Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
1/13/2025 3:15:33 PM EDT
I've done a lot of reading and narrowed it down to either the 55BN from Sparks or the Scabbard from Kramer in horsehide for either one and FBI tilt. They are pretty much the same thing, but I'm curious if anyone can shed any light on if one carries better or more comfortably.

This is for a CZ 75 PCR. I'm not really going for concealed as I mainly just carry when hiking, hunting, camping.

However, I must have old injury or something because my current holsters always seem to tip out slightly and push the barrel or lower part of the holster into my hip and it presses in a way that's fairly uncomfortable. I can't find a position that works so I'm hoping to find a better holster that won't tip out and this design seems promising.

I don't think it's a belt issue as I've tried several different thick and stiff ones and they are all about the same. There is just something about how they ride that doesn't work for me. Maybe my holsters ride too low or something.

Thanks.
1/13/2025 4:33:54 PM EDT
[#1]
Own one Kraemer IWB rig for P-35.  It is well made but un necessarily stiff/hard and took a bit of oiling and waxing to get the pistol to release.  I have a BN55 Sparks for a 1911 that is beyond reproach; comfortable, fast and protects the front sight.  I have 1 Kraemer and 5 Sparks holsters if that says anything, but Sparks takes a while to get.
1/13/2025 5:59:39 PM EDT
[#2]
I have a Kramer IWB and multiple Milt Sparks holsters for a 5" 1911, including a 55BN.
The Kramer resides in my holster box while the Sparks holsters are stored with the guns.
Take that for what it's worth.
"The right to buy weapons is the right to be free"
1/13/2025 9:30:12 PM EDT
[#3]
Quote History
Originally Posted By Mindless:
Own one Kraemer IWB rig for P-35.  It is well made but un necessarily stiff/hard and took a bit of oiling and waxing to get the pistol to release.  I have a BN55 Sparks for a 1911 that is beyond reproach; comfortable, fast and protects the front sight.  I have 1 Kraemer and 5 Sparks holsters if that says anything, but Sparks takes a while to get.
View Quote

Thanks. That's what I was wanting to hear. Are any of your Sparks holsters horsehide? I'm wondering how much of the stiffness is due to the leather. I'm interested in trying a horsehide holster so if I get the Sparks will get it with horsehide.
1/13/2025 10:02:28 PM EDT
[Last Edit: tortilla-flats][Edited] [#4]
I carried a 1911 for decades in a Kramer Scabbard, horsehide, FBI tilt. Great holster but I never tried the 55BN although I've used other Milt Sparks products.

Tom Sawyer.

"If The Rules brought us to this, what use are they?"
1/13/2025 10:07:11 PM EDT
[#5]
One "trick" I learned about ordering Milt Sparks holsters, that likely would have resulted in me owning more of their product, was that you can change your order prior to them making it. So a lot of people just jump on the list and then when they get near the top of the list, they'll call in and update their order with what they really want/need at that point in time.

Tom Sawyer.

"If The Rules brought us to this, what use are they?"
1/13/2025 11:13:56 PM EDT
[#6]
I've never owned a Sparks OWB holster and probably never will. I've owned several of their IWB VMII holsters and only one has been usable. Every single Kramer I've ever owned has been good to go right off the bat. I currently own and use three of their Belt Scabbard models. If the barrel has a tendency to tip in, you could always try ordering a holster for a longer barrel version* or use those foam wedges meant for appendix holsters.

*If carrying a G26, use a holster for a G19, etc.
1/14/2025 12:11:35 PM EDT
[#7]
Quote History
Originally Posted By pokey074:
I've never owned a Sparks OWB holster and probably never will. I've owned several of their IWB VMII holsters and only one has been usable. Every single Kramer I've ever owned has been good to go right off the bat. I currently own and use three of their Belt Scabbard models. If the barrel has a tendency to tip in, you could always try ordering a holster for a longer barrel version* or use those foam wedges meant for appendix holsters.

