55gr Hornady FMJ.  I don't think this had anything to do with the bolt fracture, but I figured you guys would want all the info.  The empty casings showed no signs of overpressure.

The bolt was in the locked position, with a chambered round when I realized what happened.  I pulled the charging handle back to see the front of the firing pin looking at me.  I disassembled the rifle, and luckily I had a pick with a 90 deg. bend that I used to unlock the bolt.  I then hit the end of the upper assembly lightly on the shooting rest to dislodge the front of the bolt.  An unfired round fell out with it.

SOoooo..... what happened???  Do I just have a shitty bolt that decided to let go?  I don't own a digital camera, but I contacted my friend who does.  Hopefully I can get pics up soon.  

Also.... Where should I buy a new bolt?  



Edit-  I keep thinking about the reloads.  Im still in the early stages of reloading, and this is kind of scaring me off from rolling my own.  Im almost 100% positive the charge amount was exactly as stated above, but I suppose human error could have reared its ugly head.  Although, like stated above, none of the casings showed signs of overpressure.  Could an overcharged round cause this type of fracture?
7/27/2008 1:07:25 PM EDT
[#1]
Buy a Bravo Company bolt. Many of the pictures I've seen of bolt failures are a separation at the cam pin hole.
7/27/2008 1:12:54 PM EDT
[#2]
Thats where they typically break at. [cam hole] Replace, check headspace and drive on!
7/27/2008 1:14:28 PM EDT
[#3]
Who made your upper and bolt?
7/27/2008 1:17:24 PM EDT
[#4]

Quoted:
Who made your upper and bolt?


Olympic arms.  I know I know.  

But it has been a solid performer prior to this incident.  And it is responsible for my case of BRD.
7/27/2008 1:18:11 PM EDT
[#5]
As was pointed out above, that is a common failure point, and no, it was not your reloads if it failed at the cam pin hole.


PursuitSS
7/27/2008 1:19:38 PM EDT
[#6]
The bolt broke because it was defective.  Simple as that.
7/27/2008 1:23:50 PM EDT
[#7]
As a rule of thumb, with exceptions, bolts that are made to mil-spec (shot peened, magnafluxed, etc.) fail at the lugs, and everything else fails earlier, and at the cam pin hole. Note that losing a single lug does not render the rifle inoperable.
7/27/2008 1:24:03 PM EDT
[#8]

Quoted:
The bolt broke because it was defective.  Simple as that.



Nope. Or then they all are defective.

It's a very common failure point. Usually takes more than 3k rounds, but .mil bolts break there all the time too. If the lugs don't break off first.

BSW
7/27/2008 1:24:29 PM EDT
[#9]
ChuckBronson

Olympic arms. I know I know.

But it has been a solid performer prior to this incident. And it is responsible for my case of BRD.


Surprise Surprise...

folks just never get it...

EVERYTHING performs solid at first... until it breaks... That's why you spent the coin up front and get something better...

Your paying for material and QC testing that will lesson that from happening... get a BCM bolt and learn from this..

Just thing if you had spent a little more.. you would be at the range today and got more then 3K out of that bolt.
7/27/2008 1:27:00 PM EDT
[#10]

Quoted:

Quoted:
The bolt broke because it was defective.  Simple as that.



Nope. Or then they all are defective.

It's a very common failure point. Usually takes more than 3k rounds, but .mil bolts break there all the time too. If the lugs don't break off first.

BSW


If they break at 3K rounds they are.  Like others said.  The two outboard lugs should break first.

In rifle length gas systems, a good bolt can go well over 30k rounds.

I was an armorer for thee years before the M-4 became common and broken bolts were almost unheard of on a .mil gun.
7/27/2008 1:30:20 PM EDT
[#11]

Quoted:
ChuckBronson

Olympic arms. I know I know.

But it has been a solid performer prior to this incident. And it is responsible for my case of BRD.


Surprise Surprise...

folks just never get it...

EVERYTHING performs solid at first... until it breaks... That's why you spent the coin up front and get something better...

Your paying for material and QC testing that will lesson that from happening... get a BCM bolt and learn from this..

Just thing if you had spent a little more.. you would be at the range today and got more then 3K out of that bolt.



Lesson learned.   However, I did go into the gun store with the intent of buying a mini-14.  The guy behind the counter talked me into an AR.  I knew nothing about the AR15 platform at the time.   Now I know.   BCM bolt was just ordered from bravo company.
7/27/2008 1:36:02 PM EDT
[#12]
Glad you ordered a BCM bolt.
I will never use a non-MPI bolt in any gun I own, and I encourage others to do the same.
7/27/2008 5:18:32 PM EDT
[#13]

Quoted:
Glad you ordered a BCM bolt.


