Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
4/30/2025 3:31:14 PM EDT
I went to Italy last year and enjoyed a few cigarillos.  

I just tried a Macanudo Maduro that was good.

I used to enjoy Montecristo, but COVID raise my pallet for bite/spice.

I will say I enjoy that lingering taste as much, or more, than smoking itself.

I don't want any flavored cigarillos

ACID makes then.  I tried Red and it's ok, but tastes flavored

Any suggestions for brands and sticks to try.
4/30/2025 3:38:21 PM EDT
[#1]
Drew Estates Undercrown Maduros. They’re my work “cigar” so I don’t have to dump a robusto if something fun comes up
4/30/2025 4:24:04 PM EDT
[#2]
The Cohiba black are Maduros that are decently “full body” and smoke nicely for 15-20 minutes.  

4/30/2025 5:00:47 PM EDT
[#3]
Originally Posted By Kiltakaze:
Drew Estates Undercrown Maduros. They’re my work “cigar” so I don’t have to dump a robusto if something fun comes up
View Quote

Originally Posted By GlockPride:
The Cohiba black are Maduros that are decently “full body” and smoke nicely for 15-20 minutes.  

View Quote

Dang guys.  the shop had BOTH of those and I passed.  I was really tempted by the COHIBA.  The undercrown they didn't have in Cigarillos, but I'll keep looking.

Thanks for the start
5/1/2025 11:17:53 AM EDT
[Last Edit: baize82][Edited] [#4]
I assume you're looking for shorter smokes, so I'll at least mention these, even though they're not all cigarillos

HVC Hot Cake half corona 3.5 x 44 - the regular Hot Cake is San Andres, they also make the Golden Line in that size which has a CT wrapper
Davidoff Winston Churchill and Winston Churchill Late Hour petite panatela - 4 x 38 and they come in tins
Davidoff makes several of their lines in a cigarillo size also
Drew Estate Papas Fritas - 4 1/2 x 44 - way too big to be a cigarillo, but they're mixed fill so they burn pretty quick
Drew Estate Liga Privada coronets - 4 x 32 - you can get them in No. 9 or T52 blends
Perdomo Champagne Puritos - 4 x 38 - its a Perdomo Champagne, nothing more needs to be said
2 Guys Cigars has a house brand called Dos Hombres, and they offer a 4 1/2 x 30 in tins, with natural or maduro wrapper, in their Dominican line. They won't blow your skirt up, but they're cheap lol - $80 for 50, 5 tins of 10
5/1/2025 1:16:32 PM EDT
[#5]
Quote History
Originally Posted By Kiltakaze:
Drew Estates Undercrown Maduros. They’re my work “cigar” so I don’t have to dump a robusto if something fun comes up
View Quote

They had the Sun Grown version...I didn't care for it much.  He said it was a bit lighter than the Maduro, but it tasted bitter to me.  Taste is so subjective and COVID really jacked things up with my taste buds.  I can now eat jalapenos without my tongue burning, but I sweat bullets  

I wonder if I'll like the Undercrown Maduros better.  I might have to grab a full size version to try, then order shorter online if I can
5/1/2025 1:41:18 PM EDT
[#6]
Quote History
Originally Posted By GlockPride:
The Cohiba black are Maduros that are decently “full body” and smoke nicely for 15-20 minutes.  

View Quote

Ugh...these were the most expensive, so I balked.  Probably have to go back and try them
5/1/2025 3:54:59 PM EDT
[#7]
So these are what I had in Italy and I found some locally to try again.  I like these and they're simple to acquire.  They're a bit long, but thin. 1/2 hour only gets me about half way through. I like that they're not symmetrical.  Kinda like smoking an actual stick   They aren't very complex either, so I might just cut them.

Still open and trying others.

Toscano Antico
5/1/2025 5:30:18 PM EDT
[#8]
Quote History
Originally Posted By SwiftyMorgan:
So these are what I had in Italy and I found some locally to try again.  I like these and they're simple to acquire.  They're a bit long, but thin. 1/2 hour only gets me about half way through. I like that they're not symmetrical.  Kinda like smoking an actual stick   They aren't very complex either, so I might just cut them.

Still open and trying others.

Toscano Antico
View Quote


Take your cutter and cut them in half. They’re not like “regular” cigars that will explode if you try that. The Toscano stuff is excellent btw
5/1/2025 8:00:37 PM EDT
[#9]
Quote History
Originally Posted By baize82:


Take your cutter and cut them in half. They’re not like “regular” cigars that will explode if you try that. The Toscano stuff is excellent btw
View Quote

Yep.  I actually cut one after smoking it a bit.  Might not be good, but I didn't see any burn down the center.

Next time I'll cut it beforehand
5/2/2025 12:16:49 AM EDT
[#10]
Quote History
Originally Posted By SwiftyMorgan:

Yep.  I actually cut one after smoking it a bit.  Might not be good, but I didn't see any burn down the center.

Next time I'll cut it beforehand
View Quote


Another cool thing about the Toscano stuff, they don’t really require humidification. You can chuck a sleeve in your glovebox for an emergency smoke.
5/6/2025 8:00:49 PM EDT
[Last Edit: SwiftyMorgan][Edited] [#11]
Quote History
Originally Posted By baize82:


Another cool thing about the Toscano stuff, they don’t really require humidification. You can chuck a sleeve in your glovebox for an emergency smoke.
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Quote History
Originally Posted By baize82:
Originally Posted By SwiftyMorgan:

Yep.  I actually cut one after smoking it a bit.  Might not be good, but I didn't see any burn down the center.

Next time I'll cut it beforehand


Another cool thing about the Toscano stuff, they don’t really require humidification. You can chuck a sleeve in your glovebox for an emergency smoke.

No kidding.  You're exactly right about that. I brought a couple back with me and just left the in a drawer and they were fine.  I do keep them in a desktop humidor now, but they're nice for the golf bag.

I also ordered some COA Brazilia.  Couldn't find any locally and I recall really liking those
5/16/2025 1:05:43 PM EDT
[#12]
Bandidos
Backwoods

Are nice and cheap.


5/18/2025 2:43:26 AM EDT
[#13]
They're not cigarillo size, just a bit bigger in corona size, but Man O' War Puro Authentico are phenomenal.
6/6/2025 3:29:28 PM EDT
[#14]
If your still looking, Amazon basin daggers 4x38 are just coming out that are supposed to be 🔥.

Sign up to continue the discussion

Create a free account to share your thoughts, follow topics, and connect with the AR15.COM community.

Already a member? Sign In