Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
Previous Page
/ 2
Next Page
5/18/2005 5:02:23 AM EDT
According to this article they are now recalling infantry who last served four years ago on a  two year enlistment.


Even Infantrymen Facing IRR Call-Ups


By Nathaniel R. Helms


Chris Bray knows the Army's dirty little secret: Now they're even going after the grunts.



After a year of bad-news reports that the U.S. Army has resorted to rummaging through the Individual Ready Reserve roster to mobilize soldiers with critical MOS designators such as Military Police, intelligence and medical, the personnel situation has become even more serious.



Even 11 Bravo infantrymen who have completed their active-duty enlistment obligations now find themselves the targets of a manpower-starved U.S. Army Resource Command, DefenseWatch has learned. And the Army doesn't want to talk about it.



But Bray does.



A 37-year-old resident of Hollywood, Calif., Bray is one of the IRR soldiers to receive his call-up notice recently. Bray, a teaching assistant at UCLA seeking to obtain his PhD in Political Science, said he joined the Army on a two-year active-duty program in May 1999 to earn money for college. Bray served 28 months on active duty as an 11 Bravo, assigned to the historic 29th Infantry Regiment at Fort Benning where his unit trained officer candidates preparing to serve as infantry platoon leaders.  



Until being recalled to active duty last week, Bray said his only claim to fame in the Army was receiving a commendation for successfully carrying out his duties as the designated driver in charge of transporting inebriated officers back home after a night of revelry at the Fort Benning Officer's Club.



Bray said he was initially alerted via telegram before receiving his "official" notification in the mail. "I didn't know they still used telegrams," he said. "I was out of town and my girlfriend opened it. It was a surprise."



The Army is beginning to fill its dwindling infantry ranks with Individual Ready Reservists who until now had appeared to individual call-ups according to a the Department of Defense plan put out last summer and never officially changed.



At that time an Army spokesman said the call-up was strictly limited to a small list of Combat Support and Combat Service Support personnel including truck drivers, military police, military intelligence, engineer support, medical and linguists.  



Several senior Army officials queried about the apparent policy shift declined comment and referred the matter to other commands without ever acknowledging a policy change was in the works.



Nevertheless, Bray and an undetermined number of infantrymen still listed on the IRR rolls have begun receiving letters from the U.S. Army Human Resources Command (HRC) ordering them to report to Fort Benning, Ga., for transfer to training commands in anticipation of combat duty in Iraq. The letters cite "By order of the Secretary of the Army," and are signed by Col. Deborah A. Cook, commanding officer of the St. Louis-based personnel center.



Lt. Col. Burton Masters, a spokesman for Cook, said she declined to respond to questions regarding the matter. While acknowledging that some infantrymen are receiving call-up notices, Masters said his office was not authorized to comment on inquiries about IRR call-ups currently underway or about policy shifts that would change what kinds of MOS specialties are now being recalled. Masters said the responsibility for answering lay with the Department of the Army.



Without question, there is a need for more infantrymen in the Army. A field-grade officer assigned to training soldiers for duty in Iraq said the need for infantrymen in the war zone is already critical.



"At first it was the 'three M's' – Medical, Military Intelligence and Military Police, but now there is also a shortage of infantry soldiers who have yet to be mobilized, or can be re-mobilized for up to another year if they have been demobilized prior to the two-year cap," said the officer, who spoke on grounds of anonymity. "Needless to say, the National Guard is running out of 11Bs [and] with recruiting down by 40 percent and the dwindling pool of mobilization-eligible 11Bs in the National Guard, the point of diminishing returns has been reached."



National Guard and U.S. Army Reserve soldiers comprise about 50 percent of the Army manpower in Iraq and Afghanistan, which is holding steady at 120,000 troops in Iraq and another 18,000 in Afghanistan. "Unlike the Active Army, they have the two-years [active-duty tour] restriction imposed on them," the officer said.



