AR Sponsor
Posted: 3/5/2009 10:58:43 AM EDT
[Last Edit: Molon][Edited]
Member of the General Population
|
Originally Posted By R6731:
Molon, Good to see the information on this load. Once again, your efforts are very much appreciated. Thank You. The thanks all goes to Dr. Roberts. He was gracious enough to offer to test this load. |
Member of the General Population
Member of the General Population
| I have ordered some of this PPU 75 from Wideners. I haven't received it yet, but how do I tell if it's 2007 or 2008 vintage? |
I pledge allegiance to the constitution of the United States of America and to the Republic which it defines. One nation, many peoples, with liberty and justice for all.
|
So 2007 Prvi 75 was tested by DocGKR?
It seems the frag test indicates that the ammo is better than M193-type rounds for self-defense (especially given the amazingly short neck length of 0.8 in., and 60% fragmentation). What would you say, Molon? I guess we can assume that this ammo would be even more effective from a 20" barrel. |
|
Yeah, I'd love to know how to differentiate the sloooow '07 ammo from the faster '08 75-gr OTM lots. The boxes appear the same and so do the bullets. Any ideas out there on how to tell 'em apart?
I would also like to see how fast the newer 69-gr PRVI OTM ammo is compared to the 75-gr OTM stuff. I think Molon has that one on the radar screen for testing in the Spring when the weather breaks up in MI, but I'd like to get some info before the price goes up or they run out of stock and would really like to know what I'm getting. Seems like no one has any info on the PRVI 69-gr OTM ammo, other than it kills hogs effectively as per another post. |
|
To tell which lot you have you just have to look at the strip of paper thats in each box of ammo. Its gives the year month and inspector number. For example it would say 0803 63 meaning 2008/03 inspector 63
Anyway the new hotter lots look to be on par with TAP FPD or Black Hills 75gr. From my personal testing it seems that Prvi 75gr and Black Hills 75gr shoot to the same point of impact at 50 yards. |
|
Originally Posted By BushMeister:
It seems the frag test indicates that the ammo is better than M193-type rounds for self-defense (especially given the amazingly short neck length of 0.8 in., and 60% fragmentation). What would you say, Molon? You pretty much answered this question for yourself. The ballistic neck of M193 is typically about six times longer than that of the Prvi round. This aspect alone, gives the Prvi load greatly superior terminal ballistic properties compared to M193. |
Member of the General Population
|
Originally Posted By phoenix27:
Yeah, I'd love to know how to differentiate the sloooow '07 ammo from the faster '08 75-gr OTM lots. The boxes appear the same and so do the bullets. Any ideas out there on how to tell 'em apart? I would also like to see how fast the newer 69-gr PRVI OTM ammo is compared to the 75-gr OTM stuff. I think Molon has that one on the radar screen for testing in the Spring when the weather breaks up in MI, but I'd like to get some info before the price goes up or they run out of stock and would really like to know what I'm getting. Seems like no one has any info on the PRVI 69-gr OTM ammo, other than it kills hogs effectively as per another post. When you open the box of ammo, there is a piece of paper in the right hand side of the box (when facing the front) that says what the lot number is. The first two numbers are the year of the lot number. 2007 is going to start with 07xx, and 2008 is going to start with 08xx. That's the easiest way to tell. |
|
hmm, tempting.
Has a full range/accuracy report been done on this yet? Is this "match" ammo actually "match" quality, aka sub MOA capable? ETA - answered my own question http://www.ar15.com/forums/topic.html?b=3&f=16&t=372350 |
I'll try to kick your ass and fail.