*If carrying a G26, use a holster for a G19, etc.
View Quote
Isn't it great that we have such a variety of quality holster makers to choose from today!
"The right to buy weapons is the right to be free"
1/14/2025 2:58:59 PM EDT
[#8]
I placed an order for the Sparks 55BN, but given the long wait I'm wondering if there might be something else to try that's not as expensive. Craft? Bianchi? Something else?
1/14/2025 10:53:57 PM EDT
[#9]
Quote History
Originally Posted By MoonDancer:
Isn't it great that we have such a variety of quality holster makers to choose from today!
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Quote History
Originally Posted By MoonDancer:
Originally Posted By pokey074:
I've never owned a Sparks OWB holster and probably never will. I've owned several of their IWB VMII holsters and only one has been usable. Every single Kramer I've ever owned has been good to go right off the bat. I currently own and use three of their Belt Scabbard models. If the barrel has a tendency to tip in, you could always try ordering a holster for a longer barrel version* or use those foam wedges meant for appendix holsters.

*If carrying a G26, use a holster for a G19, etc.
Isn't it great that we have such a variety of quality holster makers to choose from today!
Indeed, although it's sad to see old-school leather makers like Alessi, Del Fatti, FIST, etc. either defunct or severely curtailed.
1/15/2025 12:27:40 AM EDT
[#10]
www.privateerleather.com
1/15/2025 12:58:32 AM EDT
[#11]
Check and see what stock Mitch Rosen has. They have a line specifically geared to turning out quick for popular models.
Tom Sawyer.

"If The Rules brought us to this, what use are they?"
1/15/2025 1:40:52 AM EDT
[Last Edit: Cyberpunk1981][Edited] [#12]
I just ordered myself a belt scabbard for an HK45 and HK45c.  I need them with a thumb-break so they were kind enough to add them for me.  The lady I spoke to over the phone was very nice and helpful.  I have a few of their holsters for other guns and I am pleased with their retention.  The Horsehide is like kydex and my holsters snap into place.  I would suggest checking Ebay as I often see a lot of Kramer holsters on there for sale.  The prices are sometimes pretty reasonable.  If you do go with Kramer holsters they told me they are at a 14-16 week wait.
2/16/2025 2:34:08 PM EDT
[#13]
Another tip with sparks is order through a dealer rather than direct. They will make a few orders a year and if you can catch one prior to sending in final order you can get one faster. Waited six months for one I ordered and about a month for the one I ordered through a dealer.
2/16/2025 3:23:02 PM EDT
[#14]
Kramer's vertical scabbards and IWB holsters are great.  I don't care for their regular belt scabbard because of the way they form the belt loops.  The two I've had looked like the person forming the holster had a seizure while making the loops, and the holster wouldn't ride against the body like it was supposed to.  Butt wanted to tip out away from the body.  They don't seem to have that problem with the rear loop on the vertical scabbard for some reason.
2/16/2025 3:43:59 PM EDT
[#15]
Sparks all the way, but that is just my opinion. Both are serviceable, Sparks gives ME a sense of ownership that the others can't match.
Lead, follow, or get the hell out of the way!
2/16/2025 3:52:12 PM EDT
[#16]
Originally Posted By phdog:
I've done a lot of reading and narrowed it down to either the 55BN from Sparks or the Scabbard from Kramer in horsehide for either one and FBI tilt. They are pretty much the same thing, but I'm curious if anyone can shed any light on if one carries better or more comfortably.
View Quote



I have the MS VMAXII and can not give it higher praise.

Comfortable, has lasted years now and is still solid.

Best of luck
2/16/2025 9:43:38 PM EDT
[#17]
I have multiples of both and use both regularly.

Ryan grizzle makes an equal product with a shorter wait time fwiw.

Those 3 makers are really the only 3 I like for concealed carry and I prefer horsehide.

Do Good
Be Dangerous
Live Free
2/16/2025 10:59:25 PM EDT
[#18]
I’m not going to knock any brand, style, or method mentioned in this thread. Have owned them all and they are great. I also really like TTGunleather out of Cali. I have numerous holsters from Tim. Quality is equal to anything you can purchase on the internet.

https://www.ttgunleather.com/
2/17/2025 2:36:02 PM EDT
[Last Edit: Andrewsky][Edited] [#19]
Leather Beretta 92 holsters work perfectly fine with CZ75s.  The Galco Fletch for a Beretta 92 would be my choice.  