One solution is for Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld to go to Congress and ask it to lift the two-year restriction on extensions for Guard and Reservist soldiers, another well-placed Army officer said. However, an aide to one Democratic Senator on the Armed Services Committee said Monday that for Rumsfeld to do that would be a major political blunder.



"He already said we have enough troops in Iraq," the aide said.



Army spokeswoman Lt. Col. Pamela Hart told DefenseWatch she was unaware of any policy shift that authorizes the call-up of IRR infantrymen. That said, she indicated that any such mobilization would be a normal function of the Human Resources Command and not necessarily something she would need to know about.



"Wherever the need is, we send them," Hart said late last week. "We have 114,000 individuals in the IRR (Individual Ready Reserve), that is what they are there for. If there is a need for a particular MOS (Military Occupational Specialty) we go to it. If the MOS is what we need why wouldn't we? There is nothing unusual calling them if we have a need for them in the active Army. Calling up the IRR would be one option if there was a shortage."



In addition, the Army is using IRR troops that don't have infantry specialties to fill empty infantry slots. To do that, the Army has quietly adopted a policy called "In-Lieu-Of" (ILO) missions in which units perform operational duties outside their primary specialties such as non-infantry units providing infantry support for convoy protection and base security, or artillery units redirected to serve as Military Police.



Testifying before the House Armed Services Committee on Feb. 2, Army Vice Chief Gen. Richard A. Cody said the Army Reserve, to which the IRR belongs, has contributed 25 percent of the manpower required for those missions, and will likely be tasked to source up to another quarter of the remaining unit shortfalls, or 1,450 personnel, over the next year.



The IRR mobilizations, meanwhile, are taking place at a slower-then-anticipated rate, officials say. In January, the Army reported that only about 1,100 of the more than 5,600 IRR soldiers first ordered to report for active duty had been processed since the initial IRR mobilization was announced in August 2004. Since then, the Army has announced the call-up of an additional 6,000 IRR personnel for 2005, without providing any specifics about what MOS specialties are being targeted.



The mobilized IRR reservists continue to trickle in a few dozen at a time, said a Pentagon official who asked not to be identified. The Army still declines to say how many IRR infantrymen are facing involuntary call-ups for additional active duty.



According to the list of the "Top Twenty IRR" military occupation specialties provided by Hart that are currently under consideration for call-up into the active Army, there is no mention of the 11B infantryman MOS. They are:



1. Motor Transport Operators - 20 percent total called up

2. Automated Logistical Specialists (E-1 through E-4) - 12 percent

3. Light-Wheeled Vehicle Mechanics - 10 percent

4. Administrative Specialists (E-1 through E-4) - 7 percent

5. Combat Engineer - 6 percent

6. Food Service, Carpentry and Masonry Specialist

7. Petroleum Supply Specialist

8. Officer Combat Engineers

9. Cable System Installer-Maintainer

10. Construction Equipment Repairer

11. Shower/Laundry and Clothing Repair Specialist

12. Unit Supply Specialist

13. Human Resources Specialist

14. Water Treatment Specialist

15. Multichannel Transmission Systems Operator/Maintainer

16. Automated Logistical Specialist (Sgt.)

17. General Construction Equipment Operator

18. General Construction Equipment Operator

19. Administrative Specialist (Sgt.)

20. Quartermaster.



Doug Smith, spokesman for the Army Recruiting Command Headquarters at Fort Knox, Ky., told DefenseWatch it is currently short about 2,000 "11X" MOS recruits in the recruiting process. The "11X" is the pseudonym the Army applies to IIB (Light Arms Infantry) and 11C (Mortars) before the soldiers have been tested and classified while in Infantry Advanced Individual Training at Fort Benning, Smith said.



While Smith said that Fort Knox anticipates meeting its June 2005 goal for 11X-series soldiers, the Army as a whole continues to struggle with an ongoing recruiting shortfall. The active Army missed its April recruiting goal by 42 percent and the Army Reserve fell short by 37 percent, marking three months in a row the service has failed to meet its recruiting needs.



