Joined:
Sep 2022
Posts:
12
EE: 0% (0)
IL, USA
Posted: 10/2/2022 4:27:11 PM EDT
|
Came across the EAA GIRSAN MC28SA 9MM TITANIUM TUTONE for $290. It looks like a really nice Glock Copy. My buddy is looking for a quality low priced HG. Any replies are appreciated. |
|
Attached File Same exact model you were looking at... Originally Posted By sparky923: Get one! The magazine safety is REALLY easy to remove.  Now removing the striker assembly from your orbital is a bit more challenging.
|
|
Originally Posted By Capt_Destro: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/333164/Grenade_PNG-2548102.JPG Same exact model you were looking at... Now removing the striker assembly from your orbital is a bit more challenging. What is the whole story on these pics? Looks like there was a kaboom since the side of the frame is missing. Enough over pressure could just as likely cause that with a whole raft of striker fired designs. We need the details! @Capt_Destro |
One well at a time, Drill Baby Drill!
If you need more than 8 rounds in a 1911 to solve your problem, you need friends with rifles.
I don't need your PERMISSION in order to voice my OPINION
If you need more than 8 rounds in a 1911 to solve your problem, you need friends with rifles.
I don't need your PERMISSION in order to voice my OPINION
|
Originally Posted By 44-40pro: What is the whole story on these pics? Looks like there was a kaboom since the side of the frame is missing. Enough over pressure could just as likely cause that with a whole raft of striker fired designs. We need the details! Did you miss the part where the striker is in dude's eye? |
Seriously, a tractor dealer from Possum Trot, KY has to explain this to you, a lawyer? - JPL
WTB: Glock 17 gen 2. SN CAF 895
WTB: Glock 17 gen 2. SN CAF 895
|
Originally Posted By 44-40pro: What is the whole story on these pics? Looks like there was a kaboom since the side of the frame is missing. Enough over pressure could just as likely cause that with a whole raft of striker fired designs. Hence the Striker embedding in the dude's eye. We need the details! @Capt_Destro Originally Posted By 44-40pro: Originally Posted By Capt_Destro: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/333164/Grenade_PNG-2548102.JPG Same exact model you were looking at... Now removing the striker assembly from your orbital is a bit more challenging. What is the whole story on these pics? Looks like there was a kaboom since the side of the frame is missing. Enough over pressure could just as likely cause that with a whole raft of striker fired designs. Hence the Striker embedding in the dude's eye. We need the details! @Capt_Destro Just something I stumbled across last year. IIRC the back plate was plastic with no reinforcement. From what I read the striker channel design doesn't have any other openings iirc? So this made the pressure from the kaboom a bit worse than other handguns. I could be wrong on that. If I had to go Turkish I'd go with a different model imo. Girsan makes some decent stuff as long as it's a M9 or 1911 clone. @OP I'd get the Canik or Sarsilmaz SAR9 on a budger if you are buying Turkish. For budget American brands: PSA Dagger, S&W SDVE/Ruger Double Stack/Beretta APX for a cheap 9mm. https://www.ar15.com/forums/general/Turkish-handgun-kaboom-Have-we-done-this-yet-/5-2435458/&page=2 |
|
Originally Posted By Capt_Destro: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/333164/Grenade_PNG-2548102.JPG Same exact model you were looking at... Now removing the striker assembly from your orbital is a bit more challenging. Originally Posted By Capt_Destro: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/333164/Grenade_PNG-2548102.JPG Same exact model you were looking at... Originally Posted By sparky923: Get one! The magazine safety is REALLY easy to remove. Now removing the striker assembly from your orbital is a bit more challenging. According to EAA, that isn't a MC28SA. |
DUPE police are Karens.
|
Originally Posted By Capt_Destro: Just something I stumbled across last year. IIRC the back plate was plastic with no reinforcement. From what I read the striker channel design doesn't have any other openings iirc? So this made the pressure from the kaboom a bit worse than other handguns. I could be wrong on that. If I had to go Turkish I'd go with a different model imo. Girsan makes some decent stuff as long as it's a M9 or 1911 clone. @OP I'd get the Canik or Sarsilmaz SAR9 on a budger if you are buying Turkish. For budget American brands: PSA Dagger, S&W SDVE/Ruger Double Stack/Beretta APX for a cheap 9mm. https://www.ar15.com/forums/general/Turkish-handgun-kaboom-Have-we-done-this-yet-/5-2435458/&page=2 SAR9 is built like a tank. Polishing the internals makes for an extremely smooth trigger pull. Grip is very VP9 like. |
DUPE police are Karens.