I have a Kramer for my CZ75.  It's not great.  The fit was loose, although I fixed it by stitching in another row like in the photo (near the trigger guard).  It doesn't ride that comfortably on the belt and hip either.
Attached File


4/11/2025 1:13:12 PM EDT
[#20]
I have both a Milt Sparks 55BNHS and a Kramer Belt  Scabbard for 1911s. I personally find that the quality is similar and can't give an edge to either, but the Kramer carries more comfortably.
5/3/2025 7:44:22 PM EDT
[#21]
I own several Milt Sparks holsters, including a 55BN I use for a fullsize M9. I love it. I can honestly say I never in a million years would think my holsters would double in value. The VM2s and the 55BN I have are all black horsehide and were around $100 back when I bought them. Great holsters.
5/3/2025 9:06:32 PM EDT
[#22]
In my opinion Sparks is more 2A friendly than Kramer. I wouldn't spend a dime with Kramer.
YMMV.
5/3/2025 9:23:14 PM EDT
[#23]
Quote History
Originally Posted By JTMcC:
In my opinion Sparks is more 2A friendly than Kramer. I wouldn't spend a dime with Kramer.
YMMV.
View Quote

Could you elaborate a bit didn’t realize Kramer wasn’t.
5/3/2025 9:32:19 PM EDT
[#24]
Quote History
Originally Posted By Gunnie357:

Could you elaborate a bit didn’t realize Kramer wasn’t.
View Quote


Yeah, this.

I'm a big fan of Kramer holsters and would like to know if I shouldn't be.
5/3/2025 11:47:25 PM EDT
[#25]
I wouldn't say you shouldn't be a Kramer fan, but I'm not.

A lot of people on this forum would agree 100% with him.
They are in Washington state I believe. Where I live, people open carry a lot, nobody cares. Several years ago Kramer made comments about anybody open carrying, being an idiot. That's a no go for me.
Feel free to dissagree, most everybody east of the Mississippi does

In my area, it's a no brainer especially in hot weather.
5/4/2025 7:39:31 AM EDT
[#26]
Quote History
Originally Posted By JTMcC:
I wouldn't say you shouldn't be a Kramer fan, but I'm not.

A lot of people on this forum would agree 100% with him.
They are in Washington state I believe. Where I live, people open carry a lot, nobody cares. Several years ago Kramer made comments about anybody open carrying, being an idiot. That's a no go for me.
Feel free to dissagree, most everybody east of the Mississippi does

In my area, it's a no brainer especially in hot weather.
View Quote

Well that’s a shitty thing to say. I don’t necessarily think open carry promotes comfort with people carrying a firearm in public like some claim but it’s certainly an acceptable method in lots of places and I do it from time to time. It’s a wholly area specific method to blanket that everyone doing it are idiots is a bold move from a holster company.
5/4/2025 8:10:05 AM EDT
[#27]
Quote History
Originally Posted By JTMcC:
I wouldn't say you shouldn't be a Kramer fan, but I'm not.

A lot of people on this forum would agree 100% with him.
They are in Washington state I believe. Where I live, people open carry a lot, nobody cares. Several years ago Kramer made comments about anybody open carrying, being an idiot. That's a no go for me.
Feel free to dissagree, most everybody east of the Mississippi does

In my area, it's a no brainer especially in hot weather.
View Quote


To be fair, a lot of people on this forum say the same thing.

I used to live in AZ and open carried frequently.  I don't consider myself an idiot.

Back on topic, I love Kramer holsters.  Been using them for EDC @ 20 years now.  Nothing wrong with Milt Sparks, but Kramer has been getting the job done for me for a long time.

Sign up to continue the discussion

Create a free account to share your thoughts, follow topics, and connect with the AR15.COM community.

Already a member? Sign In