Joined:
Mar 2008
Posts:
2686
EE: 100% (60)
|
Originally Posted By BadassWeakling:
Originally Posted By Molon:
Originally Posted By BushMeister:
It seems the frag test indicates that the ammo is better than M193-type rounds for self-defense (especially given the amazingly short neck length of 0.8 in., and 60% fragmentation). What would you say, Molon? You pretty much answered this question for yourself. The ballistic neck of M193 is typically about six times longer than that of the Prvi round. This aspect alone, gives the Prvi load greatly superior terminal ballistic properties compared to M193. http://ammo.ar15.com/ammo/project/ammoOraclePics/m193.jpg The above M-193 chart seems to be using centimeters instead of inches. Remember that ~2.2 cm = 1 inch. Now use this chart provided by DocGKR to interpret the data he also provided. http://www.tridentconcepts.com/alumni/Portals/0/NTForums_Attach/1424105328171.jpg Originally Posted By Molon:
penetration in bare ballistic gel: 12.6" neck length: 0.8” maximum temporary cavity: 3.2” at a depth of 4.7” recovered diameter: 0.36” recovered length: 0.15” recovered weight: 30.1gr percentage of fragmentation: 60% I prefer visual representation of information If anyone had the picture of 77 Gr or 75 gr fragnmentation handy, it would be much appreciated NATO pressure Nosler 77 grain OTM from a 20" barrel
courtesy of Dr. G.K. Roberts SAAMI pressure Hornady 75 grain OTM from a 16" barrel
courtesy of Dr. G.K. Roberts |
Member of the General Population
|
Originally Posted By QuicksilverJPR:
Originally Posted By cerberus212:
Do all 08 lots have the faster velocities? I have several hundred 0803 and a 1000 of 0808, just curious if I will see any large velocity difference between them. Those are both 2008 lot numbers... It depends, even the best ammo mfgs have small lot to lot variations. I guess its just another thing to test. |
I'll try to kick your ass and fail.
Joined:
Mar 2008
Posts:
2912
EE: 100% (60)
|
Originally Posted By Molon: NATO pressure Nosler 77 grain OTM from a 20" barrel http://home.comcast.net/~gocartmozart/NATO_pressure_Nosler_77_OTM_gel_shot_from_20_inch_barrel.jpg courtesy of Dr. G.K. Roberts SAAMI pressure Hornady 75 grain OTM from a 16" barrel http://home.comcast.net/~gocartmozart/SAMMI_pressure_Hornady_75_gel_shot_from_16_inch_barrel.jpg courtesy of Dr. G.K. Roberts Beautiful, thanks! |
Member of the General Population
I'll try to kick your ass and fail.
Joined:
Mar 2008
Posts:
2914
EE: 100% (60)
Member of the General Population
| Does the Doc give any indication of wether the bullet yaws before fragmenting or expand like a soft point staying nose forward. All the info from hog hunters, the photo from the water jug test and other reports up till now has led me to beleive the bullet is acting as a soft point and expanding rather than yawing and fragmenting. The short neck length also indicates the bullet may be acting as an expansion rnd. I've finally got my hands on a couple of boxes and will do a back yard test in wet news print and report here soon. The news print gives a difinitive view of a bullet yawing so I can see if it yaws or expands. |
|
Originally Posted By HP40:
Does the Doc give any indication of wether the bullet yaws before fragmenting or expand like a soft point staying nose forward. All the info from hog hunters, the photo from the water jug test and other reports up till now has led me to beleive the bullet is acting as a soft point and expanding rather than yawing and fragmenting. The short neck length also indicates the bullet may be acting as an expansion rnd. I've finally got my hands on a couple of boxes and will do a back yard test in wet news print and report here soon. The news print gives a difinitive view of a bullet yawing so I can see if it yaws or expands. When I shot news-print with T2 it just punched a massive hole. I could not tell you what happened definitively. It just blew a hole the size of my fist into it after about 1-2". |
Every ripple has the potential to become a tidal wave.