|
Originally Posted By erazor55: SAR9 is built like a tank. Polishing the internals makes for an extremely smooth trigger pull. Grip is very VP9 like. Originally Posted By erazor55: Originally Posted By Capt_Destro: Just something I stumbled across last year. IIRC the back plate was plastic with no reinforcement. From what I read the striker channel design doesn't have any other openings iirc? So this made the pressure from the kaboom a bit worse than other handguns. I could be wrong on that. If I had to go Turkish I'd go with a different model imo. Girsan makes some decent stuff as long as it's a M9 or 1911 clone. @OP I'd get the Canik or Sarsilmaz SAR9 on a budger if you are buying Turkish. For budget American brands: PSA Dagger, S&W SDVE/Ruger Double Stack/Beretta APX for a cheap 9mm. https://www.ar15.com/forums/general/Turkish-handgun-kaboom-Have-we-done-this-yet-/5-2435458/&page=2 SAR9 is built like a tank. Polishing the internals makes for an extremely smooth trigger pull. Grip is very VP9 like. Seriously think they would of hit a home run if it took Glock Magazines. It's pretty much a Glock frame with a VP9 Grip, that takes metal mags, which aint a bad thing I guess. Also noticed is has some Canik Esque Aesthetics. It's a very nice looking pistol. Just wish it wasn't Turkish I heard OEM ones could be a bit pricy. But you can adapt other mags to it such as Canik, and even Sig mags with a cut out. Havent purchased one but I've been doing some reading on them. |
|
Originally Posted By MisterPX: Did you miss the part where the striker is in dude's eye? Did you even read my post. Yeah, I did see that pic. I do not believe that pistol merely came apart at the back plate on the slide. A large part of the right side of the frame is missing. Indicative to me of a more serious failure. THAT IS WHY I ASKED FOR MORE DETAILS. Did you miss that in the picture? |
One well at a time, Drill Baby Drill!
If you need more than 8 rounds in a 1911 to solve your problem, you need friends with rifles.
I don't need your PERMISSION in order to voice my OPINION
If you need more than 8 rounds in a 1911 to solve your problem, you need friends with rifles.
I don't need your PERMISSION in order to voice my OPINION
|
Originally Posted By 44-40pro: Did you even read my post. Yeah, I did see that pic. I do not believe that pistol merely came apart at the back plate on the slide. A large part of the right side of the frame is missing. Indicative to me of a more serious failure. THAT IS WHY I ASKED FOR MORE DETAILS. Did you miss that in the picture? Originally Posted By 44-40pro: Originally Posted By MisterPX: Did you miss the part where the striker is in dude's eye? Did you even read my post. Yeah, I did see that pic. I do not believe that pistol merely came apart at the back plate on the slide. A large part of the right side of the frame is missing. Indicative to me of a more serious failure. THAT IS WHY I ASKED FOR MORE DETAILS. Did you miss that in the picture? I think it happened in Turkey so we'll never really know. But like it's speculated it was a double charge/bad ammo. An aluminum slide plate could of prevented the striker assembly shooting out, or even a reinforced one glock uses. Never understood why companies will cheap out on a $5 part |
|
Originally Posted By 44-40pro: Did you even read my post. Yeah, I did see that pic. I do not believe that pistol merely came apart at the back plate on the slide. A large part of the right side of the frame is missing. Indicative to me of a more serious failure. THAT IS WHY I ASKED FOR MORE DETAILS. Did you miss that in the picture? "Looks like there was a kaboom since the side of the frame is missing. " That's why I mentioned the striker in the eye. Enough pressure to blow through the breechface via the striker. |
Seriously, a tractor dealer from Possum Trot, KY has to explain this to you, a lawyer? - JPL
WTB: Glock 17 gen 2. SN CAF 895
WTB: Glock 17 gen 2. SN CAF 895
Joined:
Sep 2022
Posts:
17
EE: 0% (0)
IL, USA
|
Originally Posted By Lin1958: Thanks for the input everyone! Definitely don't need a striker in the eye, yet that has to be something with the ammo. Still not sure, might go Canik for a tad more of more likely wait on it. Canik, even the base models are amazing for their money. They are more or less Walther's at heart, so you can't really go wrong with a clone of a reputable firearm. They even have a model that mimics the whole DA/SA setup of the Walther P99/S&W SW99. Or you can just go with the glock-ish version. |
|
It is more of a M&P clone. My advice is to pass. I purchased 2 of these(1 full size &1 compcact ) when Zenith with the importer and was selling them super cheap. I sold both. Look for a used or new SAR9 it is everything Glock is and everything Glock wishes it could be. It is internally a glock with the externals of a HK. |
|
Originally Posted By Lin1958: Thanks for the input everyone! Definitely don't need a striker in the eye, yet that has to be something with the ammo. Still not sure, might go Canik for a tad more of more likely wait on it. I can tell you the Canik’s are nice pistols, but the price has been creeping up on them and I don’t know they they are as worth it now. I’m still curious about the Sars and the Girsans since they haven’t quite “arrived” yet like Canik has. |
|
Originally Posted By mikebaker1129: Where? |
Call the tune and let's dance; but beware that the devil is the piper and the tab for that soiree will be hell to pay.
Training&Trigger Time are more important than chasing a hardware Holy Grail
Training&Trigger Time are more important than chasing a hardware Holy Grail
|
Originally Posted By Aggie_Gunner: $250 PSA Daggers have drastically changed my opinion of what constitutes a good deal in a polymer, striker fired pistol… Why even try anything else? That is where I am now. At that price point and an American pro-2A company, why go elsewhere? Still, that Canik on consignment was cheaper.............
|
Call the tune and let's dance; but beware that the devil is the piper and the tab for that soiree will be hell to pay.
Training&Trigger Time are more important than chasing a hardware Holy Grail
Training&Trigger Time are more important than chasing a hardware Holy Grail