+1

Glad someone talked you out of the Mini14 too, even if they turned around and sold you an Oly.
7/27/2008 5:38:12 PM EDT
[#14]

Quoted:

Glad someone talked you out of the Mini14 too, even if they turned around and sold you an Oly.


Yeah, but now I have a full fledged case of BRD.  I have a RRA upper assembly on order that Im going to put on a cmmg lower I bought last weekend for Black Rifle number 2.  The 600 dollar plinker plus really got me back into shooting, and I think its going to make a nice "test" rifle for future reload recipies.

thanks for all your help guys.  
7/28/2008 2:16:16 AM EDT
[#15]
Doesnt olympic arms have a lifetime warranty?? You could still give them a call and tell them. Maybe they will send you a new BCG. You can keep that as a spare.
7/30/2008 3:19:01 AM EDT
[#16]

Quoted:
Doesnt olympic arms have a lifetime warranty?? You could still give them a call and tell them. Maybe they will send you a new BCG. You can keep that as a spare.


But if you do call them, be sure NOT to mention you were using handloads.  Oly will use any excuse to avoid honoring their warrenty. Tell them you were using Winchester factory ammo.
7/30/2008 9:17:04 AM EDT
[#17]

Quoted:


I was shooting my reloads.  However, they were all well below the advertised maximum charge amount.  I was using 22gr of H335 with a 55gr Hornady FMJ.  I don't think this had anything to do with the bolt fracture, but I figured you guys would want all the info.  The empty casings showed no signs of overpressure.




Edit-  I keep thinking about the reloads.  Im still in the early stages of reloading, and this is kind of scaring me off from rolling my own.  Im almost 100% positive the charge amount was exactly as stated above, but I suppose human error could have reared its ugly head.  Although, like stated above, none of the casings showed signs of overpressure.  Could an overcharged round cause this type of fracture?



I use the exact same componants to make my blastin rounds except I like it hotter and use 25gr of H335.If you are doing 22gr of it then they are light and you definately had an inferior bolt.in Illinois you are better off loading your own rounds, so keep it up.
7/30/2008 3:19:25 PM EDT
[#18]
I figured it was Oly or DPMS.

I'd have rather had the Mini14 than an AR made by either of the aforementioned companies.
7/30/2008 5:28:36 PM EDT
[#19]
Get a new Colt bolt.  Compare its 10k+ round expectancy to anything else and it becomes very cost effective.
7/31/2008 3:11:01 AM EDT
[#20]

Quoted:
Get a new Colt bolt.  Compare its 10k+ round expectancy to anything else and it becomes very cost effective.


Absolutely right!!!

Yeah, I've seen broken Colt bolts a time or two---after 10-12,000 rounds of largely full auto fire.

My ARs all have different makers names on the side of the lowers, but every one has a bolt and carrier marked "C"
8/1/2008 3:49:34 AM EDT
[#21]
I dont really see where the carrier makes much of a difference aslong as the gas key is properly staked and it has a shrouded fireing pin(if it isnt staked correctly you can do it yourself in a few min)...but I would suggest getting a LMT or BCM MPI bolt.
8/1/2008 2:02:21 PM EDT
[#22]
FYI the BCM BCG is just as good as the Colt and a lot less $$$$$$
8/2/2008 7:17:05 AM EDT
[#23]

Quoted:
FYI the BCM BCG is just as good as the Colt and a lot less $$$$$$


Hell, I picked up a couple of test fired only Colt bolt/carrier assys from CDNN a few years back for $100 apiece; the carrier in my class threed SP1 cost me $30 (in 1977) and is correct in it's staking (single punch) and right side hole, and the bolt/carrier assy in the arsenal remand M16A1 upper I bought for $300 a few years back was brand new (along w/the barrel)  Sold the upper w/o the bolt/carrier for what I paid for the thing w/the bolt/carrier awhile back. O yeah, also swapped an early issue Colt bolt/ carrier that I paid  $25-$30 for, back in the '70s, and some cash boot, for an even earlier Colt chromed bolt/carrier, awhile back.

You don't seriously think anyone with a lick of good sense would pay Colt's price for anything these days Hell, all my triggers, hammers, and disconnectors are demilled Colt M16 pieces bought at gun shows for 1/4-1/3rd what Colt wants new.

You can go w/anything you want, but to whatever extent possible, I'l stick w/Colt. Not saying there aren't other good pieces out there. It's just that If I can get a good condition milsurp Colt or FN piece I don't have to worry about  "did I get one of the bad batch that slipped through?"

Hell, Gonif; w/your screen name, I'm surpirised you didn't find a way to get your bolts/carriers for free

ETA:For those who don't speak Yiddish (or Australian slang) Gonif means "Thief"  
AR Sponsor