|
Originally Posted By 12_gauge:
Originally Posted By HP40:
Does the Doc give any indication of wether the bullet yaws before fragmenting or expand like a soft point staying nose forward. All the info from hog hunters, the photo from the water jug test and other reports up till now has led me to beleive the bullet is acting as a soft point and expanding rather than yawing and fragmenting. The short neck length also indicates the bullet may be acting as an expansion rnd. I've finally got my hands on a couple of boxes and will do a back yard test in wet news print and report here soon. The news print gives a difinitive view of a bullet yawing so I can see if it yaws or expands. When I shot news-print with T2 it just punched a massive hole. I could not tell you what happened definitively. It just blew a hole the size of my fist into it after about 1-2". Maybe my definitive test won't won't be so definitive after all, I know know my tests of various M193 and M855 rnds all showed the yaw very clearly as the bullet profile shape of the hole prior to the main wound cavity.The only soft points I've tested were Remington 55 gr. PSP wich showed expansion begining at 1" and being fully expanded at 2" wich was the begining of a massive cavity extending to 6" with 11" total penetration. I've always been impressed with how closely wet newsprint corrosponds to ballistic gel though I've heard of deviations others have had. |
|
Originally Posted By Molon: Originally Posted By HP40: Does the Doc give any indication of wether the bullet yaws before fragmenting or expand like a soft point staying nose forward. The Doc stated, "They yaw, then fragment." (He's not one to waste words.) You're right, he's pretty quiet most of the time. |
|
Originally Posted By Molon: Originally Posted By phoenix27: Molon- Very graphic stuff...I guess the picture really is worth 1,000-words, thanks. Hey, did you ever get a chance to test out the 69-gr OTM Prvi or the corbon 5.56mm 69 and 77-gr SMK ammo? Those results would be very intriguing. phoenix27 It was in the 50s here this week, so we're getting closer. http://www.box.net/shared/static/v7004ph42k.jpg http://www.box.net/shared/static/70h027aae4.jpg We just got clobbered with blizzard-like snow and sleet I'm looking forward to the 69gr Privi test [and warmer weather!] |
Once killed a man for snoring too loud
~ John Wesley Hardin
Here lies Lester Moore
Four slugs from a .44
No Les No Moore.
~Tombstone grave epitaph
~ John Wesley Hardin
Here lies Lester Moore
Four slugs from a .44
No Les No Moore.
~Tombstone grave epitaph
|
Originally Posted By Rampant_Colt:
Originally Posted By Molon:
Originally Posted By phoenix27:
Molon- Very graphic stuff...I guess the picture really is worth 1,000-words, thanks. Hey, did you ever get a chance to test out the 69-gr OTM Prvi or the corbon 5.56mm 69 and 77-gr SMK ammo? Those results would be very intriguing. phoenix27 It was in the 50s here this week, so we're getting closer. http://www.box.net/shared/static/v7004ph42k.jpg http://www.box.net/shared/static/70h027aae4.jpg We just got clobbered with blizzard-like snow and sleet I'm looking forward to the 69gr Privi test [and warmer weather!] It's in the 60's today, so it should be sometime soon. |
Member of the General Population
|
Originally Posted By cowboy7242001:
Great results, thanks for posting! But geez...you'd think they could get it to fly a little faster. they probably could I bet they did it to keep the presures well with in the safe range of 223. MK262 dose a bit faster than this I think but I hear it's considered a fairly hot load as well. |
|
Originally Posted By Molon:
Originally Posted By Rampant_Colt:
Originally Posted By Molon:
Originally Posted By phoenix27:
Molon- Very graphic stuff...I guess the picture really is worth 1,000-words, thanks. Hey, did you ever get a chance to test out the 69-gr OTM Prvi or the corbon 5.56mm 69 and 77-gr SMK ammo? Those results would be very intriguing. phoenix27 It was in the 50s here this week, so we're getting closer. http://www.box.net/shared/static/v7004ph42k.jpg http://www.box.net/shared/static/70h027aae4.jpg We just got clobbered with blizzard-like snow and sleet I'm looking forward to the 69gr Privi test [and warmer weather!] It's in the 60's today, so it should be sometime soon. Molon- You're such a tease, ha-ha. |
|
Originally Posted By fdkay:
Originally Posted By chapperjoe:
thanks! Question: Isn't 13" perfect? Perfect? I guess it depends. Are you shooting a 6 foot, 135 lb emaciated turd or a 6 foot, 550 lb fat ass. In one case 13" might be to much in another 13" might not be enough. Which is why you want lots of penetration with a short neck before yaw/fragmentation. |
"You underestimate my ability to handle the Cock." - BUCC_Guy
| got it, I though the 'goal' of a good round was 13-18 inches |
There is but one truth in the world and it is all yours. If you are not sure of it stay at home; but if you are sure don't look back and it will be your way.
Honored to be a "Proud Member of Ranstad's Militia"
Honored to be a "Proud Member of Ranstad's Militia"
AR Sponsor