The Army is currently 16 percent behind its year-to-date recruiting goal and it appears will fail to meet its annual objective of 80,000 recruit accessions in the 2005 fiscal year ending on Sept. 30, officials say.



That translates into sudden life-changing telegrams for young veterans who thought they had fulfilled their Army service obligations.



When Bray called the HRC in St. Louis to find out what the telegram and letter all meant, he said he was put on hold for a long time. The individual who finally came to his aid apologized by explaining they were "very busy these days."



"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."



Bray, a student of military history, compared his impending service to American soldiers called to the colors during the Philippine Insurrection in 1899.



"It looks like the Philippines," he said of the unexpected manpower shortage. "The Army suddenly needed huge numbers of soldiers and thought it was going to have a short war. It wasn't. It is not a moral or ethical issue, although I am not convinced the war was well planned or the right choice. I walked into the recruiter's office and told him I wanted to do something interesting. He shows me a videotape of people shooting shit and blowing things up. I said it looked interesting and joined the infantry."



Regardless of what it looks like, the reality is there simply aren't enough infantrymen in the pipeline to meet the Army's current and anticipated needs in Iraq. How that shortage is to be filled is still a question waiting for answers.



Col. Al Schultz, a spokesman for the Office of the Chief, Army Reserve – a command DefenseWatch was referred to by the Army Public Affairs office – said it was a good question, a question that ought to be answered. Unfortunately, it is also a question to which Schultz said his command is unable to answer.



DefenseWatch Contributing Editor Nathaniel R. "Nat" Helms is a Vietnam veteran, former police officer, long-time journalist and war correspondent living in Missouri. He is the author of two books, Numba One – Numba Ten and Journey Into Madness: A Hitchhiker's Account of the Bosnian Civil War, both available at www.ebooks-online.com. He can be reached at [email protected]. Send Feedback responses to­ [email protected].

5/18/2005 5:03:59 AM EDT
[#1]

A "Backdoor Draf"...hmmmm...

All this talk about draft and the need for soldiers and I can't get in...
5/18/2005 5:07:26 AM EDT
[#2]
Oh Jesus Christ!!!!  It's like freaking 1899 all over again man!!!  We better have a drum circle protest!!!
5/18/2005 5:13:34 AM EDT
[#3]
What the article is not telling you is that in addition to the two years of active duty there was a certain number of years of IRR in the contract that he signed.  I'm guessing he signed a contract for two years active duty and six years IRR.  I know for a four year active duty enlistment, you a signing a contract that is for four years active duty and four years IRR.
5/18/2005 5:15:35 AM EDT
[#4]

Quoted:
What the article is not telling you is that in addition to the two years of active duty there was a certain number of years of IRR in the contract that he signed.  I'm guessing he signed a contract for two years active duty and six years IRR.  I know for a four year active duty enlistment, you a signing a contract that is for four years active duty and four years IRR.



bingo! You sign up for a minimum of 8 years, sometimes they let you out early and you get recalled at any time. I did 4 and 4 during the first gulf war. Never got called back tho.
5/18/2005 5:16:09 AM EDT
[#5]

Quoted:
What the article is not telling you is that in addition to the two years of active duty there was a certain number of years of IRR in the contract that he signed.  I'm guessing he signed a contract for two years active duty and six years IRR.  I know for a four year active duty enlistment, you a signing a contract that is for four years active duty and four years IRR.



What he said.  It isn't a draft.
5/18/2005 5:21:30 AM EDT
[#6]
What is it? Every able-bodied man between 18 and 45 is part of the militia?

We should all be prepared to defend our country.
5/18/2005 5:25:24 AM EDT
[#7]

Quoted:
A "Backdoor Draf"...hmmmm...

All this talk about draft and the need for soldiers and I can't get in...



Yep, they dont want me either. Stupid I think but that pretty much sums up the .Gov
5/18/2005 5:32:39 AM EDT
[#8]
thats not a draft. it a fullfillment of your contract if recalled.
5/18/2005 5:40:14 AM EDT
[#9]


Poor baby........

