Posted: 6/16/2020 8:30:02 PM EDT
|
Like the title says. I have begun to get extremely interested in the Civil War. I spent the most of my adult life reading about Modern Warfare especially around World War II Korea and Vietnam. Oddly enough the History Channel 3 part series on Grant got me interested. That and the movie Gettysburg. I've already read the book The Killer Angels. I am mostly interested in books about the campaigns and those that led them. |
Hansan: "This is a .30 caliber, gas operated, clip fed, semi-automatic rifle....."
Soldier: "Look, you ain't sellin it to me, you're only showing me how it works."
Soldier: "Look, you ain't sellin it to me, you're only showing me how it works."
Veteran of the Third Battle of Tannhauser Gate.
Joined:
Dec 2005
Posts:
68062
EE: 100% (6)
ID, USA
|
Originally Posted By Terlinguachili: The Personal Memoir of U S Grant is considered to be some of the finest writing in US history.. Best memoir from the Union side. For the Confederate equivalent: Edward Porter Alexander's Military Memoirs of a Confederate and then his private work intended only for his immediate family, Fighting For the Confederacy. For a soldier's view: John Billings' Hard Tack and Coffee John Worshams' One of Jackson's Foot Cavalry. - this book got me hooked on reading the CW. I read a bunch of CW books before this one really reeled me in. Wyman White's The Civil War Diary of Wyman White - the best memoir by a Berdan Sharp Shooter Berry Benson The Civil War Memoirs of Berry Benson - best Confederate memoir by a rebel sharp shooter For a general's view: James Longstreet From Manassas to Appomattox - good memoir by a leading Confederate general. Be sure to have a map. Longstreet served at Manassas, was sent down to Suffolk (Virginia and was absent from Fredericksburg II/Chancellorsville), fought at Gettysburg and then his corps was sent to the Army of Tennessee and fought at Chickamugua, then up north to Knoxville where he failed to capture that city, then rejoined Lee until the end of the war. Regis de Trobriand Four Years in the Army of the Potomac. Rose from colonel to maj. general and was a col. in the post war army. Very insightful. For an officer's view: Francis Adam Donaldson Inside The Army of the Potomac For a modern historian perspective of the average soldier: Bell Irving Wiley's The Life of Billy Yank and The Life of Johnny Reb Gary Gallagher's books. Robert Krick - The Smoothbore Volley That Doomed the Confederacy Want to learn about the Myth of the Lost Cause? |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
|
The Shelby Foote books are a tour de force. Excellent way to get started in Civil War history. He spent some 25 years of his life putting it all together. He was a novelist and his writing style makes his books an easy read. "Company Aytch" by Sam Watkins is a great read. He fought for the south. His view of the war is strictly what he saw from where he was. It is a look at the war from an individual level and dose not bother with grand strategies of battle plans etc. Plenty of interesting commentary along the way. Ken Burns documentary on the Civil War is also very good. |
|
Sneden's The Eye of the Storm. Private soldier in the Army of the Potomac, later captured and imprisoned at Andersonville. He did a lot of illustrations that were reproduced in the book. Elisha Hunt Rhodes. All For the Union. Another great account by a private soldier. Used by Ken Burns in his series. William Fletcher Rebel Private, Front and Rear Another great account given by a Confederate soldier. John B. Gordon Reminiscences of the Civil War. Rose from commanding the Raccoon Roughs to Corps Command. Heavily biased towards reconstruction, but valuable resource and good reading. |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
| Awesome! Thank you guys I just got in today the Shelby Foote series. Getting ready to crawl into bed and do a little light reading with volume one |
Hansan: "This is a .30 caliber, gas operated, clip fed, semi-automatic rifle....."
Soldier: "Look, you ain't sellin it to me, you're only showing me how it works."
Soldier: "Look, you ain't sellin it to me, you're only showing me how it works."
|
I couldn't read Foote's books. It's me, not Foote. For mainstream historian, I enjoyed journalist Bruce Catton's Army of the Potomac trilogy (Mr. Lincoln's Army, The Glory Road, A Stillness at Appomattox). I also enjoyed Catton's books on Grant (it was a trilogy started by Lloyd Lewis with Capt. Sam Grant but after Lewis died, Catton picked it up and using the notes and information provided by Lewis' widow, finished it with Grant Moves South and Grant Takes Command). |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
|
Grant's memoirs is a very good description of the strategy used to win the war. Confederates in the Attic is fairly amusing, even though it's not a historical book. Porter Alexander's memoirs is also very good. |
"It is not enough to simply beat Trump. He must be destroyed thoroughly. His kind must not rise again." - David Plouffe
“God has a special providence for fools, drunkards, and the United States of America.” - Otto von Bismarck
“God has a special providence for fools, drunkards, and the United States of America.” - Otto von Bismarck
|
May have a slant on some things, the companion book to the Ken Burns PBS series on the Civil War is good, but may not be as in depth you are looking for. Also look up the various national battlefields during the Civil War. They usually have a bookstore section with locally written and published research focusing on the particular battles and participants. Then look on eBay or thriftbooks.com for the used books titles you are looking for. |
| National Park Bookstores' books are generally those screened by the rangers for accuracy. |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Rebel yell was the last I read! I really liked it. I have been twice stone wall Jackson and lees graves in Lexington Virginia. Jackson’s house tour was interesting. The chapel where lees office and grave is not to be missed. I have spent many weeks touring civil war sites in Virginia while on vacation. So much history in Virginia. I hope they don’t tear down everything before I can pass that way again. 
|
I dont know If you know, but I am a big deal
Joined:
Jun 2010
Posts:
12430
EE: 100% (5)
USA
|
Originally Posted By FrankSymptoms: Shelby Foote has an exhaustive 3-volume set about the entire CW: "The Civil War: A Narrative." He is awesome. |
Every citizen should be a soldier. This was the case with the Greeks and Romans, and must be that of every free state.
