Armory Sponsor
Posted: 5/5/2024 11:47:23 AM EDT
|
Any thoughts on using the old salt/vinegar/peroxide formula on a non stainless gun barrel? Would embrittlement actually be a concern on this? |
|
OK, so I asked my favorite AI girlfriend if hydrogen embrittlement was a problem when rust bluing with hydrogen peroxide, and she said it was a potential problem. So if it concerns you, you could always use one of the traditional nitric acid based rust bluing solutions. Probably easiest to just obtain one of the proprietary solutions readily available, as it is difficult to obtain small quantities of nitric acid. They are expensive however. Seems like they went way up since I bought my last bottle. Just another example of transitory inflation, I suppose. Supposedly, heating to 300F will remove some of the hydrogen. Usually, steel will not be affected by that low of a temperature, but it might be if you went higher. What exactly are you trying to rust blue? That might be important. |
|
Originally Posted By grendelbane: OK, so I asked my favorite AI girlfriend if hydrogen embrittlement was a problem when rust bluing with hydrogen peroxide, and she said it was a potential problem. So if it concerns you, you could always use one of the traditional nitric acid based rust bluing solutions. Probably easiest to just obtain one of the proprietary solutions readily available, as it is difficult to obtain small quantities of nitric acid. They are expensive however. Seems like they went way up since I bought my last bottle. Just another example of transitory inflation, I suppose. Supposedly, heating to 300F will remove some of the hydrogen. Usually, steel will not be affected by that low of a temperature, but it might be if you went higher. What exactly are you trying to rust blue? That might be important. Picked up a (presumed 4140) rifle barrel in the white ,30 odd years ago. I'm thinking about rebarrelling a shot out one with it. Pretty much a weekend boredom project. Nothing critical but I also dont want it crack 10 years down the road due to chemistry issues. |
|
Originally Posted By Abearir: Picked up a (presumed 4140) rifle barrel in the white ,30 odd years ago. I'm thinking about rebarrelling a shot out one with it. Pretty much a weekend boredom project. Nothing critical but I also dont want it crack 10 years down the road due to chemistry issues. I would go right ahead. I can't see a problem with that. The interior of the barrel is where strength is required, and that doesn't even come in contact with the rusting solution. |
|
Hydrogen embrittlement is not usually super concerning with gun barrels, the reason being they are not that hard. Time is of the essence when baking to remove atomic hydrogen, which nullifies its effectiveness when you are taking about a slow process like rust bluing (waiting a long time to make it after exposure to acid isn't going to help you). Exposing harder quenched & tempered steel (martensitic) components to acids or to temperatures in the range of approximately 400F to 1000F is not advisable. |
Armory Sponsor