They signed on the dotted line.  It's nice getting all that free college money, until they have to EARN it.



Fuck em.  Pay the piper his due.

Works at UCLA too....... Why am I not suprised.

fucking worthless whiners


5/18/2005 5:51:24 AM EDT
[#10]
Let me get this straight, you sign up for eight years no matter how much time you actually spend in? I have a buddy who was 11b and got out just before 911. Is he on the list?
5/18/2005 5:52:42 AM EDT
[#11]
This is not a back door draft, it was part of their contracts they will now have to full fill. Nothing more nothing less.
5/18/2005 5:52:57 AM EDT
[#12]

Quoted:
Is he on the list?



Most likely, unless his eight years of obligation is up.
5/18/2005 5:54:08 AM EDT
[#13]

Quoted:
Let me get this straight, you sign up for eight years no matter how much time you actually spend in? I have a buddy who was 11b and got out just before 911. Is he on the list?



depends on how many years he completed. if he completed only 2 or 4 years, then he has the remainder on Inactive Reserves and could be called back at any time until he reaches the 8th year.
5/18/2005 5:57:13 AM EDT
[#14]
There's a reason they are called "Reserves" They are already trained. If they had to draft folks, they have to train them and it take more than just boot camp to do that.
5/18/2005 6:02:54 AM EDT
[#15]

Quoted:

Quoted:
Let me get this straight, you sign up for eight years no matter how much time you actually spend in? I have a buddy who was 11b and got out just before 911. Is he on the list?



depends on how many years he completed. if he completed only 2 or 4 years, then he has the remainder on Inactive Reserves and could be called back at any time until he reaches the 8th year.



I guess he's on the list. He's not the soldier type really, he joined for a shot at the Golden Knights and actually made the team but peered out. I think he only did two years in.
He wont like getting called up if it happens. What are the odds?
5/18/2005 6:02:59 AM EDT
[#16]

Quoted:
thats not a draft. it a fullfillment of your contract if recalled.



yup

8 years they own you
5/18/2005 6:38:32 AM EDT
[#17]
God bless the members of our armed forces... but the few whiners there are really piss me off.

You go in knowing the obligations. I had very closely considered getting into the military after I graduated high school in the late 80s. And even then I knew there was a 4 year period (IIRC it's longer if you're higher up, too) they could call you back after your period of duty was up.

Don't get me started on the National Guard or Reserve people that complain that they got dragged out of their homes for  active duty... That college money isn't free.
5/18/2005 6:44:41 AM EDT
[#18]
MY RECRUITER LIED!
My pussy hurts too!
5/18/2005 6:45:28 AM EDT
[#19]
well they better hurry up and call me then.
still on IRR till october 06.  but for 19D, not sure how low they are on that mos
5/18/2005 6:52:34 AM EDT
[#20]
back door draft my arse. Its SOP, at least they are using the IRR. Thats what it is ther for. Sheesh.
5/18/2005 7:08:43 AM EDT
[#21]
Why is it that when I was a teenager and enlisted, I knew the nature of my contract and the terms of my enlistment?
I was aware of what it meant to be IRR.

Yet people are shocked when they are called upon to live up to that contract.

If you  use the term "Backdoor Draft", you are essentially admitting that you are stupid.
5/18/2005 7:10:55 AM EDT
[#22]

Quoted:
Why is it that when I was a teenager and enlisted, I knew the nature of my contract and the terms of my enlistment.
I was aware of what it meant to be IRR.

Yet people are shocked when they are called upon to live up to that contract.

If you  use the term "Backdoor Draft", you are essentially admitting that you are stupid.





I couldn't have said it better.