-Thomas Jefferson
-Thomas Jefferson
|
Originally Posted By ruger556boy: He is awesome. Originally Posted By ruger556boy: Originally Posted By FrankSymptoms: Shelby Foote has an exhaustive 3-volume set about the entire CW: "The Civil War: A Narrative." He is awesome. I had trouble reading Foote and gave up. I prefer Joseph Glatthaar's style of writing. I've got his book Soldiering In the Army of Northern Virginia as well h The March to the Sea and Beyond. Both are highly recommended. Didn't read his Forged In Battle about the so called alliance between white officers and the colored men they led. I've only ready about a few colored troops (54, 55 Mass and the 1st and 3rd LA Native Guards at Port Hudson) and I did read about a colored artillery unit (Rhode Island) and all that book discussed were the activities of the white officer. Not a word about the men. The post-Civil War book, Under Fire about the Tenth US Cavalry (regulars) was much better. |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Attack & die is one of the best if you are looking for wisdom as a soldier or warrior  link to attack & die as a historian I would recommend starting in the Great awakening of the 1820s. Prohibition, Zionism, feminism, & abolitionism all sprang forth from the large number of protestant churches created in America in the 1820s-m1830.s the roots for just about all the nations' success & failures lie inside the great awakening ideals.and how those ideals played out. |
|
Best single volume work on the war is "The Story of the Confederacy" by Robert S. Henry It is the book with which one begins the subject and the book to which you will return after you have read all else on the subject. - Bruce Catton |
"No clause in the Constitution could by any rule of construction be conceived to give to congress a power to disarm the people." William Rawle
| David Holt's A Mississippi Rebel in the Army of Northern Virginia. It has one of the most intense accounts of the Bloody Angle at Spotsylvania Court House. |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
|
The formation of the Confederate States of America by the people of the South through their secession conventions was the greatest expression of democracy and self-government in the history of the world. How could it not be? Millions of people in a land mass as great as Europe rose up in state after state and invoked Thomas Jefferson, Patrick Henry, George Washington and others of their Revolutionary sires. There were only 85 years between 1776 and 1861. The Revolution and Declaration of Independence were still fresh in the minds and hearts of Southerners. From a book The Confederate States of America: 1861 Was 1776 All Over by Gene Kizer, Jr. |
|
I live in Appomattox Co. In Virginia, we are surrounded by American history. It's a bit of a ride for you but a few days visiting battlefields is a worthy endeavor. Not Civil War-related but I got a chance to visit Patrick Henry's Red Hill and talk to his 6x Great-grandson on Sat. I've been researching the location of where he lived nearby after he left the Governor's office. Yep, I'm a History Nerd. As far as books, I enjoy reading first-person accounts rather than looking through a present-day lens. |
|
Originally Posted By GLOCKshooter: What's good on Audible? I'm doing a lot of driving lately. Team of Rivals by Doris Goodwin. It's about Lincoln's cabinet. |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
| I spoke with Lt. Col. Tom McKenney once and asked for clarification about the bullet. We also spoke about Maj. Walter Walsh who was capt. of the shooting team and his boss once. |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
|
John Hebrich's Masters of the Field about the 4th US Cavalry is easily the best cavalry book I've read to understand the life of a cavalryman and cavalry operations. Forrest hated them. ETA: Edward Hamilton bookseller has this hardcover book at less than $10! |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
|
I didn't see how old this threat was. Please excuse the double tap. here's another good book: The Young Volunteer, by Joseph E. Crowell. It chronicles the experiences of an ordinary soldier in the 13th New Jersey Volunteer Regiment. |
If you don’t see the irony of a gun ban being enforced by men with guns, then you fail to understand why the 2nd amendment was written in the first place - Kevin Sorbo
|
Originally Posted By ChickenDaddy: On audible i am currently reading “rebel yell” and find it engaging. I started jack hinsons war and gave up 4-5 hours in. I get very discouraged reading about all the mistakes and losses suffered by the South. To be fair, Jack Hinsons story gets good in the second half. The first part lays the groundwork and the logistics. The second half explains how bad ass Jack Hinson actually was. |
|
Theodre Upson's With Sherman to the Sea: The Civil War Letters, Diaries & Reminisces of Theodore F. Upson |
#53 says, "Take 22 mg absorbed Vit C per lb plus 1 gram Chaga daily. Don't forget 2000iu Vit D-3, 30 mg Zinc and 2 mg Cu."
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
Unfettered with the formalities of an economics education but well read in monetary history.
|
https://www.amazon.com/Co-Aytch-First-Tennessee-Regiment/dp/1577363825 
|
NRA Life Member
USPSA-IPSC
Phuc cancer
I liked this place a lot better when it was a gun forum.
USPSA-IPSC
Phuc cancer
I liked this place a lot better when it was a gun forum.
|
I worked with a guy who was a Civil War fanatic, he knew every battle, the strategy behind it, why it was fought, statistics of the battles....he was a wealth of knowledge....he passed away about 5 years ago....real nice guy |
When I was once asked to explain the concept of entropy....I thought about it and said: "You can't unscramble an egg...." 77Bronc, 1981