5/18/2005 7:18:53 AM EDT
[#23]

Quoted:
If you  use the term "Backdoor Draft", you are essentially admitting that you are stupid.


that pretty much describes the media...i never met anyone who wasn't told by the recruiter what the deal was. same for the tamp class, they tell you to maintain your shit in the irr and to keep your info updated with mcrsc (now mobcom) in case you're called back.

recalls weren't just for wartime, either. i've known lots of guys called back cuz they had the experience that was needed for something or an mos was critically short...

i remember back in the day, before kids started learning computers at 3 or 4 yoa, the corps called a super geek back for some kinda project...guy went from making high six figures to lance coolie pay overnight! man, talk about PISSED! hahahahahaha

and i remember a married snco couple back in the early '80's who got a $100,000 reenl bonus cuz they were in the computer mos...

man, i sure missed that boat!
5/18/2005 7:24:50 AM EDT
[#24]
How come when people got called up for Gulf War I, you didn't hear a bunch of pissing and moaning about a "back door draft"?

The Vaginization of America continues.
5/18/2005 7:28:00 AM EDT
[#25]
Hmmm...all three of my MOS's are listed.  I think I have been out too long.  I recieved my Honorable Discharge 10 years ago.  Who knows maybe they won't find me.
5/18/2005 7:28:50 AM EDT
[#26]
"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."

Doesn't seem like whining to me...
5/18/2005 7:30:31 AM EDT
[#27]

Quoted:
Why is it that when I was a teenager and enlisted, I knew the nature of my contract and the terms of my enlistment?
I was aware of what it meant to be IRR.

Yet people are shocked when they are called upon to live up to that contract.

If you  use the term "Backdoor Draft", you are essentially admitting that you are stupid.



I was wondering the same thing.  It was VERY clear when I enlisted in '86 what the deal was.  And they say that the quality and intelligence of  enlistees is getting better??
5/18/2005 7:30:46 AM EDT
[#28]

Quoted:
What is it? Every able-bodied man between 18 and 45 is part of the militia?

We should all be prepared to defend our country.



from what?

this guy signed up for 8 years or not whether he realized it is not a issue.
5/18/2005 7:31:19 AM EDT
[#29]
My uncle was in the army around ten years ago and he's being recalled.
5/18/2005 7:31:57 AM EDT
[#30]

Quoted:
"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."

Doesn't seem like whining to me...



The mere fact that he's making this a public issue is whining (like a little girl).  Tossing out "I'm happy to do it" is a thinly veiled attempt to reduce all the "cry baby" accusations.

5/18/2005 7:36:45 AM EDT
[#31]

Quoted:
My uncle was in the army around ten years ago and he's being recalled.



wow is he a officer?
5/18/2005 7:36:46 AM EDT
[#32]

Quoted:

Quoted:
"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."

Doesn't seem like whining to me...



The mere fact that he's making this a public issue is whining (like a little girl).  Tossing out "I'm happy to do it" is a thinly veiled attempt to reduce all the "cry baby" accusations.




+1  Where is the govt denying any of this?  As a matter of fact they put it in writing, on his contract.
5/18/2005 7:38:43 AM EDT
[#33]

Quoted:

Quoted:
My uncle was in the army around ten years ago and he's being recalled.



wow is he a officer?



most likely
5/18/2005 7:39:41 AM EDT
[#34]
Wow.  The .mil expects people to honor contracts that they sign??

Unbelieveable.
5/18/2005 7:43:16 AM EDT
[#35]
IT is not a back door draft. It has been like this since Jesus was a corpral. 4 years=4 years IRR,
2 years active= 6 years IRR. It is all in contract when you sign up.
5/18/2005 7:46:37 AM EDT
[#36]

Quoted:

Quoted:

Quoted:
My uncle was in the army around ten years ago and he's being recalled.



wow is he a officer?



most likely


or retired.
5/18/2005 7:50:55 AM EDT
[#37]
Did my 8 for the beloved Corps. If the situation was different here on the homefront, I would be back in.

5/18/2005 7:51:53 AM EDT
[#38]

Quoted:
"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."

Doesn't seem like whining to me...



What the hell does this douchebag want?  A personal letter to every citizen, detailing EXACTLY what the military is doing?

ETA:

SHIT FIRE!!! POST 1000!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Have mercy! I MADE IT!!!!!!!

Google 1000 Image search:


5/18/2005 8:09:02 AM EDT
[#39]

The Vaginization of America continues.


HAHAHAHAHAAH!!!!

Clearly, you can see the slant in this "report". I bet if you polled the writiers feeling about Iraq, you;d find he's like every other "combat veteran from vietnam" who opposes the war. Sandy Vagina syndrome if you ask me.

Me...I'm waiting for the call to SRP and premob, its almost inevitable as an 11Chuck. Screw it, I'll go drop rounds for a year!
5/18/2005 8:30:49 AM EDT
[#40]

Quoted:

Quoted:
"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."

Doesn't seem like whining to me...



The mere fact that he's making this a public issue is whining (like a little girl).  Tossing out "I'm happy to do it" is a thinly veiled attempt to reduce all the "cry baby" accusations.




Actually, I doubt that. This guy was a moderately well-known writer for Reason and Suck before he decided to join the Army - which he did before 9/11 and certainly not because he had to do it. I've chatted with him a few times over the Internet and I don't doubt he is telling the truth when he says he doesn't mind going.

He just wants to make the point that the Pentagon is claiming that they are only using the IRR to fill a few critical specialties when it seems from this activation that they are using it to recall 11-series soldiers. Being one of those libertarian-types, he probably got pissed to see the government misrepresenting exactly who was getting called up through the IRR and being a former journalist, he had easy access to people happy to tell his story.
5/18/2005 9:47:10 AM EDT
[#41]
Sure sounds like he's creating a straw man from which to launch his argument.

When exactly did the Pentagon put out statements detailing qualifiers on their IRR recall policy?
5/18/2005 9:49:07 AM EDT
[#42]

Quoted:
A "Backdoor Draf"...hmmmm...

All this talk about draft and the need for soldiers and I can't get in...




EGGS ACT LY!

I am 40 and have a bad back...but come on.

I'll take a desk job anywhere if it will help my country!

SGatr15
5/18/2005 9:52:30 AM EDT
[#43]

Quoted:
"I'm happy to do it, happy to serve my country," Bray added. "What I don't like is they are not telling the country they are calling back infantry. I want them to say what they are doing and be honest."

Doesn't seem like whining to me...



SUre it is.

The guy isn't being honest about what his military obligations are.

ANd then he is bitching about having to fullfill his committeement.



SGatr15
5/18/2005 10:10:59 AM EDT
[#44]

Quoted:
How come when people got called up for Gulf War I, you didn't hear a bunch of pissing and moaning about a "back door draft"?

The Vaginization of America continues.



There was.  There were some doctors that I remember reading about getting called up an complaining about it.  Same story, money for school.
5/18/2005 10:22:36 AM EDT
[#45]
Wasn't there a deal where you could keep signing up for the IRR? Added so many points to your retirement?
5/18/2005 10:47:33 AM EDT
[#46]
Its part of the contract. You sign, you honor the contract. I am sick of dipshits whining about the 'backdoor draft'.
5/18/2005 10:50:21 AM EDT
[#47]
god journalists are fucking retarded
5/18/2005 10:52:13 AM EDT
[#48]
Is there anyway to sign up without going into IRR after you finish active duty?
5/18/2005 11:00:35 AM EDT
[#49]
I can't believe these frigging whiners.  If you sign up to serve you are signing up for a minumum of an 8 year enlistment.  Your initial enlistment, whether it be 2 or 4 years but 4 or 6 in the IRR, respectivley.  There are steps that could have been taken to prevent this from being such a " Surprise".

1.  Read your goddamn enlistment contract.
2.  Pay a little more attention in Boot, it was explained to me several times over the first few weeks, and again upon seperation from service at the end of my 1st enlistment.  

Only in America can you expect to see people whining over having to actually finish what they started.  Bravo to all those trying to get in now, sorry you can't.  
5/18/2005 11:20:35 AM EDT
[#50]

Quoted:
Is there anyway to sign up without going into IRR after you finish active duty?



There sure is.  You simply have to sign up for 8 years active duty.  
Previous Page
/ 2
Next Page